Skip to Content

Stock photo from Pexels

South Africa: ‘Only blacks’ medical programme ripped as racist

The South African province of KwaZulu-Natal has attempted to create 100 new positions in a training program for physicians reserved exclusively for black candidates.

Published: January 15, 2019, 8:18 am

    The racial quota was not met because of the lack of black applicants. The quota has been criticised as “racist” by opposition parties.

    As there were not enough black applicants, 21 positions were offered to non-black South Africans. The registrar programme, which spans fours years, trains doctors to become specialists.

    But the provincial health authority remained unforgiving despite its failure to do anything about its policies, saying, “South Africa, including KwaZulu-Natal, remains an uneven society with limited self-development opportunities for the historically oppressed.”

    Spokeswoman Ncumisa Mafunda added that the measure should “address these imbalances of the past”. But in the past – under Apartheid – black hospitals were staffed by black doctors.

    Mafunda said the racial discriminatory move was a “government imperative” and “the morally and socially right thing to do”. She told TimesLIVE that South Africa had limited opportunities for the self-development of blacks.

    Leaked documents revealed that the department was aiming to train a total of 366 black doctors and had already recruited 32 Indian, 12 white and four mixed race registrars, but need a further 100 black medics to meet racial employment equity targets.

    South Africa’s medical schools graduate some 1 800 students a year, according Martin Veller, who chairs the South African Committee of Medical Deans. At least two-thirds of these students are already black racial quota entrants.

    Mary de Haas, member of Medical Rights Advocacy Network (Meran) said the department has been mismanaging of their budget: “I think it is a very bad way of doing it. It’s not really fair to sideline people [whites] who have done extremely well.”

    De Haas added: “It [the health department] spent money sending students to Cuba instead of building local capacity, which would have sorted this out years ago.”

    More than 500 black students who spent six years in Cuba as part of the Nelson Mandela/Fidel Castro Medical Training programme, returned last year. But Steve Pheeha, an alumni of the programme, said the students are ill-prepared. “[In Cuba] you rarely see a person go into hospital with bullet wounds. At Bara [Chris Hani Baragwanath Academic, Africa’s largest black hospital built by the Apartheid government], you may see 10 people come in with these wounds in a matter of hours,” he explained.

    Last year, Health Minister Aaron Motsoaledi told Business Day the programme has become a headache for both countries and a decision had been taken in the National Health Council to scale it back. Critics have questioned the wisdom of training black doctors in Cuba at a far greater cost.

    A spokesman for the Democratic Alliance, an opposition party to the ruling African National Congress, argued that this policy is “a departure from our constitutional values ​​and racist”.

    The initiative by the authorities to appoint only blacks was also sharply criticised on Twitter. Many openly called it racist. “Let me understand – you should practice racism to eradicate racism – sounds logical,” one Twitter user noted.

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    • AnotherView

      The historically oppressed are now becoming the white populatioon!

    • Mavis Vermicast

      Merry Christmas Mr Lawrence


    South Africa: activist against farm attacks murdered at home

    The brutal killing of human-rights activist Annette Kennealy on her small farm has again placed South African farm murders in the spotlight.

    South Africa’s FF Plus party ‘could have done even better’

    During South Africa's recent parliamentary elections, the Freedom Front Plus almost trebled its number of votes to 414 844 and the number of its MPs in the national parliament increased from 4 to 10. Dan Roodt spoke to a long-standing and prominent party member, Werner Weber.

    South African election: Swing to the right amid fabricated consensus

    Despite ongoing and profound corruption within the ruling party, South Africa's electorate has given the ANC another five years of power. Among white Afrikaans voters, there is a swing to the right, however. FWM takes an exclusive look at the election.

    Diplomatic wife found guilty of fraud in ‘ghost teachers’ case

    In South Africa, being the wife of an MP or the spouse of an ambassador does not preclude you from engaging in fraud and embezzlement of funds destined for the education of small children, as the Portia Sizani case bears out.

    Three black attackers stab white farmer to death

    KirkwoodPolice have identified the name of the white man who was stabbed to death by black assaillants during a farm attack in Kirkwood on Sunday evening.

    Democrats took expensive trip to South Africa for Beyoncé concert

    Five House Democrats took a $60,000 trip to South Africa to attend the chaotic "Global Citizen Mandela 100" concert in Johannesburg that ended in criminal violence. Strangely, none of them had noticed anything while on their visit.

    South Africa: Grave of EFF’s favourite philosopher vandalised

    Karl Marx's memorial in Highgate Cemetery, London, in the UK has been vandalised, with parts of the Grade I listed monument's inscription damaged by a hammer-wielding individual. Britain's Highgate Cemetery regularly receives over 80 000 visitors a year, and this is the main sight that many of them come to see.

    Blacks threaten white genocide on Cape Town’s Clifton Beach

    The clash of civilisations and deteriorating race relations in South Africa have sunk even lower with the latest furore over the ritual killing of a sheep on a public beach by black 'anti-racist' protestors.

    Beyoncé’s Global Citizen concert ends in criminal chaos

    JohannesburgThe much-publicised 'Global Citizen' concert in Johannesburg exposed the criminal underbelly of the city, and the gross incompetence of its police officials as concertgoers were terrorised by gangs that one newspaper described as "hyenas" outside the stadium.

    South Africa’s ANC gearing up to grab white land

    PretoriaSouth Africa white farmer land grabs will be set in stone after change to the Constitution is approved.

    Go to archive