Skip to Content

Anthea Jeffery interviewed on SA television

Black ‘land hunger’ in South Africa is a big lie

Anthea Jeffery, head of Policy Research at the Institute for Race Relations (IRR), a political think tank in Johannesburg, South Africa, revealed that black South Africans have virtually no interest in land reform.

Published: March 1, 2018, 10:26 am

    President Cyril Ramaphosa’s push for land expropriation without compensation is ostensibly due to a “pressing” and “urgent” hunger for farming land belonging to mostly Afrikaners, he says.

    But comprehensive and countrywide opinion polls commissioned by the IRR from 2015 to 2017 have repeatedly shown that the great majority of black South Africans have almost zero interest in land reform.

    In the IRR’s 2016 field survey, for instance, only 1 percent of black respondents – down from 2 percent the previous year – said that “more land reform” was the “best way to improve lives”. By contrast, 73 percent of black people saw “more jobs and better education” as the “best way” to improve their lives, Jeffery says.

    “In similar vein, in the IRR’s 2017 field survey, only 1 percent of black respondents identified ‘speeding up land reform’ as a top priority for the government,” she added.

    “Even among people who were dispossessed of land under apartheid laws – and were most likely to have a strong wish to see their land restored to them – there has been little interest in land as opposed to cash compensation.”

    When the land restitution process began in 1994, some 79 700 valid land claims were submitted by December 1998. By 2013, as the then minister of rural development and land reform, Gugile Nkwinti, pointed out, roughly 76 000 successful claims had been disposed of. However, only about 5 800 of these successful claimants, some 8 percent, chose to have their land restored to them. The remaining 92 percent preferred to receive cash compensation instead.

    A surprised Nkwinti noted: “We thought everybody when they got a chance to get land, they would jump for it. Now only 5 856 have opted for land restoration. We no longer have a peasantry; we have wage earners now.”

    So the 76 000 successful land claimants, faced with a real-life choice, opted for cash rather than land. Black people wanted money because they have become too urbanised to do physically demanding farm labour.

    In the IRR’s 2016 survey, for instance, respondents were asked whether they preferred “a political party which focuses on faster growth and more jobs”, or one which “focuses on land expropriation to redress past wrongs”.

    Given this choice, 84 percent of black respondents opted for growth and jobs, whereas only 7 percent wanted major land redistribution as redress for apartheid injustices, Jeffery said.

    Similar results have emerged from a comprehensive opinion survey commissioned by eNCA and carried out by MarkData in September 2017 among a representative sample of some 5 000 people, including about 2 700 self-declared ANC voters.

    Most blacks – even most ANC voters – wanted the ruling party to embark on “more pro-business policies”, rather than to pursue “radical policies/redistribution”.

    Support among ANC voters for “more pro-business policies” was strong in all provinces, while support for “more radical policies/redistribution” was weak countrywide.

    These surveys confirm that the great majority of ordinary ANC voters do not want the same as the ANC and EFF leaders who seem determined to push ahead with a globalist, Marxist agenda.

    Political analyst RW Johnson believes “much of the ANC leadership has completely lost contact with what most ANC voters think – and may not even be conscious of the huge divide that separates their assumptions from those of their electorate”.

    The ruling black elite is however keenly aware of how popular race-baiting has become.

    Jeffery told Fin24 that banks too could be facing disaster in the coming landgrab. “How will the bank get the money it is still owed? It can’t foreclose on the property, because the state now owns the property.”

    Jeffery said the when the farmer defaults because of land confiscation, the bank that has no relationship with the government, will not be able to recover the money.

    “If this default happened on a massive scale, it could be disastrous for banks,” she explained. If the government decides not to compensate the banks when taking land, R160 billion could be wiped off the banks’ books.

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    • boerie

      Agreed, this is clearly EFF trying to score political points before 2019 election and ANC as well. They are still clinging to an outdated “Freedom Charter” with Marxist fundamentals. The reality is, Communism never worked, especially in African countries, because there will always be an elite, white, black or pink, and a middle and poor class. Poverty will worsen even more if the ANC regime continue with their communist landtheft. The economy will continue into a disastrous spiral and their “land restitution” will be meaningless when more people go hungry and unemployment soar.


    South Africa: Motion to confiscate white land without compensation passed

    PretoriaThe South African parliament voted this week to amend the Constitution to allow for the confiscation of land owned by the white minority without compensation.

    South Africa’s new president dashes hope of moderates

    Those still hoping that South Africa's new President, Cyril Ramaphosa, would represent a positive, new chapter for South Africa, had their hopes dashed on Wednesday.

    South African president Zuma resigns after party turns on him

    PretoriaSouth African president Jacob Zuma resigned on Wednesday after his party, the African National Congress (ANC) forced him to leave.

    South Africa: 143 mental patients dead in communist-style atrocity

    The Life Esidimeni scandal has demonstrated to what extent South Africa is emulating 20th-century communist societies, with 143 patients "dying of torture" in mental hospitals run by unlicensed NGOs, and another 55 simply "disappearing".

    ‘White men you must die’ say South African blacks at Overvaal school

    After losing a court case against a school over language, a provincial education department whipped up racial hatred against white pupils, their parents and teachers.

    South African president-in-waiting wants to ‘confiscate white farms without compensation’

    PretoriaThe newly elected leader of South Africa's ruling ANC (African National Congress), Cyril Ramaphosa, has come out strongly in favour of a Zimbabwe-style land grab in the country, promising to confiscate white-owned farms without compensation.

    Economic Freedom Fighters trash H&M stores in South Africa

    JohannesburgThe Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) damaged multiple H&M shops in South Africa, including in Gauteng, the Western Cape, Limpopo, Mpumalanga and KwaZulu-Natal against "racism" in a catalogue.

    South Africa: New ANC leader promises Zim-style landgrab

    PretoriaCyril Ramaphosa, the new president of South Africa's ruling ANC, wants to seize land from white South Africans without compensation as part of an ANC policy of "radical economic transformation".

    South Africa’s new leader will be an oligarch or a Zuma clan leader

    This weekend a titanic leadership struggle takes place in South African when the ruling ANC elects a new party leader.

    South Africa: Paying municipal residents face severe water shortages

    White paying residents in small towns in the Free State, in South Africa, are facing severe water shortages after the Department of Water and Sanitation’s threatened to cut off the water supply for non-payment by municipalities.

    Go to archive