Skip to Content

Photo by Liesl Leonard on Unsplash.

Furore over British journal article on Coloured South African women

In South Africa's latest race controversy, an academic article published in the United Kingdom on the cognition of Coloured women is drawing fire.

Published: May 1, 2019, 11:56 am

    A media furore has erupted in South Africa over a scientific article published in a British academic journal, Aging Neuropsychology and Cognition, in which the effects of poverty and low education on Coloured women are discussed. The University of Stellenbosch has publicly apologised for its researchers having engaged in such research, although it was internationally peer-reviewed and passed a research ethics test.

    The article, entitled “Age- and education-related effects on cognitive functioning in Colored South African women” found that such women had “an increased risk for low cognitive functioning, as they present with low education levels and unhealthy lifestyle behaviors”.

    Although the findings from the five Stellenbosch researchers were passed by the international reviewers as reasonable and factually-based, their university has now all but denounced their work by issuing a statement saying:

    “We apologise unconditionally for the pain and the anguish which resulted from this article. We also have empathy towards current and past staff members, our students and our alumni who have had to endure criticism for their association with our institution.”

    The five academics concerned, Sharné Nieuwoudt, Kasha Elizabeth Dickie, Carla Coetsee, Elmarie Terblanche and Louise Engelbrecht, are now being threatened with a witch hunt as a result of the media outrage.

    According to the university’s deputy vice-chancellor for research, innovation and postgraduate studies, Professor Eugene Cloete, “The rectorate has… decided to request a thorough investigation into all aspects of this study, guided by the Stellenbosch University’s Policy for Responsible Research Conduct, as well as the university’s procedure for the investigation of allegations of breach of research norms and standards. Based on the outcome of this investigation, we will take corrective action, as required.”

    The five researchers belong to the university’s Sport Science department and they have previously published on health and fitness, including cognition and the prevalence of obesity in certain socioeconomic groups.

    For the current study, they used an international test known as the Montreal Cognitive Assessment that accord points on a scale of 30, measuring short-term memory recall, visuospatial abilities, verbal abstraction and orientation to time. It is commonly used to test for mental impairment in patients with dementia, Alzheimer’s disease or other neurological disorders. It is therefore not an IQ test, but an assessment of cognitive functioning.

    The five researchers conclude in their article that cognitive function among the target group of Coloured women correlated both with age and education level, which may not in itself seem controversial.

    However, the Psychological Society of South Africa denounced it as “racism”, saying: “We are disturbed by and strongly opposed to the practice of misusing racial classification in scientific research and the consequent perpetuation of stigma, discrimination and racism within our society, as exemplified in the recent publication.”

    The “Coloured” or mixed-race group in South Africa is also defined in legislation by the current ANC government, so conducting research on this group cannot be illegal. But the Psychology Society further denounced the study as “colonial”, stating that “(t)he article draws on colonial stereotypes of ‘coloured’ women, and portrays them as intellectually deficient, making broad, reckless and injurious generalisations on the basis of a flawed methodology”.

    The British-based journal, Aging Neuropsychology and Cognition, is published by Taylor & Francis, which belongs to a listed UK media and communications group, Informa UK Limited. It is also a member of the FTSE 100 group of the largest companies on the London Stock Exchange.

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.


    South Africa: activist against farm attacks murdered at home

    The brutal killing of human-rights activist Annette Kennealy on her small farm has again placed South African farm murders in the spotlight.

    South Africa’s FF Plus party ‘could have done even better’

    During South Africa's recent parliamentary elections, the Freedom Front Plus almost trebled its number of votes to 414 844 and the number of its MPs in the national parliament increased from 4 to 10. Dan Roodt spoke to a long-standing and prominent party member, Werner Weber.

    South African election: Swing to the right amid fabricated consensus

    Despite ongoing and profound corruption within the ruling party, South Africa's electorate has given the ANC another five years of power. Among white Afrikaans voters, there is a swing to the right, however. FWM takes an exclusive look at the election.

    Diplomatic wife found guilty of fraud in ‘ghost teachers’ case

    In South Africa, being the wife of an MP or the spouse of an ambassador does not preclude you from engaging in fraud and embezzlement of funds destined for the education of small children, as the Portia Sizani case bears out.

    Three black attackers stab white farmer to death

    KirkwoodPolice have identified the name of the white man who was stabbed to death by black assaillants during a farm attack in Kirkwood on Sunday evening.

    Democrats took expensive trip to South Africa for Beyoncé concert

    Five House Democrats took a $60,000 trip to South Africa to attend the chaotic "Global Citizen Mandela 100" concert in Johannesburg that ended in criminal violence. Strangely, none of them had noticed anything while on their visit.

    South Africa: Grave of EFF’s favourite philosopher vandalised

    Karl Marx's memorial in Highgate Cemetery, London, in the UK has been vandalised, with parts of the Grade I listed monument's inscription damaged by a hammer-wielding individual. Britain's Highgate Cemetery regularly receives over 80 000 visitors a year, and this is the main sight that many of them come to see.

    South Africa: ‘Only blacks’ medical programme ripped as racist

    The South African province of KwaZulu-Natal has attempted to create 100 new positions in a training program for physicians reserved exclusively for black candidates.

    Blacks threaten white genocide on Cape Town’s Clifton Beach

    The clash of civilisations and deteriorating race relations in South Africa have sunk even lower with the latest furore over the ritual killing of a sheep on a public beach by black 'anti-racist' protestors.

    Beyoncé’s Global Citizen concert ends in criminal chaos

    JohannesburgThe much-publicised 'Global Citizen' concert in Johannesburg exposed the criminal underbelly of the city, and the gross incompetence of its police officials as concertgoers were terrorised by gangs that one newspaper described as "hyenas" outside the stadium.

    Go to archive