Skip to Content

German media as well as police underreport migrant crime

The German Sächsische Zeitung, based in the eastern city of Dresden has adopted a policy of reporting migrant crime. Since July of last year, its policy is to always report the nationality of people who commit crimes.

Published: April 2, 2017, 11:51 am

    Read more

    This was prompted by a reader survey carried out by communication scientist Lutz Hagen. He said that almost half of those surveyed thought that journalists had been ordered to leave out the ethnicity of criminals because of the current migration crisis.

    Another survey is due to be conducted in a year’s time. Hagen’s hypothesis is that reporting about the nationality of criminals will result in readers’ being better able to more accurately assess the share of crimes committed by foreigners, expressing the hope that such crime would eventually be lower than expected.

    The experiment could also have negative consequences, warned Georg Ruhrmann, an expert on the portrayal of migrants in the media. “Depending on the attitudes and routines of individual journalists, you could see more stereotypes or discriminatory statements filtering through,” he said. It could appeal to readers who hold “racist or anti-immigrant views”.

    Last month the German Press Council — a voluntary, industry-run body — concluded that ethnicity could not be published “unless there is a justified public interest in doing so”. Journalists and the “Lügenpresse” (lying press) have however felt the pressure of the anti-immigrant Alternative for Germany party.

    The new wording replaces previous guidelines that said such details should only be published if there was a link between a person’s ethnicity or religion and the crime. But withholding such information left readers suspecting the media of covering up migrant crimes.

    The thefts and mass sexual assaults of women during the 2015/16 New Year’s Eve festivities in Cologne were eventually young men of “North African or Arab descent” after the media deliberately avoided any mention of the crimes or ethnicity, citing “professional ethical guidelines”.

    A recent study by the University of Munich showed that several weeks after New Year’s Eve, newspapers tended to mention the ethnicity of perpetrators much more than they did previously, because they were caught in a cover-up.

    But the new media guidelines on migrant crime, might not be enough, because the actual number of migrant-related sex crimes in Germany is at least two or three times higher than the official number.

    Only 10 percent of the sex crimes committed in Germany appear in the official statistics, says André Schulz, head of the Criminal Police Association. Strangely accurate statistics are notoriously non-existent in one of the most technologically advanced countries in the world.

    According to Federal Criminal Police Office (Bundeskriminalamt, BKA) data includes only crimes that have been solved (aufgeklärten Straftaten). According to police statistics, on average only around half of all crimes committed in Germany in any given year are solved (Aufklärungsquote).

    Moreover, BKA crime statistics do not include data from North Rhine-Westphalia, the most populous state in Germany and the one with the largest number of migrants, or from Hamburg, the second-largest city in the country.

    An even more toxic practice is for police deliberately to omit any references to migrants in crime reports. This lapse makes it impossible for the media and therefore German citizens to understand the true scale of migrant crime.

    Germany’s sclerotic justice system exacerbates the problem by imposing seemingly interminable delays of several months in bringing migrant perpetrators to justice. In all police files from January 2017, migrants have no stated ethnicity, but are either called “dark-skinned” or “southern looking”.

    In a recent note for media editors by police it was stated: “The legal basis for publishing the surveillance photos has been dispensed with. We strongly urge you to take this into account in future reporting and to remove and/or make changes to existing publications.”

    Consider donating to support our work

    Help us to produce more articles like this. FreeWestMedia is depending on donations from our readers to keep going. With your help, we expose the mainstream fake news agenda.

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    • Jaka

      “”1984″”

    Europe

    France could offer its UN permanent seat to EU

    ParisFrance's seat at the UN could be given to the European Union to promote the creation of an EU standing force after Australia made it clear that it would be pursuing nuclear technology for its submarines together with the US and UK.

    Italy: Nationwide house raids against vaccine opponents

    MilanThe Milan Public Prosecutor's Office has launched searches of anti-vaccination opponents in six Italian cities. Allegedly the members of the Telegram group "The Warriors" planned violent demonstrations against the Covid-19 policy of the Italian government.

    Orban offers Pope copy of 1250 letter in which a Hungarian king pleads for help against Tartar invasion

    BudapestDuring his visit to Budapest on Sunday to celebrate mass, Pope Francis met with Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban, whose anti-migration policy in Hungary he does not share. The Pope received a copy of a letter reminding him why he should be more circumspect in his views.

    EMA: Almost a third of Covid vaccination side effects are severe

    BrusselsThe reported suspected side effects for the four Covid vaccines, which have only been conditionally approved in the EU, are record-breaking after just 8 months. Serious side effects have been reported.

    Breaking news: UK government drops Covid passport

    LondonIn the UK, Health Minister Sajid Javid has told the BBC that Covid passports will not be introduced in his country. When will European countries come to their senses?

    France: Thousands protest against ‘health pass’ for 9th weekend in a row

    ParisOn Saturday, demonstrators took to the streets in the French capital for the ninth consecutive weekend to express their displeasure with the health passport policy of the Macron administration. The protest quickly degenerated into clashes with the police.

    Key Dutch ministers in bed with the WEF

    The HagueAt the end of May, the Forum for Democracy led by Thierry Baudet, submitted a parliamentary question on the relations between cabinet members and Klaus Schwab's World Economic Forum. "We received evasive or even no answers to these questions," said Dutch MP Pepijn van Houwelingen.

    Marine Le Pen’s phone number leaked on social networks

    ParisThe cellphone number of the president of the National Rally was published on social networks. Many strangers called her, forcing her to change her number and file a complaint.

    Hungarian teacher promises better grades to vaccinated children

    TamasiParents have complained about the biology teacher at the Würtz Ádám Primary School and Elementary Art School in Tamasi, Hungary, because he wanted to reward students who had been vaccinated against the Coronavirus and punish those who had not received the jab.

    Serious vaccination side effects increase by a factor of 114 in Switzerland

    BernAccording to the Swiss regulatory authority, 137 people have died after the mRNA injections since the start of the vaccination campaign. And the serious side effects after the mRNA injections continue to increase.

    Go to archive