Skip to Content

Migrants found with multi-resistant tuberculosis pathogens

Scientists confirmed the outbreak of a multi-resistant strain of tuberculosis. It was discovered in 29 migrants who had come to Germany via the Horn of Africa.

Published: January 26, 2018, 6:29 am

    Tuberculosis, which had been declining for many years, has made a comeback. This is what the Robert-Koch-Institut (RKI) in Berlin announced at World Tuberculosis Day 2017, pointing the current migration movements as a new vector in spreading the disease.

    Researchers from the National Reference Centre (NRZ) at Borstel, have discovered a Europe-wide outbreak of a multi-resistant strain of tuberculosis, Die Welt reported. The strain showed a remarkable resistance to at least four different antibiotics.

    The increase of cases involving persons with a migration background have compelled NRZ scientists to conduct further research.

    Migrants are generally screened for communicable diseases on entry, a requirement as stated in paragraph 62 of German Asylum Law (AsylG). This includes an X-ray of the respiratory tract, which can determine a tuberculosis infection. But only ten percent of the people who are infected with the pathogen become ill — half of them in the first year after infection, the other half even later.

    Since the law for protection against infection (IfSG) was introduced in January 2001, numerous characteristics of each tuberculosis patient were recorded and, in anonymised form, transferred by the 400 health offices in Germany via the 16 state offices to the Robert Koch Institute.

    The research center at Borstel made their findings known in the professional journal The Lancet for Infectious Diseases when researchers from Schleswig-Holstein and their colleagues at the National Reference Center for Mycobacteria (NZM) in Switzerland identified a hitherto unknown tuberculosis pathogen in 2016.

    The journal is recognised for providing a global, authoritative, and independent forum for the highest quality infectious diseases research and opinion, covering such areas as antibiotic resistance, emerging infections, and public health.

    The molecular-biological examination in combination with patient interviews enabled the scientists to partially reconstruct the chain of infection. The data pointed to infection before the arrival in Europe, in a Libyan refugee camp at Bani Walid.

    It is likely that the strain developed from a clone of a tuberculosis strain that is common at the Horn of Africa. All 29 patients from seven European countries had migrated to Europe via the Horn of Africa.

    “The patients are mainly unaccompanied underage refugees who registered in Baden-Württemberg,” says Dr. Katharina Kranzer, chief of the NRZ at Borstel. But as the outbreak was still ongoing, more cases might surface.

    In September 2015, in what has been the largest influx of migrants to Hamburg until now, nine people were taken to the University Hospital Hamburg-Eppendorf (UKE) as a precaution. A paramedic had noticed, in a tent at the main train station, symptoms of the highly infectious disease in three migrants.

    “It was only through analysis of the genome that the strain of the outbreak was unambiguously identified,” says Professor Stefan Niemann, author of the study and leader of the research team for molecular and experimental mycobacteriology at the Borstel research center, and the tuberculosis department at the German Center for Infectious Research. “But in order to be able to fully benefit from the advantages of this technology it needs to be incorporated into routine screening and monitoring for tuberculosis.”

    Niemann refers to himself and his colleagues as “genome detectives”, as they have been analyzing the genome of the tuberculosis bacterium. “In order to be able to determine the tuberculosis strain, we have developed a quick test,” says Niemann. Additionally, in Borstel, in a pilot project, all laboratory samples from tuberculosis patients from Hamburg, Hannover and Frankfurt are being analyzed. “We have material from Hamburg from 1996 on,” says the researcher, hoping that other cities will join in on the project.

    According to RKI, a total of 5915 cases of tuberculosis were registered in 2016, meaning 7.2 newly-ill per 100 000 inhabitants. The analysis by nationality showed visible differences in the risk of illness: The incidence with foreign nationals was 42.6 per 100 000 inhabitants, some 19 times higher than in the German population with an incidence of 2.2.

    This discrepancy has increased, compared to the previous year. The difference was especially notable in young adults. Altogether, 30.9 percent of those who had fallen sick had German nationality, but 69.1 percent were foreign nationals.

    The analysis by country of birth shows that the number of foreign-born patients steadily increased over the past years, and constituted three quarters or 74.3 percent of all registered cases in 2016. The most frequently-stated countries are Somalia, Eritrea, Afghanistan, Syria and Romania.

    “But it would be wrong to assume that you can’t become infected by tuberculosis in Germany, and that it is always transmitted abroad,” Niemann says. “30 percent of the cases occur via transmission in Germany.”

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    • Same here in the US, long-eradicated diseases making a comeback. Probably, other Western nations too. ALL due to immivasion. Deport the invaders, and crush our traitors. Please.


    Ukrainian pilot suspected of shooting down MH17 found dead

    The Ukrainian pilot Vladislav Voloshin, whom his colleague Yevgeny Agapov had accused of involvement in the shooting down of flight MH17, has been found dead.

    Islamo-leftists march in London

    LondonThousands of demonstrators gathered in London to protest against the "evil of racism" and "Islamophobia" in a strong show of Islamo-leftism.

    Porton Down not able to identify chemical used on Russian ex-spy

    Well-placed sources inside the British Foreign Office have confirmed that Porton Down scientists were not able to identify the nerve agent as being of Russian manufacture, and are angry about the political pressure from inside the government to lie about the poison being Russian.

    Joint allied statement against Russia after UK ignores OCPW convention

    LondonOn 15 March, the United Kingdom, together with allies Germany, France and the United States, issued a collective statement alleging that ex-spy Sergey Skripal and his daughter Yulia were poisoned by agents of the Russian Federation.

    Britain’s spy hysteria is damaging its credibility and standing

    LondonThe actions of the British government in response to the alleged poisoning of a British double agent Sergei Skripal and his daughter is damaging Britain's credibility and international standing.

    Cost of EU Parliament steeply rising

    The costs of the European parliament have been steeply increasing since 2011. It won’t take long before it hits 2 billion euros a year, a Dutch newspaper reported.

    Telford: largest child sex abuse scandal in history ignored by the BBC

    The Sunday Mirror reported this weekend that a young English girl could be one of up to 1000 victims of grooming or child sexual abuse in the Shropshire town over the last four decades, thought to be one of the worst of its kind in modern Britain.

    UK Foreign Office issued letter in pidgin English to banned speakers

    LondonConservative vlogger Brittany Pettibone was given a letter written in pidgin English denying her leave to enter the UK. Pettibone, an American citizen and her partner the Austrian Identitarian activist Martin Sellner were both held in detention in the UK and denied entry into the country.

    Mainstream Polish author barred from UK visit

    LondonWhile the UK ban on two visiting conservatives from Austria and the US, Martin Sellner and Brittany Pettibone made headlines, the UK ban on award-winning Polish journalist received little attention.

    Dutch politicians call for end to EU’s ‘fact checking’

    The HagueDutch home affairs minister Kasja Ollongren is facing pressure from a majority of Dutch MPs who want on Brussels to disband its "fact checking" unit known as EU vs Disinfo.

    Go to archive