Skip to Content

Google hurts consumers by rigging prices

The EU has imposed a $2.7 billion fine on Google as a result of its anti-competitive behavior. A Silicon Valley antitrust lawyer Gary Reback explained how the search engine company hurts consumers.

Published: July 8, 2017, 9:40 am

    Reback explained in an opinion piece for the Washington Post, titled: You Should Be Outraged at Google’s Anti-Competitive Behavior that before 2007, products would appear in Google search results, ranked in the order of their quality to users.

    Following a seven-year long investigation by the EU of Google’s search engine practices, the European Commission has alleged Google denied “consumers a genuine choice” by unfairly promoting Google Shopping in internet searches to the detriment of its rivals. The fine is the highest ever imposed in Europe for anti-competitive behavior.

    Such “comparison shopping sites” were designed to identify the lowest prices. “The more accurate and comprehensive their results, the higher they were ranked and the more traffic they generated,” Reback noted.

    “But the more successful that comparison shopping sites became, the more they threatened Google’s business plan. Google makes money by selling ads placed next to its free search results, and merchants could not be expected to bid for ad placement if the listings in comparison shopping sites on the same search undercut their prices.”

    To address this, Google developed a devious plan, documented by the FTC, and published in the Wall Street Journal.

    “Quoting internal Google documents and emails, the report shows that the company created a list of rival comparison shopping sites that it would artificially lower in the general search results, even though tests showed that Google users ‘liked the quality of the [rival] sites’ and gave negative feedback on the proposed changes.

    “Google reworked its search algorithm at least four times, the documents show, and altered its established rating criteria before the proposed changes received ‘slightly positive’ user feedback. Internal Google documents predicted that the proposed changes would reduce rivals’ user traffic up to 20 percent and subsequently reported producing the desired results once the changes were implemented.”

    Google then bumped up results from its own comparison shopping service to the top of their search results. “After these changes, the only source of low-price information readily available on Google’s search platform came from Google’s own comparison shopping service,” Reback said.

    “Google’s conduct certainly hurt its rivals, particularly after a second round of search-listing demotions documented by the European Union. Many companies have been forced to lay off all of their employees and even shut down operations,” the lawyer concluded. Those rivals included US consumer review website Yelp, TripAdvisor, UK price comparison site Foundem, News Corp and lobbying group Fair Search.

    Google’s prices for everyday products are much higher than those on rival sites, sometimes more than 50 percent higher. A study by the Financial Times documented the higher prices, as Google eliminated services showing the lowest prices, free to merchants, and replaced them with high-priced ads.

    Other countries have also accused the Silicon Valley tech giant of abusing its market clout by imposing restrictions on Android device manufactures and mobile network operators.

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    Americas

    Pentagon dumps millions on mind-control project

    The Pentagon’s research arm — the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency, or DARPA — has just been given $65 million of American taxpayer money to develop a direct link between a human brain and a computer.

    The most downvoted song about deviant sex nominated for an Emmy Award

    Despite being one of the most heavily downvoted songs of all time on YouTube, a song about "fluid sexuality" was nominated for a prestigious US television award.

    Ukrainian meddling in US election in the spotlight

    WashingtonIt seems the only presidential candidate whose campaign was boosted directly by a former Communist country, was Hillary Clinton. "Ukrainian government officials tried to help Hillary Clinton and undermine Trump by publicly questioning his fitness for office," Politico reported.

    US state about to decriminalise hard drugs meth, cocaine and heroin

    PortlandThe Oregon legislature passed two bills last week decriminalising at least six hard drugs, including cocaine, heroin, methamphetamine and ecstasy, because keeping the laws currently on the law books, amounts to “institutional racism”.

    New Jersey lists Antifa as a domestic terrorist organisation

    Trenton, NJThe Department of Homeland Security in the state of New Jersey has officially listed Antifa as a domestic terrorist group after a series of violent attacks on supporters of president Donald Trump.

    CNN caught red-handed promoting fake news about Russia

    An undercover video released by Project Veritas shows CNN producer John Bonifield admitting the Trump-Russia narrative is "mostly bullshit" but on the orders of CNN's CEO Jeff Zucker, journalists are told to keep up the fake reports "for ratings".

    Illegals voting in US election far higher than previously estimated

    WashingtonThe number of illegal immigrants that voted in recent US elections was likely far greater than previous estimates, a new study revealed. As many as 5.7 million illegals may have voted in the 2008 election, securing the White House for Barack Obama.

    One in six Americans unhappy about media even before ex-FBI Comey’s hearing

    WashingtonAmericans are not happy with their news media, as almost six in 10 say it makes them angry and dissatisfied in a new poll. It may also be the trending topic from the appearance by ex-FBI director James Comey in front of the Senate Intelligence Committee.

    Fake news: New York Times misrepresents Putin’s denial of Russian hacking

    New YorkThis week the New York Times misrepresented Putin's denial Russia that engages in hacking to insinuate an admission of a Russian role in hacking the Democratic campaign to stop Hillary Clinton from being elected.

    Beheading presidents: Chelsea Clinton is not laughing so much now

    WashingtonHillary Clinton once famously said "We came, we saw, he died" cackling about the murder of Muammar Ghaddafi of Libya her country unleashed. But her daughter Chelsea for one, does not appreciate gags about killing presidents:

    Go to archive