Skip to Content

Climate whistleblower reveals massive cover-up, manipulation before Paris agreement

The British Mail on Sunday revealed that a landmark paper exaggerated global warming, duping world leaders into spending billions after being taken for a ride with manipulated global warming data.

Published: February 6, 2017, 8:06 am

    Read more

    The NOAA is set to face an inquiry by the Republican-led House science committee as a result of the flawed data.

    The data was timed to influence the Paris agreement on climate change. Climate data was rushed to publish a landmark paper containing exaggerated claims of warming in time for the historic Paris Agreement on global climate change.

    A high-level whistleblower the paper that America’s National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) breached its own rules on scientific integrity by publishing the flawed report.

    The sensational claim made at the UN climate conference in Paris in 2015, was that a “pause” or “slowdown” in global warming in the period since 1998 – revealed by UN scientists in 2013 – never existed.

    The paper, launched by NOAA, stated emphatically that world temperatures had been rising faster than scientists expected.

    Whistleblower, Dr John Bates, a top NOAA scientist, has shown The Mail on Sunday irrefutable evidence that the paper was based on misleading, unverified data and never subjected to the NOAA’s own rigorous internal evaluation process.

    Bates has accused the lead author of the paper, Thomas Karl, for the Pausebuster paper, rushed in time to influence national and international policy makers.

    According to Bates, “there needs to be a fundamental change to the way NOAA deals with data so that people can check and validate scientific results. I’m hoping that this will be a wake-up call to the climate science community – a signal that we have to put in place processes to make sure this kind of crap doesn’t happen again.

    “I want to address the systemic problems. I don’t care whether modifications to the datasets make temperatures go up or down. But I want the observations to speak for themselves, and for that, there needs to be a new emphasis that ethical standards must be maintained.”

    Official delegations have committed advanced nations to fossil fuel reductions and pouring billions every year into green projects. The extra “climate-related” aid to the developing world by rich nations, run into billions.

    Bates said he had decided to speak out after seeing fake news reports, including in the Washington Post and Forbes magazine, claiming that scientists feared the Trump administration would fail to “maintain and preserve NOAA’s climate records”.

    Bates said: “How ironic it is that there is now this idea that Trump is going to trash climate data, when key decisions were earlier taken by someone whose responsibility it was to maintain its integrity – and failed.”

    The scandal has disturbing echoes of the ‘Climategate’ affair which broke shortly before the UN climate summit in 2009, when leaked emails between climate scientists suggested they had manipulated and hidden data.

    NOAA’s 2015 “Pausebuster” paper was based on two new temperature sets of data – one containing measurements of temperatures at the planet’s surface on land, the other at the surface of the seas. Both datasets were flawed and a final, approved version has still not been issued.

    Neither has the data on which the paper was based been archived – a mandatory requirement meant to ensure that raw data and the software used to process it is accessible to other scientists to be checked.

    A report from the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), which drew on the work of hundreds of scientists around the world, had found “a much smaller increasing trend over the past 15 years 1998-2012 than over the past 30 to 60 years”.

    Thus explaining the pause became a key issue for climate science.

    The impact was massive and lasting. On publication day, the BBC said the pause in global warming was “an illusion caused by inaccurate data”. One American magazine described the paper as a “science bomb” dropped on sceptics.

    Data was actually changed to make the sea appear warmer, Bates said: “They had good data from buoys. And they threw it out and ‘corrected’ it by using the bad data from ships. You never change good data to agree with bad, but that’s what they did – so as to make it look as if the sea was warmer.”

    Karl’s study “adjusted” buoy readings up by 0.12C. It also ignored data from satellites that measure the temperature of the lower atmosphere, which are also considered reliable. Bates said he gave the paper’s co-authors “a hard time” but “they never really justified what they were doing”.

    In the weeks following the publication of the Pausebuster paper, Bates continued his dogged one-man investigation. He revealed that the failure to archive and make available fully documented data, violated NOAA rules.

    Before he retired last year, he continued to investigate the matter: “I learned that the computer used to process the software had suffered a complete failure.” The reason for the failure is unknown, but it means the Pausebuster paper can never be replicated or verified by other scientists.

    Karl moreover had a longstanding relationship with President Obama’s chief science adviser, John Holdren, with a direct hotline to the White House.

    The NOAA not only failed, but it effectively proceeded with a cover-up when challenged over its data. After the paper was published, the US House of Representatives Science Committee launched an inquiry into its Pausebuster claims. NOAA refused to comply with subpoenas demanding internal emails from the committee chairman, the Texas Republican Lamar Smith, and falsely claimed that no one had raised concerns about the paper internally.

    President Trump has since pledged to withdraw from the Paris Agreement.

    Jeremy Berg, Science’s editor-in-chief, said: “Dr Bates raises some serious concerns. After the results of any appropriate investigations… we will consider our options.” He said that “could include retracting that paper”.

    Consider donating to support our work

    Help us to produce more articles like this. FreeWestMedia is depending on donations from our readers to keep going. With your help, we expose the mainstream fake news agenda.

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    Americas

    Does climate influence the spread of the Coronavirus?

    Studies and observations on the relationship between climate and the Covid-19 pandemic are multiplying. A cold and dry climate create the worst conditions, while temperatures above 18 degrees and a humid climate slows down the virus some say.

    Mearsheimer: The collapse of the liberal world order

    The days of liberal hegemony may be numbered. John J. Mearsheimer, one of the most important and influential scholars of international relations in the world and distinguished professor of Political Science at the University of Chicago, and one of the most famous exponents of the school of contemporary political realism, which has roots and tradition in Machiavelli and Hobbes, thinks so.

    World’s largest lithium mine will impact on geopolitics

    In Mexico, in the Sonora region, there is the largest lithium mine ever discovered so far in the world. Its probable reserves are estimated at 243,8 million tons and lithium carbonate, the mineral from which it is extracted the metal amounts to 4,5 million tons.

    Cyborg Soldiers 2050: The future of the Pentagon

    According to what has been formalized by the US Army's Combat Capabilities Development Command, the US military will be able to see the first enlistments made up of personnel which are half human and half machine, integrated into their military apparatus within ten years.

    US: Second Amendment Sanctuaries are exploding

    In the rural areas of Virginia, in the United States, citizens are clinging to guns and religion: They have voted overwhelmingly to declare their localities Second Amendment Sanctuaries.

    Culture wars: Pro-Israel supporters versus Groypers

    While the political mainstream in the United States has turned its attention to the impeachment of Donald Trump, something else has been happening from a conservative perspective: an ideological civil war has broken out in the right-wing camp.

    Greta Thunberg mural uses thousands of litres of noxious aerosol paint

    San FranciscoControversy has been following climate activist Greta Thunberg to San Francisco too. The American city is struggling with environmental issues, not the least of which is a human feces crisis on the streets currently plaguing inhabitants and terrible air quality.

    CNN not a source of news but a shameless propaganda outlet

    According to a conservative activist group, CNN has no interest in reporting news. The network is focused solely on anti-conservative propaganda.

    Ukraine-gate: Complaint form revised just days ahead of impeachment proceedings

    WashingtonThere is a strange coincidence regarding the recent whistleblower complaint filed by a CIA officer against President Trump and a revised complaint form.

    Appeal of 500 scientists: ‘There is no climate emergency’

    New YorkMore than 500 scientists have contradicted the thesis of man-made climate change in a letter to UN Secretary-General António Guterres.

    Go to archive