Skip to Content

‘Delusional’ report on Russian hacking in Ukraine

The cyber-security company Crowdstrike has claimed that "Russia" hacked artillery units of the Ukrainian army, but the claim is completely baseless and false. The Crowdstrike report, released in December, asserted that the hack into a Ukrainian artillery app, resulted in heavy losses of howitzers in Ukraine’s war against the Donbass.

Published: March 23, 2017, 9:48 am

    Read more

    The company led by a one Dimitry Alperovich, a Senior Fellow of the NATO-aligned think tank the Atlantic Council, found “evidence” of involvement by Russian intelligence services.

    In interviews, Alperovitch had linked Ukraine and Democratic campaign hacks, which Crowdstrike declared had involved the same Russian hacking group, Fancy Bear, and versions of X-Agent malware the group was known to use.

    Crowdstrike investigators had claimed that the artillery units of the Ukrainian army had had “excessive combat losses” of up to 80 percent in their fight with Donbass separatists.

    The company asserted that Russian intelligence “hacked” an application used by the Ukrainians to aim their guns. The hack, it was claimed, enabled well targeted counter-fire that then destroyed the Ukrainian artillery.

    “The fact that they would be tracking and helping the Russian military kill Ukrainian army personnel in eastern Ukraine and also intervening in the US election is quite chilling,” Alperovitch told The Washington Post on December 22.

    The same day, Alperovitch told the PBS NewsHour: “And when you think about, well, who would be interested in targeting Ukraine artillerymen in eastern Ukraine?” suggesting again that Russians were responsible.

    “It’s pretty high confidence that Fancy Bear had to be in touch with the Russian military,” Dmitri Alperovich told Forbes. “This is exactly what the mission is of the GRU.”

    Crowdstrike had based its numbers for “excessive losses” of Ukrainian artillery units on statistics collected by the International Institute for Strategic Studies (IISS). The IISS now says that its statistic do not provide what Crowdstrike claimed. There were no “excessive losses” of Ukrainian artillery.

    The IISS told Voice of America that Crowdstrike had erroneously used IISS data as proof of such an intrusion. IISS has disavowed any connection to the Crowdstrike report.

    “The Crowdstrike report uses our data, but the inferences and analysis drawn from that data belong solely to the report’s authors,” the IISS said. “The inference they make that reductions in Ukrainian D-30 artillery holdings between 2013 and 2016 were primarily the result of combat losses is not a conclusion that we have ever suggested ourselves, nor one we believe to be accurate,” the IISS said.

    It seems that the whole “Ukrainian artillery hack” claims by Crowdstrike was simply made up. There was no “hack” and the claimed damage from the “hack” did not occur at all. Crowdstrike had evidently invented a “crime” and “Russian hacking” where none had happened.

    Yaroslav Sherstyuk, maker of the Ukrainian military app in question, called the company’s report “delusional” in a Facebook post. Crowdstrike also never contacted him before or after its report was published, he told VOA.

    The company’s credibility is now at stake, because the firm was the first to link last year’s hacks of Democratic Party computers to “Russian hackers”. There were and are also no Russian troops fighting in Donbass regardless of what Alperovitch asserts. According to Esquire.com, Alperovitch had vetted speeches for Hillary Clinton about cyber security issues in the past.

    Alperovitch, a Russian expatriate working at the Atlantic Council policy research center in Washington, co-founded the company in 2011. The firm boasts two former FBI agents: Shawn Henry, who oversaw global cyber investigations at the agency, and Steven Chabinsky, who was the agency’s top cyber lawyer and had served on an Obama administration’s cybersecurity commission.

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    Americas

    Democratic governor invents conservative ‘weapons caches’ story

    CharlottesvilleIt seems the Democratic governor of the US state of Virginia, Terry McAuliffe, invented a story about "caches of weapons" being stashed around Charlottesville by conservatives in advance of the recently held Unite the Right rally.

    Tech companies move to take down alt-right websites from Internet

    The blacklisting on the Internet of alt-right and conservative sites by US tech companies, has begun in all earnest.

    Why did the police not intervene in Charlottesville?

    Charlottesville, VirginiaPolice and the National Guard outnumbered Unite the Right [UTR] participants in Charlottesville, Virgina, by 2:1, but somehow they still let the situation get out of hand with one person killed and several injured.

    #UniteTheRight gathering ends in chaos with one death as Charlottesville police stand down

    Lack of police protection for alt-right marchers in Charlottesville, Virginia led to the cancellation of speeches in front of the beleaguered statue of General Robert E. Lee, soon to be removed.

    Google fires engineer for memo based on gender science

    After Google fired James Damore, author of a manifesto defending a fact-based, scientific approach to the alleged gender gap in tech, many Google employees spoke out in support of his manifesto.

    Half of Detroit’s mayoral candidates have a violent criminal past

    DetroitHalf of all mayoral hopefuls on Detroit’s primary list of candidates have been convicted of crimes involving drugs, assault or weapons, a Detroit News analysis revealed.

    Black murders soar in US’s most gun controlled city

    ChicagoChicago has reached more than 400 murders for the year so far, outpacing 2016, which was one of the bloodiest years recorded in decades.

    Generals take over Trump White House

    New White House Chief of Staff Gen. John Kelly was appointed to "bring order" to the White House and to the US administration. The New York Times reported that Kelly “made it clear” that he would be imposing a strict line of command.

    Pentagon offers plan to arm Ukraine escalating tensions with Russia

    WashingtonThe United States Military-Industrial Complex plan to escalate tensions with Russia and supply Ukraine with antitank missiles and other advanced weaponry.

    Pentagon dumps millions on mind-control project

    The Pentagon’s research arm — the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency, or DARPA — has just been given $65 million of American taxpayer money to develop a direct link between a human brain and a computer.

    Go to archive