Skip to Content

PACE; Poroshenko

PACE to debate Ukraine’s discriminatory new language law

The Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE) will hold a debate today on a new contraversial Ukrainian education law concerning minority languages.

Published: October 12, 2017, 10:11 am

    Read more

    This point was added to the agenda of PACE’s autumn plenary as urgent during a recent session, after Hungary and Poland’s parliamentary representatives called for a discussion on the new Ukrainian law. The law requires that educational institutions teach in Ukrainian only.

    The Ukrainian Verkhovna Rada adopted the new education law on 5 September, entitled “On Education”, which instantly drew furious condemnation from both Ukraine’s European neighbours as well as Russia.

    The law means that all national minority languages, such as Russian, will be taught only up to fifth grade, and only until 2020, when Ukraine’s education system will be exclusively Ukrainian-language-based.

    Ukraine’s classification of Russians and the Russian language as a “national minority” is problematic at best. Novorossiya actually refers to the historical conquest by Russians. As a result of all of these historical facts, the Russian language is spoken at home by at least half of the Ukrainian population. Thus, Russians are the second ethnos composing Ukraine.

    The second ethnic group targeted by Kiev, are the Hungarians, who similarly cannot be dismissed as a mere national minority. Hungarians have lived on the territory of Transcarpathian Rus (currently Ukraine’s Transcarpathian region) for more than 1000 years since this land’s induction into the Kingdom of Hungary. Ukrainians, who migrated from Galicia, are actually the real “national minority” of Transcarpathia.

    The European Charter for Regional or Minority Languages has been practically annulled by the Kiev junta since the victory of Euromaidan, undermining the status of both Hungarian and Russian.

    And despite the Euromaidan slogan of “Ukraine is Europe!”, the new government forthwith abolished the European Charter and suspended the existing language law crafted for the EU.

    While Kiev would not dare to stamp out the Russian language alone, as such a move would be too transparently and deliberately anti-democratic, they have included minorities linked Hungary, Poland, and Romania.

    The new law deprives the 152 000-strong Magyar community in Transcarpathia of the possibility of education in their native language.

    Hungary’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs has expressed his profound displeasure at the measures and on 10 October initiated a review of the Ukraine-EU Association Agreement. Hungarian Foreign Minister Péter Szijjártó announced his decision during a meeting with representatives of the Hungarian diaspora in Ukraine’s Uzhgorod, on Kiev’s own territory.

    The First Vice-Speaker of the Verkhovna Rada, Irina Gerashchenko, dismissed Hungary’s criticism of the Ukrainian law as part of the upcoming Hungarian parliamentary elections.

    In an interview with Sputnik Radio yesterday, Eduard Popov drew attention to the fact that the Hungarian experience of living in particular linguistic environments – Slavic and German – has led to the development of a particular sensitivity among Hungarians regarding language rights.

    Budapest will no doubt work to undermine all forms of cooperation between the EU and Ukraine if Kiev continues its unpopular measures.

    Popov expects the PACE debates on 12 October to be heated, where Ukraine will be facing harsh accusations from the Hungarian and Polish delegations. Some sensible members of the Verkhovna Rada have even admitted to a difficult meeting.

    PACE has recommended that the Ukrainian government reconsider the issue of education with respect to the languages of minorities and emphasized that there should be no discrimination on the basis of language.

    The blow to Ukraine’s unity has already been dealt, by Kiev sacrificing the loyalty of “non-titular” ethnic groups that make up Ukraine.

    Kiev may even lose the very territories that it acquired following the Second World War thanks to the Soviet Union, without any interference from Russia.

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    Europe

    Czech election outcome may be fresh challenge to EU establishment

    ANO, the Czech party led by a billionaire, is the clear favourite in a general election taking place this weekend where traditional parties most likely will face an uphill battle.

    Leftists disrupt Frankfurt book fair, blame conservatives

    Leftist activists at the Frankfurt Book Fair interrupted an event held by a member of the AfD party and a conservative publishing house.

    Huge anti-Islamic rally in London gets almost no media attention

    A huge demonstration held by tens of thousands of British citizens against jihadism in their own country, attracted little mainstream media attention.

    Multinational NATO forces amassing near Russian border

    A thousands-strong multinational NATO battalion stationed in Romania is part of the ongoing military buildup of NATO aimed at Russia.

    Frankfurt Book Fair: Leftist propaganda on steroids

    At the opening gala of the Frankfurt Book Fair on Tuesday night, Angela Merkel and Emmanuel Macron appealed to their audience for more "tolerance and diversity" and books to counter the rise of nationalism.

    French philosopher says France is in a ‘civil war’ with Islam

    A respected French philosopher, Damien Le Guay, believes that by refusing to acknowledge we are in a state of civil war with radical Islam, we are in fact only aggravating the situation.

    Dirty campaign bombshell rocks Austria ahead of elections

    Austria's election campaign has been rocked by a massive scandal when it was disovered that the ruling party of Chancellor Christian Kern had attacked its biggest challenger on Facebook using xenophobic memes and conspiracy theories.

    New seating arrangement in the Bundestag for AfD?

    Parties in the German Bundestag want nothing to do with their 93 new AfD colleagues and nobody wants to sit next to them. Since the deputies can not be placed in the hemisphere of the Reichstag or a floor lower, a solution will have to be found.

    French government to detain illegal immigrants up to 90 days

    In an attempt to clamp down on illegal immigration, the French government is going to start detaining immigrants on the expulsion list for up to 90 days.

    AfD success sends tremors through political establishment

    BerlinIn a dramatic development, the AfD's rise on the national stage in Germany, has sent tremors through the political establishment. The AfD said it would challenge Merkel's decision to open German borders without Bundestag approval.

    Go to archive