Skip to Content

Stock photo from Pexels

Judge says German justice system is losing credibility

District Judge Stephan Zantke made headlines last December in Germany and his new book details biased judgement in the upper courts and an overburdened justice system. But some argue that the judge is part of the problem.

Published: October 9, 2018, 11:12 am

    A question that the judge from Zwickau had asked an accused asylum seeker, earned him the nickname Judge “Straightforward”. Zantke asked the migrant multiple offender: “If Germany is so shitty, why are you here?”

    The migrant suspect had insulted others as “Nazis” and “shit Germans” during a court case of property damage and personal injury.

    A year later, the judge has now published a book in which he describes this case as well as others. The question that made the judge famous, is also the title of his new book. He told German news outlet MDR that this trial was nothing special for him.

    “It is neither a very special case, nor a case – as is most cases – which I have judged, that somehow stand out.” The migrant serial offender had to spend only one night in police custody. It sounds incomprehensible, but it is German law, Stephan Zantke says.

    “I’m a normal judge, but one with a purpose. And the purpose is called consequence. This means that I am not prepared to give a suspect, who has repeatedly received parole, a chance to fail again – because he has already,” he told Bild newspaper.

    It is no exception that German regional courts often give milder judgments than local courts. “That happens daily. The district courts have a partially incomprehensible leniency that can interfere with the belief in a just punishment of the perpetrators in the population,” says Zantke.

    Above all, he criticises probation sentences that are repeatedly issued. “Next time there will be no probation – who should actually believe that? The offender? The defender? The prosecutor, who had demanded an imprisonment to be carried out? Or even the victims, who will meet the same culprit again on the street?”

    If such mild judgments in the upper courts are the order of the day in Germany, “then one can lose faith in justice”.

    The Zwickau judge also spoke out against austerity. “The judiciary has always been neglected,” he said. “If a lawsuit is left unfinished because there are not enough judges and the few [remaining] judges have to release prisoners for overdue deadlines, that’s a scandal to me.”

    Even though a migrant criminal had violently raped a young German medical student and tried to infect her with Hepatitis C, the same Zwickau judge had only given him 3 years and 10 months in prison, with some reports noting that it means “he’ll probably serve two [years]”.

    According to reports “every policeman in Zwickau knows him”, a 38-year-old Pakistani migrant who had deliberately bitten a 19-year-old German woman while raping her in order to infect her with Hepatitis C. And despite his heinous crime, he will not be deported either.

    The Pakistani with multiple criminal convictions who three months previously had been firing a blank pistol around in Zwickau city centre, pushed his victim into the smoking room, struck her in the face, and bit her deliberately in the lips. “He wanted to infect her with his virus,” said the assistant prosecutor Diana Enzinger-Leichsenring.

    But according to the Zwickau judge Zantke, justice was served.

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    Europe

    French Interior Ministry orders 40 000 new grenades

    ParisPlace Beauvau has ordered 40 000 new grenades for law enforcement after a tender was launched in August 2018, but the timing of the arrival of this "A2 category war material" is most unfortunate.

    German court allows jihadist criminal of 14 years to walk free

    DuesseldorfAn Islamic criminal, who has been in Germany for 14 years, remains at liberty despite a breach of his residence obligations, according to a Düsseldorf District Court.

    Salvini announces budget cuts for pro-migration associations

    RomeThe leftist funding party in Italy is coming to an end, after the announcement by Italian Interior Minister Matteo Salvini that a series of budgetary cuts will be aimed at migrant aid associations.

    Wilders calls for parliamentary enquiry into political meddling in his trail

    The HaguePVV leader Geert Wilders has called for a parliamentary inquiry into political interference in his trial in which he is being accused of "discrimination and inciting hatred" against people with a Moroccan background.

    Orban and Aung San Suu Kyi meet to discuss illegal immigration

    BudapestHungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban met with Myanmar’s State Counsellor, San Suu Kyi, to focus on illegal Islamic migration. The two held talks in Budapest on Wednesday in the Prime Minister’s Office.

    Act XXX: Yellow Vest numbers on the rise

    MontpellierOn Saturday, June 8, some 10 300 Yellow Vests mobilized throughout France, according to the Ministry of Interior, more than last week.

    German biologist faces court after linking gays to pedophilia

    KasselThe evolutionary biologist Ulrich Kutschera is facing German justice because of remarks he made scientifically linking homosexuality to pedophilia.

    French priest to be charged for singing anti-Macron songs

    The French prefect of Eure - a department in the north of France named after the river Eure - claims to have demanded that the prosecutor of the Republic step in after a priest sang an anti-Macron song.

    Hungary turns down Salvini offer to join EP ‘supergroup’

    BudapestHungary will not join Italian Deputy Prime Minister Matteo Salvini in the European Parliament, according to Prime Minister Viktor Orban’s chief of staff Gergely Gulyas.

    Malaysian PM says ‘no evidence’ that Russia shot down MH17

    TokyoThe Malaysian government says it has seen no conclusive evidence that Russia was responsible for the Malaysia Airlines flight MH17 tragedy in 2014, according to Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad.

    Go to archive