Skip to Content

Paul Craig Roberts. Photo supplied

The marginalization of white people

On the morning of January 27, 2020, on NPR I heard a white female novelist describe her difficulty in getting her novel published. The problem was not that her novel was uninteresting or badly written.

Published: February 3, 2020, 9:25 am

    Her problem was that one of the characters was black. Unbeknownst to her, it is now considered cultural imperialism or cultural trespassing — some such term — for a person with white skin to write about even fictional people of color.

    Publishers liked her novel, but were afraid to publish it. They told the novelist that publishing her book would bring them charges of insensitivity toward blacks and be regarded as a sign of their disrespect of the maxim that only blacks can know about blacks. Her problem was not that she was writing insensitively about blacks, but that it is now considered insensitive for a white person to invade black culture by having a black character in a novel.

    The novelist seemed to agree with this perspective. Her defense was that as she had lived with a black man for many years, she was familiar with blacks and thereby qualified to have a black character in her novel.

    Another woman on the program said that the way publishers are dealing with this new problem is to send the manuscript to a “sensitivity checker” who can make suggestions that if implemented gives the book a “sensitivity approval.” She did say that even with this safeguard, the subjective nature of what is considered insensitive can still rise up and bite the publisher.

    Thinking about this new constraint on the creativity of white writers, I realized that little of the great literature that we have could have been written under this rule. For example, Shakespeare could not have written Othello.

    One wonders if this is a two-way street. Are black writers banned from having white characters in their novels? Would this also be cultural intrusion, trespassing or imperialism? Probably not. This seems to be yet another offense of which only white people can be guilty.

    The program brought to mind what I had recently read about white professors and administrators at Cambridge University in England being assigned a person of color as their monitor to make certain that language, lectures, reading lists, and university policies did not offend a sensitive student of color.

    The report did not say whether black professors and administrators at Cambridge have white monitors to prevent blacks from calling whites “racist,” “white supremacists,” and so on. If so, there will be big changes in “black studies” programs.

    All of the constraints seem to be for whites only. They alone are marginalized and have their voices muzzled and creativity limited.

    One assumes that feminists will want to get in on this and that this road also will be a one-way street. It will be gender imperialism or gender trespassing for male novelists to have female characters.

    Just as whites are not blacks and cannot be trusted to write about blacks, men are not women and can’t be trusted to write about women.

    University faculties punish whites for “insensitivity” toward people of color and punish white heterosexual males for “insensitivity” toward females. This happens whether the insensitivity was intended or simply in the mind of the offended. These same faculties host “women’s studies” and “black studies” in which white people are routinely described as “racist” and white heterosexual males as misogynists and rapists. I assume there are now “transgender studies” which has its own epithets to throw. What we are experiencing is the marginalization of the majority by minorities.

    What will be the result of giving protective status to the violent language of anti-white, anti-male minorities while muzzling the majority? Why is there no public discussion of this dangerous fomenting of social disunity?

    pcroberts@freewestmedia.com

    Exclusively for freewestmedia.com

    Consider donating to support our work

    Help us to produce more articles like this. FreeWestMedia is depending on donations from our readers to keep going. With your help, we expose the mainstream fake news agenda.

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    • pcl

      Anonymous speech is still free. The recent examples of “It’s OK to be white.” signs being posted on campus and “Islam is right about women.” signs being posted in the center of ultra-liberal Winchester, MA are examples of what should be happening everywhere. Whether people agree or disagree with them, messages like this, and the insane reactions to them, force people to think, rather than feel, about how far down the rabbit hole we’ve gone.

      • End PC

        Agree, we need more devices like these signs to stimulated conversations that expose the left’s insane PC positions.

    Opinion

    Sweden’s decaying democracy

    A journalist is arrested and dragged out of the Gothenburg Book Fair because he politely asked a powerful politician... the wrong questions about his support for the ethnically-cleansed Zimbabwean dictatorship. Not only journalists, but academics and bloggers are being hounded by the leftist establishment daily. And the leftists have all the nasty instruments of the state at their disposal. Citizen reporter Fabian Fjälling looks into their excesses.

    The geopolitical future of Nordic countries

    Between unity and disunity, independence and foreign interference: Nordic countries have to either choose between creating an independent neutral block in the North, or seeing the region being divided between the great powers.

    Russian, Chinese intelligence: ISIS heading for Central Asia with US cover

    Operatives of the crumbling Islamic State in Syria and Iraq (ISIS) are moving to new battlegrounds near the Russian border, intelligence sources have revealed.

    The unraveling of US/Russian relations

    Washington has taken nuclear war against Russia from a hypothetical scenario to a real danger that threatens the future of humanity. 

    Hero commander killed in Syria – when the war is nearly won

    For most Syrians it came as a shock: One of the most popular military commanders of the Syrian Arab Army, Issam Zahreddine, was killed on 18 October 2017.

    What Is The Obama Regime Up To?

    Obama has announced new sanctions on Russia based on unsubstantiated charges by the CIA.

    Kevork Almassian: Aleppo resisted and triumphed

    OPINIONEven the Western Mainstream Media couldn’t hide the celebrations and the joy of the civilians in Aleppo, who expressed their gratitude to the Syrian Army and Russia.

    Lebanon’s new president: Michel Aoun

    COMMENT

    Ukrainian Terror and Donbass referendum: What we can learn from the latest events in Donetsk

    OPINIONThe assassination of Donbass field commander Arsen “Motorola” Pavlov on October 16 can be seen as a new escalation of the war scenario in former Eastern Ukraine. The successful elimination of one of the most popular commanders of the independence war of Donbass brought that geopolitical hotspot – despite the events in Syria´s Aleppo – back in Western mainstream media.

    Renaud Camus

    The Great Replacement and the tragedy of Sweden

    Go to archive