Skip to Content

André Nollkaemper, expert on International Law, University of Amsterdam
The Hague

Dutch International Law expert rips ‘illegal’ support for ‘moderate’ rebels

The external public law advisor to the Dutch cabinet, André Nollkaemper, has written a scathing opinion about Dutch support to Syrian "moderate" rebels.

Published: September 27, 2018, 9:54 am

    The distinguished Nollkaemper is also external Legal Advisor to the Minister of Foreign Affairs of the Netherlands, Member of the Permanent Court of Arbitration, President of the European Society of International Law and Member of the Royal Netherlands Academy of Arts and Sciences.

    In his judgment, which he sent to the Lower House on Wednesday evening, he writes that the support to armed Syrian “moderate” rebels may have been at odds with international law.

    The government never asked for advice, but members of the Lower House asked him afterwards for his advice on the so-called NLA or “non-lethal assistance program”.

    Nollkaemper told Dutch daily Trouw and political news programme Nieuwsuur: “I think there are more facts to be put the table, but on the basis of what there is now, my preliminary opinion is that the Netherlands went too far in providing support to groups, in which the goods have been used in a way that is contrary to international law. On the basis of the facts I now know, based on the UN reports that have also been published, I would also have had serious doubts in 2015 about whether there were groups that we could have supported.

    “The nature and agenda of the different groups were not clear, nor it was clear whether they leaned towards terrorism or towards battling Assad,” says Nollkaemper.

    Nollkaemper regards the Syrian conflict as a “legal minefield”. The fact that the Netherlands supplied “non-lethal” goods to the jihadists is, according to Nollkaemper, “not decisive”. But he added: “The question is whether they were used in the context of armed operations. And that seems to have happened.”

    “In my opinion, the principle that we were not allowed to deliver goods against the Assad government is the most fundamental,” says Nollkaemper. “It is one thing to support moderate groups that are part of a political process. It is different to deliver goods that are part of armed action against Assad.

    “International law makes a very sharp distinction, and with good grounds. We also do not want Russia to support opposition groups in Ukraine to overthrow the government there or to seize territory. If you go that way, the world will become a very unsafe place.”

    Political pundits have recently argued in the Dutch daily NRC that in a war you end up with “getting your hands dirty”. But Nollkaemper finds this reasoning “dangerous” he says. “We have all committed ourselves to the rule of law. The rule of law applies in the Netherlands, but also for our foreign policy. It is very dangerous to ignore the law if matters become difficult. Here in the Netherlands, we also do not say, if it is useful for the prosecution of suspects, that we will just ignore the legal safeguards. Are we committed to the rule of law, or not?”

    The Ministry of Foreign Affairs asked for advice from its own lawyers regarding the support program, but Nollkaemper was not asked for advice.

    The Rutte government still does not want to make public the legal grounds on which it thought it would be able to implement the NLA programme. Lawmakers were only informed confidentially, and are therefore not allowed to speak about it publicly.

    Nollkaemper would prefer to see it differently: “I think the confidentiality that is now being enforced is a problem. The Middle East is a matter of great social and political importance, and that calls for an open debate in which justice also participates fully. If you choose to only disclose the legal arguments for confidentiality, you will keep hidden a very important part of the debate.”

    Nollkaemper has given his written opinion to the House. “My advise is that the system, as it was conceived, did not work adequately in this case,” he writes.

    The establishment of an external international adviser was intended to provide the government with sound legal advice on “important foreign issues”, and according to Nollkaemper there is “no doubt about it” that the support programme for Syria was an “important foreign issue”. And despite that, the government never asked him for advice.

    The Dutch government was aware – in detail – of the crimes committed by the Syrian rebel movement Jabhat al-Shamiya. This is evident from an email exchange from 2016 between Amnesty International and Foreign Affairs, which has been reviewed by Trouw and Nieuwsuur.

    In 1999, Nollkaemper established the Amsterdam Center for International Law (ACIL), which has become a centre of excellence at the University of Amsterdam and ranks amongst the top institutions for international law in the Netherlands.

    His practical experience includes cases before the European Court on Human Rights, the Special Court for Sierra Leone, the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia, the Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia, courts of the Netherlands and consultancy for a variety of international and national organisations.

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    Europe

    Swedish mother sexually assaulted outside asylum centre – media censored her description of the attacker

    DOCUMENTARYBoth media and the police refused to publish her description of an Afghani perpetrator after Mikaela, 40, was subjected to a rape attempt outside the asylum centre in a small village called Deje. Watch the Swedish documentary about the case with English subtitles.

    After Strasburg ‘the Yellow Vests must stop’ says Minister of Justice

    StrasburgAsked about the continued demonstrations by Yellow Vests in the context of the latest Strasbourg terror attack, French Justice Minister Nicole Belloubet said the movement "must stop", because President Emmanuel Macron has provided "answers" to their demands.

    Bamberg: Arrest warrants against migrants who wanted to kill policemen

    BambergGerman police in Bamberg had to send in reinforcements to end a migrant riot in the asylum reception center of the town. In the night of Tuesday even special forces were called in to bring the situation under control.

    Belgium faces government crisis as result of UN Global Migration Compact

    BrusselsThe dispute over the UN Compact on Migration has led to the end of the coalition government in Belgium. Unfazed, Prime Minister Charles Michel plans to continue as part of a minority government and will sign the agreement.

    An anti-immigration billboard campaign hits the streets of Brussels

    BrusselsA Hungarian counter-campaign has been launched against EU migrant propaganda spearheaded by EU heavyweight Guy Verhofstad, and is spreading on social media.

    Bullying and harassment at Sweden’s new Gender Equality Agency

    Sweden is often synonymous with feminist fanaticism. The country's Gender Equality Agency was opened in January this year and is thus one of its newest agencies. However, even before the government could celebrate a year, 70 percent of the staff are at risk of ill health and more than half suffer from burnout and fatigue. It seems the agency's disastrous workplace culture is related to its staunchly feminist leadership. There is not a single man in the "equal" management group.

    Macron and his wife discuss decorations with media while country burns

    ParisBetween the first two Saturdays of massive demonstrations by the Yellow Vests, Emmanuel and Brigitte Macron were redecorating their palace. They invited guests to the new "dialogue space" from which the Yellow Vests were conspicuously absent.

    German government funds brochure attacking natural gender roles

    BerlinIn true Stasi fashion, the Federal Ministry for Family Affairs in Germany has allegedly been funding a brochure for young children encouraging them to spy on their conservative parents.

    Macron backs down on climate change fuel tax

    ParisFrench President Emmanuel Macron has called for a six-month suspension of the government's proposed "climate change" fuel tax, backing down in the face of angry Yellow Vest protests throughout France for more than three weeks.

    After failed referendum Swiss anti-immigration party fears EU takeover

    BernAfter a failed sovereignist referendum in Switzerland on the encroaching powers of Brussels, the largest party in the Swiss parliament warned that the country was now facing a "massive erosion" of their unique democracy.

    Go to archive