Skip to Content

Hamburg expropriates private dwellings for migrants

German authorities in Hamburg have confiscated six residential units in the Hamm district near the city center in what constitutes an attack on property rights.

Published: May 15, 2017, 1:25 pm

    Hamburg

    It remains unclear why no one has challenged the constitutionality of the property expropriation, as authorities have begun laying claim to private dwellings against the will of the owner.

    A trustee appointed by the second-largest city in Germany, is currently renovating the properties and will rent them to “refugees”, while all renovation will be done at the owner’s cost. The dwellings in Hamm have been vacant since 2012.

    The housing shortage has been brought about by Chancellor Angela Merkel’s decision to open the borders to more than two million migrants in a short space of time.

    City officials have been seizing commercial properties and converting them into migrant shelters since late 2015. On October 1, 2015, the Hamburg Parliament approved a new law that allows the city to seize vacant commercial real estate – office buildings as well as land – and use it to house migrants. But now, they have moved to expropriate residential property units owned privately.

    When Merkel invited millions from Africa, Asia and the Middle East, the housing problem became acute. More than 400 new migrants arrive in Hamburg each day and all the existing refugee shelters are full.

    The housing crisis is however self-inflicted. A study conducted in 2012, forecast that by 2017, Hamburg would have a deficit of at least 50 000 rental properties. The government presented a plan to build 6 000 new residential units per year, but the plan never got off the ground because prospective builders were constricted by government-imposed rental caps which would have made it impossible for them to even recover their construction costs.

    Since then, the city has been seizinging private property to resolve its housing shortage. Because the owners of vacant real estate refuse to make their properties available to the city on a voluntary basis, the city is simply confiscating it.

    The measure has been welcomed by the left and far-left. “We are doing everything we can to ensure that the refugees are not homeless during the coming winter,” said Senator Till Steffen of the Green Party. “For this reason, we need to use vacant commercial properties.”

    “The proposed confiscation of private land and buildings is a massive attack on the property rights of the citizens of Hamburg,” said André Trepoll of the Christian Democratic Union (CDU) and added that the ends did not justify the means. “It amounts to an expropriation by the state.” He called the measure a “law of intimidation” that amounts to a “political dam-break with far-reaching implications”.

    Katja Suding, the leader of the Free Democrats (FDP) in Hamburg, said that the proposed law is an “unacceptable crossing of red lines… Such coercive measures will only fuel resentment against refugees”.

    Similar expropriation measures have been proposed in Berlin, the German capital, but abandoned because they were deemed unconstitutional.

    In November 2015, Social Democrats (SPD) in Berlin wanted Section 36 of Berlin’s Public Order and Safety Law [Allgemeine Gesetz zum Schutz der öffentlichen Sicherheit und Ordnung, ASOG], amended. It currently allows police to enter private residences only in extreme instances, to “avert acute threats,” such as serious crime. The SPD wanted to expand the scope for warrantless inspections to include “preventing homelessness”.

    A Die Zeit article from September 2015, reported that Hamburg changed the law specifically because of the refugees.

    Christiana Kant, co-ordinating some of the refugee housing in Hamburg told the BBC that the sheer numbers of the influx are a huge logistical problem. “We’re packing people into supermarkets, into a tennis hall, just to get a roof over their heads,” she said.

    Will German authorities limit the maximum amount of living space per person next, and force those with large apartments to share them with strangers?

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    Europe

    Warnings about Manchester bomber ignored, because tolerance trumps safety

    ManchesterWould Manchester suicide bomber Salman Abedi have engaged in Monday's tragic killings if, as the Wall Street Journal notes, he had not been part of the US effort overthrow of the Libyan government, ending with the US proxy war in Syria meant to overthrow president Assad for a Qatari gas pipeline?

    Trend emerging of countries wanting to leave NATO

    BratislavaWhile the mainstream media pushes the idea of an enlarged NATO constantly - Montenegro is the latest addition - very little is being said about the emerging trend of countries wishing to leave NATO.

    Hungarians in Transcarpathia. File photo

    European politicians: ‘Kiev, respect minority rights!’

    Increasing tensions in Transcarpathia: European politicians urge protection of the rights of national minorities in Ukraine and call for autonomy.

    British Muslim said to be responsible for Manchester attack

    ManchesterISIS has officially claimed responsibility on Tuesday for the bombing of a concert in Manchester through its Amaq News Agency, according to the SITE Intelligence Group. The ISIS statement called him a "soldier" of the Caliphate.

    New EU joint military fund shakes up Britain

    BrusselsEU countries are heading for greater defence integration and on Thursday approved the creation of a fund for joint military projects as part of the push known as the Cooperative Financial Mechanism.

    Migrants to be kept away from pro-immigration G7 leaders

    TaorminaThe leaders of G7 countries aren't taking any chances with "refugees" when it concerns their own safety.

    ‘Crimea can soon be the Russian Monaco’

    INTERVIEWAndrey Nazarov, co-chair of the All-Russian Civic Organisation “Business Russia” (Delovaya Rossiya) in an exclusive Free West Media-interview about the huge business opportunities for the Russian peninsula Crimea.

    Belgian minister suggests closing migrant smuggling routes

    BrusselsBelgium’s migration minister Theo Francken told Reuters on Thursday that African migrants should be turned back if they pay human traffickers to cross the Mediterranean into the EU

    Donbass wants to be part of Russia again

    The leaders of independent republics Donetsk and Lugansk see their long term future with the Russian Federation.

    Childless leaders are steering Europe

    ParisThree world leaders now have the distinction of being childless at an historical time in Europe.

    Go to archive