Skip to Content

German pilots refuse to fly out migrant deportees

German pilots have refused to carry out the planned deportations of rejected asylum seekers.

Published: December 6, 2017, 5:57 am

    Read more

    Not only are pilots helping the deportees, but migrants appealing their deportation orders in record numbers, are winning their appeals.

    Since Germany lost WWII, the federal government is not allowed to directly carry on deportations. Such orders have to be passed on to state and then local authorities.

    Several pilots have refused to participate in deportations, local media reported on Monday. The majority of the flights, 140, were scheduled to take off from Frankfurt, and 40 others from Dusseldorf, where #WelcomeUnited activists regularly protest against deportation of asylum applicants.

    In 2017, German pilots refused to fly 222 chartered flights to repatriate rejected Afghan asylum seekers, according to Deutsche Welle.

    The figures were obtained by the Die Linke, commonly referred to as the Left Party.

    Some 85 of the cancelled flights were operated by Lufthansa or Eurowings, a decision taken by pilots after a controversial designation of Afghanistan as a “safe country of origin”.

    The designation resulted in Afghan asylum seekers losing their entitlement to be granted refuge outside the country.

    Lufthansa spokesman Michael Lamberty defended the pilots, citing security concerns. “The decision not to carry a passenger is ultimately made by the pilot on a case by case basis. If he or she had the impression that flight safety could be affected, he must refuse to transport the passenger,” Lamberty told Westdeutsche Allegeimeine Zeitung.

    According to Lamberty, Lufthansa pilots interview some passengers who are about to be deported prior to the flight, since “they have a valid ticket after all”.

    “Should security personnel at the airports have some sort of information in advance which indicates that a situation could escalate during a deportation, they can decide ahead of time not to let the passengers board.”

    Germany issues the largest number of decisions on refugees. It has processed more asylum applications than all 27 other EU countries combined.

    According to data from the Bundesamt für Migration und Flüchtlinge (BAMF), the German immigration office, the country has accepted almost 170 000 asylum requests for 2017, and rejected around 210 000.

    Most of the rejected cases – one in every two – have been appealed however, and of these, one in four decisions is overturned. Every second ruling made by the BAMF in the first half of the year was brought before a judge, double the number of appeals made during the same period in 2016.

    Die Welt, a German daily, reported that the European statistics agency Eurostat, showed that the Federal Office for Migration and Refugees (BAMF) decided 388 201 asylum cases in the first six months of 2017.

    The public broadcaster NDR, reported that these appeals have cost Berlin about €19 million from January to November 2017, an increase of €7.8 million from the previous year.

    In order to reduce the number of appeals and speed up deportations, the government has proposed a program to begin in February 2018 for rejected asylum seekers. They will be given 3 000 euros as an incentive to accept deportation.

    But according to Amnesty International, the deportation of asylum seekers back to Afghanistan were putting nearly 10 000 people at risk of death, as the organisation maintains “no part of Afghanistan is safe, they are putting people at risk of torture, kidnapping, death and other horrors”.

    Forcible repatriations to Afghanistan include children and minors.

    At least one similar refusal was registered the UK earlier this year when British Airways pilot refused to take off while Samim Bigzad was on board, The Independent reported.

    Bigzad, an Afghan, faced deportation to the city where the Taliban had threatened to kill him. “You’re not going to take him; I’m not flying,” the pilot said. “Someone’s life is at risk.”


    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    • Germany needs to unburden itself of the White Guilt imposed on it since WWII. Or it will be destroyed.

    • Smash Islamophobia

      “Since Germany lost WWII, the federal government is not allowed to directly carry on deportations. Such orders have to be passed on to state and then local authorities.”

      That’s insane. Nonsensical. Repeal is clearly indicated.

      • Joseph Martin

        Hi Smash! We miss you. I hope you are just taking a well deserved break and will be back soon.

        Happy New Year!

        • Событие

          My post is being held hostage by the Spam monster over on Mickey’s Happy Christmas! OP. A little New Year’s message for you.

          • Joseph Martin

            OK. And thanks very much. Happy New Year!

            • Событие

              You’re welcome. I’m always wary of risking over-familiarity when offering support through words. It’s all I can do. Always wishing you the best, Joseph. Stay strong.

            • Joseph Martin

              I could tell your post was heartfelt and I appreciate it very much.

            • Событие

              Hi, Joseph. I have a comment Pending on ‘Kate Steinle’s illegal cockroach killer…’

        • Copyright101

          Yes, I hope he’s back soon.

      • George Clark

        Three months, where are you?

      • Please come back, Smash. We all miss you.

        • Copyright101

          Yes, it’s about time.

    • Andy C

      Was this really the pilot, or were his owning sponsors, their airliner behind it? There’s a bigger scandal here.
      If it’s the pilot, who are they? What are their affiliations, politically etc? Keeping failed asylum seekers is to put childrens lives in danger. So I don’t buy their BS.

    • Copyright101

      I’m sure we could find similar examples of pilots refusing to take white South Africans (denied residency in the west) back to South Africa. And of course they would not have been punished/sacked for doing such a thing.

    • Logician

      Could it be the pilots are more concerned about the risk to their aircraft while carrying certain unwilling passengers?. Alternatively, are the pilots themselves of the same ideological caste? In which case it’s a recruitment issue. Anyway there are alternatives, like collecting deportees into groups and sailing them out, or freighting them in groups using ideologically-sound pilots.

    Will the Yellow Vests conquer the municipal elections?

    In the run-up to the 2020 municipal elections, the Yellow Vests intend to weigh in by loudly claiming their demands at a local level. And they will do so without necessarily presenting a list.

    Six out of 10 foreign-trained NHS doctors linked to sexual misconduct

    LondonShocking new figures from the UK's National Health Service (NHS) revealed that foreign-trained doctors commit six in ten cases of sexual misconduct with patients, even though they make up only a third of the NHS staff.

    Act XXXII: Yellow Vests return to their original strategy

    For Act XXXII of their mobilization, the Yellow Vests have chosen to return to their original strategy: blockages paralyzing the economy and targeted actions. The move could succeed in reigniting the movement.

    Security protection units for French ministers ‘exhausted’

    ParisOf the 61 French gendarmes who were charged on Thursday to escort two French high officials, 48 were off work.

    Large percentage of migrants condone violence against AfD

    A large percentage of migrants have expressed consent for violence used against the German anti-immigration party, the AfD.

    Russia to become 5th largest economy overtaking Germany

    The Russian economy has clearly weathered sanctions better than some Western politicians imagined. Despite years of international pressure and low oil prices, Russia will overtake Germany as the world's fifth largest economy.

    Salvini: Italy will not be inking the UN Global Compact in Marrakesh

    RomeItalian Deputy Premier and Interior Minister Matteo Salvini confirmed on Wednesday that Italy will not be signing the UN United Nations Global Compact for Safe, Orderly and Regular Migration at an intergovernmental conference to be held in Marrakech next month.

    Migrant gets milder punishment to prevent his expulsion after rape

    AmsterdamA Dutch judge has just given an asylum seeker a milder punishment after he raped a disabled girl, so as to prevent the migrant's expulsion.

    Russia continues warning of provocations in Syria

    The Russian Defense Ministry has continued its warning of another fake a chemical incident which would be a pretext for a US-led attack on the Syrian government.

    Bombing of Italian League office treated as terrorism

    Treviso Prosecutor Michele Dalla Costa said on Friday that the explosives planted outside the provincial office of the League in the town of Villorba was "terrorism".

    Go to archive