Skip to Content

President Macron. Immigrants performing. Photo supplied
Paris

Quotas for migrants: Is France being ‘submerged’?

Is France being "overwhelmed" by migrants, as the former Minister of the Interior Gerard Collomb suggested? Only the lack of data available to French voters may guarantee a dispassionate debate on immigration.

Published: June 20, 2019, 8:39 am

    At the request of Emmanuel Macron, the Minister of the Interior Christophe Castaner announced on Sunday, June 16, in the Journal du dimanche (JDD) that a debate will be held in the National Assembly on immigration.

    Castaner pledged: “The issue of quotas can be raised in the context of the debate for other modes of legal immigration.” But he immediately added: “Let us also ensure that the debate on the immigration does not focus only on the number of immigrants.”

    It is difficult to understand how it is possible to organise a debate on migration quotas, without focusing on the question of “numbers”. The data on immigration appears to be the biggest French taboo.

    Under the leadership of former President Nicolas Sarkozy who praised “chosen immigration”, the annual debate on who France wants to welcome never saw the day. This careless attitude had created a huge disappointment among voters.

    Since then, political figures François Fillon, Laurent Wauquiez and Éric Ciotti, have stressed the need for the implementation of migrant quotas.

    But the sad circus of French political life under Emannuel Macron was on display on January 14, when MP for the Republicans Eric Ciotti asked the government once again to hold an annual debate on immigration. Laughing in his face, was Macron’s Minister Jacqueline Gourault. She sneered: “The introduction of quotas does not stand up to scrutiny for lack of feasibility.”

    One certainty, is that the French perceive immigration very negatively. And if they are already largely opposed to illegal immigration, they also want to reduce legal immigration significantly.

    In the JDD, on December 2, a survey conducted by Ifop highlighted anti-immigration public sentiment.

    Some 58 percent of French people dislike immigration in general, while 55 percent fear for the country’s future, 58 percent for its identity and 64 percent for the cohesion of society.

    The French have said it unambiguously: Some 64 percent think that welcoming additional immigrants is not desirable. Finally, 71 percent consider that it allows employers to drag wages down; and 60 percent believe immigrants should be chosen according to the economic needs of the country.

    There is no longer any doubt: the French want a calm debate on the issue of immigration. They want to regain control over the mass immigration that has hit their country.

    But two globalist politicians, Stella Dupont (LREM) and Jean-François Parigi (LR) have since estimated that the prices of residence permits was too high for people with a limited income.

    Their report was presented to the Finance Committee, reported LCP. At present, the price of a temporary authorization for residing on French territory costs from 269 euros up to 609 euros. The price of a passport is 89 euros and the identity card is free.

    In their report, the two deputies consider that the amounts practiced are “excessive” and “accentuate the precariousness of certain foreigners, even hinder their integration”. The Macronist Dupont deplored the fact that “immigrants are presented as profiteers while they pay more than nationals”.

    In addition, they advise issuing multi-year residence permits to extend payments for foreigners. According to the two MEPs, this estimated loss of 38 million euros can be offset by tourist visas, which should soon be increased.

    With the interference of Islam in society, France faces a major challenge. Communities are currently living “side by side” but it could soon become “face-to-face” as former Minister of the Interior Collomb noted when he left the Place Beauvau in October 2018 .

    “The communitarization of France is the direct consequence of multiculturalism and therefore massive immigration of the last thirty years,” explained one of his former collaborators.

    “All ministers of the Interior are aware of this, their daily lives are punctuated by the consequences of communitarianism. But it is impossible to point the finger at the two real problems: immigration and its direct link, Islam, ” continued the source.

    Collomb had warned in February 2018: “In five years, the situation could become irreversible.”

    Every year it is on average the equivalent of the population of the city of Rennes that arrives in France (over 200 000 people). That figure excludes the illegal arrivals. In 2018, a record was broken with 255 550 first residence permits issued by the State.

    Of the 100 000 obligations to leave French territory pronounced in 2018, only 12 percent were carried out. This means that 88 percent of the clandestines that the justice expels from French territory remain illegally.

    [mashshare]

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    Europe

    French Senator wants to ban Algerian flags on French soil

    MarseilleA French Senator has deplored the many Algerian flags seen in the streets of France after Algeria's victory in the CAN semi-final as well as the absence of the French flag.

    Macron loudly booed at Bastille Day parade

    ParisDuring the the Bastille Day military parade in France, President Emmanuel Macron was loudly booed as he was coming down the Champs-Élysées aboard a military command car.

    Génération Identitaire members risk imprisonment

    GapThree members of the movement were summoned by the French criminal court of Gap, Thursday, July 11, after an anti-immigrantion action organised in the spring of 2018, on the Franco-Italian border.

    German intel classify Identitarians as ‘right-wing extremist’

    The German domestic intelligence service, known as the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution, has classified the Identitarian Movement (IB) as "right-wing extremist".

    Number of British Christians at a record low

    LondonA survey to gauge British Social Attitudes (BSA) has revealed that the number of Christian believers in the country are at a record low.

    Hungary highlights weight of Visegrad and Baltic voters against immigration

    BudapestHungarian cabinet chief Antal Rogan told public radio on Sunday that the European Commission needs a leader who respected countries in Central Europe. Rogan was interviewed on Kossuth Radio.

    French police station attacked by youths shouting ‘Allah Akbar’

    A police station in the Eure was attacked by youths shouting "Allah Akbar".

    French aid workers refuse to hand over list of people in emergency accommodation

    Forty French aid associations called on the government to "give up" the measure requiring homeless shelters to send lists of refugees and asylum seekers to the authorities.

    Trouble in Tbilisi

    TsibilisiSince June 20, protests have swept Georgia. The unannounced start of the protests was done as a provocation. The consequences however, are utterly painful, especially for the average citizen of Georgia.

    Dutch parliament adopts motion against ‘racially-based land expropriation in South Africa’

    The Dutch parliament or Tweede Kamer at The Hague, has become the first elected body in Europe to express its opposition to the policy of "expropriation without compensation" adopted by South Africa's ANC regime against white Afrikaner farmers.

    Go to archive