Skip to Content

Not minors. Photo supplied

Italy: ‘Minors accepted, but they are 40 years old’

Immigrants declare an age, but to verify it is very difficult. Thus they end up in structures that cost the Italian taxpayer between 70 to 100 euros a day.

Published: September 10, 2019, 11:46 am


    There are many, and almost all of them obtain a residence permit and are housed without distinction in expensive reception facilities. The unaccompanied foreign minors represent a large part of the approximately 500 000 migrants that arrived in Italy between 2015 and 2019.

    Many minors are not children in need of care. Some “don’t have hair”, others look “35 years”, yet they are welcomed as if they are children.

    The data shows that of the 7 580 immigrants registered in Italy as minors, over 63 percent are 17 years old and another 22,5 percent are 16. The “children” in the 0-14 age group number only 502. Is it possible that almost only youngsters have decided to take the sea route via the Mediterranean to reach Italy?

    At the end of January the attorney of Syracuse, Antonio Scavone, boarded the Sea Watch 3 anchored offshore, and noted that “some minors have a dubious age because they have no documents with them”. The prosecutor also noted that the asylum seekers had all declared “as a birth date January 1” or only the year (2002) which, incidentally, allowed them to define themselves as 17 years old.

    In Friuli Venezia Giulia, Antonio Calligaris, the League party’s regional councillor told “Pakistanis and Afghans declare themselves minors but, very often, they are over 40”. Of the 498 “minors” registered in the third quarter of 2018, 93,8 percent are between 16 and 17 years old. Of these, 87 percent come from Kosovo, Pakistan, Albania and Afghanistan.

    “Some of them have white hair”, says Karim, living in housing for minors in which the oldest of the “fake” young people “is over 30 years old” and should not be there.

    The problem is that nobody checks carefully. “When I arrived,” explained Mohamed, a former guest in a center for MSNA [minor accommodation, ed.], “I declared a date of birth but the authorities did not check.”

    He pointed out: “I was born in Pakistan in 1995, but my parents registered me in 1997.” But no one has investigated his true age.

    The police have their hands tied. “The practice is that they declare an age and the story ends there”, explained an agent who asked to remain anonymous. Italy trusts their words. “The investigations are carried out only if the minor commits serious crimes,” added the policeman. “The trick is also known to them” and they take full advantage of it.

    To change the rules of the game is very difficult because Article 5 of the law on this issue states that “if there is doubt as to the stated age” the immigrant after trying the diplomatic channels, may be ordered by the Court to submit to a social and health assessment. But it has many limitations. “The error range is 3-4 years,” explained the agent. And so the law dictates that, in case doubts remain about age, “it is presumed for all legal purposes”.

    For the State to verify every single case would be a considerable expenditure of energy. Migrants thus exploit a broken system: they arrive in Italy, declare themselves minors and get all the benefits.

    In fact, to obtain a residence permit for minors is much easier, because only 26 percent of them do not qualify for the asylum. The figure is very different for the average adult, who in 67 percent of cases are denied and must return to the country of origin.

    The burden for tax payers is mind-boggling: For 2020 and 2021, a cost of 170 million euros is expected. “The structures cost from 70 to 100 euros per day per migrant,” explained Luca Colussi, legal guardian of the minors. The amount is almost twice as big as for an adult immigrant.

    “It does not seem right that in structures for boys they end up there in the 40s. It would be enough to carry out checks to save a lot of money and not provide services to those who do not deserve it,” said Calligaris.

    Consider donating to support our work

    Help us to produce more articles like this. FreeWestMedia is depending on donations from our readers to keep going. With your help, we expose the mainstream fake news agenda.

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.


    Instability in Northern Africa: AFRICOM brigades, Russian planes and Syrian jihadists

    TripoliOn May 30, the US Africa Command (AFRICOM) released a statement in which its commander, Stephen Townsend, expressed to Tunisian Defence Minister Imed Hazgui readiness to deploy the US Security Force Assistance Brigades in Tunisia, citing concerns about Russian activities in Libya.

    Security and privacy experts sound the alarm on contact tracing apps

    The terrorist acts of September 11, 2001 became the starting point for massive surveillance of the world's citizens, and not least in Western countries such as the United States and the United Kingdom.

    Maghreb singer accuses French police of blanket racism

    ParisFor the deputy of the National Rally in France, the speech of the singer Camélia Jordana on Saturday evening claiming she is afraid when she sees a police officer, is a typical example of the excesses of the cultural left: They prefer to defend the delinquents rather than the police.

    Provocative statements from Turkey against Greece continue

    IstanbulThe Turkish Minister of Defense, Hulusi Akar during his visit to a Turkish naval base, spoke of "harassment in the Aegean" in recent days, which he described as a "very serious challenge", adding that he could not "explain them".

    The controversy over hydroxychloroquine intensifies

    WashingtonAmerican scientists concluded in a study that chloroquine was ineffective against Covid-19. The release of the study coincided with bad news about the US drug Remdesivir.

    Deaths in Swedish nursing homes hidden by municipalities

    In the "humanitarian superpower" Sweden, the management of the Covid-19 pandemic by public health authorities has defied the most basic sense of medical ethics.

    German politician: ‘Why should we risk our relations with China?’

    BerlinDr. Maximilian Krah, member of the European Parliament for the Eurosceptic Alternative für Deutschland (AfD) and Vice Chairman of the EP China Friendship Group in an exclusive FreeWestMedia interview.

    Senior European WHO official predicts second deadly virus wave

    LondonAccording to information from a British daily, a senior European official of the WHO predicts that a second peak of the virus outbreak could coincide with outbreaks of other infectious diseases.

    Thousands demonstrate in Germany against confinement

    BerlinThousands of Germans demonstrated nationwide again this weekend against Corona confinement requirements. Citizens who are afraid for their jobs, rallied alongside extremists and opponents of vaccination.

    Covid-19 information ‘better on YouTube than in traditional media’

    MarseilleThe world-renowned French virologist from Marseille, Prof Didier Raoult, believes that he is being identified as a "fake news" propagator because he discloses information buried by the mainstream media.

    Go to archive