UN urged to launch ‘cultural appropriation’ wars
Indigenous advocates worldwide were calling on a UN committee this week to ban the appropriation of Indigenous cultures as soon as possible.
Published: June 19, 2017, 6:40 am
Delegates from 189 countries were gathered in Geneva, attending the meeting of a special international committee within the World Intellectual Property Organisation (WIPO), a United Nations agency.
Since it began in 2001, the committee has been working on creating and finishing three pieces of international law that would expand intellectual-property regulations to protect things like Indigenous designs, dances, words and traditional medicines.
Concern about the rights of cultures to control their own goods has been at the forefront of the meetings.
James Anaya, dean of law at the University of Colorado, said on Monday that the UN’s negotiated document should “obligate states to create effective criminal and civil enforcement procedures to recognize and prevent the non-consensual taking and illegitimate possession, sale and export of traditional cultural expressions.”
The committee has been working on three draft documents for 16 years already, and member states as well as some Indigenous leaders say they are frustrated and disenchanted about the committee’s future.
“We are only halfway through 2017 and yet the number of occurrences of misappropriation happening to Indigenous Peoples in all regions of the world seems relentless with no relief in sight,” complained Aroha Te Pareake Mead, a member of the Ngati Awa and Ngati Porou tribes in Wellington, New Zealand. “We asked the international community to help deal with a problem that traverses international boundaries and are still waiting.”
The Navajo Nation however had launched a legal battle against a US company for trademark infringement in 2012 after a clothing company labeled several designs on products “Navajo”. The case was settled out of court late last year.
A US designer Tory Burch was forced to change the description of one of her coats for women after Romanians protested that it had been described as African-inspired when it actually appropriated a traditional Romanian garment.
One member told CBC News that WIPO has what she called “one of the lowest” rates of Indigenous participation. “The issues being discussed at the [Intergovernmental Committee] are also being discussed in Indigenous organizations and communities all around the world on a regular basis. So why are there not more Indigenous representatives here?”
Indigenous groups from around the world taking part in this round of negotiations, including groups from New Zealand, Kenya, Mexico, Colombia and the United States. No representatives from Canada’s First Nations were present, despite a heated debate over cultural appropriation and free speech that had boiled over in Canadian media also this week.
The controversy began when a white novelist and former editor of the Writers’ Union of Canada’s publication, Hal Niedzviecki penned an editorial in Write magazine under the headline “Winning the Appropriation Prize” in which he argued that he did “not believe in cultural appropriation” because writers should write “what they don’t know”.
He was quickly forced to resign as editor and had to publicly apologise after his editorial sparked outrage from members of the Indigenous community. Not only was Niedzviecki fired, but the backlash over the article has led to a number of retractions, resignations, and reassignments of some media heavyweights. Even the managing editor of CBC’s “The National,” was reassigned less than a week after tweeting about the issue.
“The theft of our story is the loss of our culture, is our assimilation. That’s why in the arts it actually matters to us as much as anything else,” Jesse Wente, a Toronto-based culture critic, told the Canadian Press. “This is as important as the pipelines, as sovereignty, as water. They’re all interconnected.”
“Barbecue is a form of cultural power and is intensely political”, because “it was made by enslaved Africans with inspiration and contributions from Native Americans struggling to maintain their independence” argued Michael Twitty in the Guardian in 2015.
A group of Palestinian chefs said Israeli chef Shalom Kadosh had launched a “flagrant Israeli attack on our culture” after he cooked falafel.
All rights reserved. You have permission to quote freely from the articles provided that the source (www.freewestmedia.com) is given. Photos may not be used without our consent.
Keep your language polite. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in, for example, Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.
If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violations of any law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.
If your comments are subject to preview by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.
We reserve the right to delete comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.
AlkmaarEight very angry, unwashed migrants in jogging pants gathered in the shared kitchen of the asylum seekers' center in Alkmaar, the Netherlands to complain about having to clean toilets, a Dutch daily reported.
The US has significantly boosted its forces in Europe, while preparing a "military Schengen" to allow easy movement across borders.
Germans were promised that an influx of migrants would solve the country's imploding demography. But instead pensioners are bearing the brunt of the wave of newcomers, not benefitting from it.
ToulouseA police patrol in the southern city of Toulouse, France arrested a woman wearing a niqab last weekend because she refused to show her face. The arrest, which took place in the city’s migrant populated Mirail suburb, sparked five consecutive nights of violence.
NaplesA nuclear submarine that took part in a series of missile strikes conducted by US, French and UK warships and warplanes against Syria in contravention of the UN Charter, is not welcome near the waters of one of Italy's largest seaports, according to the popular mayor of Naples.
An American Republican survey has exposed the mood in Ukraine: It is currently bad and respondents are expecting worse.
The leader of Lega Nord Matteo Salvini will put an end to “absurd” EU sanctions against Russia if he becomes prime minister of the country he said.
Britain needs to show proof that Russia was behind the poisoning of a former Russian double agent and his daughter in England, the German government’s coordinator for Russia told German broadcaster ARD on Thursday.
An African asylum seeker in France has been sentenced to four months in prison for identity fraud after he claimed that he was underage, then an adult and then switching his gender from female to male.
An informative Swedish weekly has revealed the high drama - worse than the Cuban crisis - that enveloped the world in March while the West's population was being kept ignorant.