Skip to Content

Mila on Instagram. Screenshot

The Mila affair rocks France

The Mila affair, named after a young girl threatened by a cohort of Muslim fanatics, has ignited the religious debate in France.

Published: February 3, 2020, 7:49 am

    On January 19, on her Instagram account dedicated to singing, the high school student talks to her subscribers in a live stream. During the stream, the teenager starts mocking Islam. Upset, one subscriber explodes with anger and insults Mila. Quickly, other internet users join in the hostilities: “Dirty white”, “French shit” and other religious imprecations: “Inshallah. Die, you dirty whore”, “Bitch, […] I hope you will burn in hell.”

    Several personalities have defended an impious adolescent in the media denouncing her abandonment by the French political-media class.

    Threatened with death as a result of her criticism, in particular, of Islam, the adolescent is currently in such danger that no educational establishment in France, for the time being, wants to accommodate her.

    The Islamists are so powerful in France that the state can no longer protect their targets, according to the Richard Malka, lawyer of Charlie Hebdo and the young Mila. The latter, who openly criticized all religions, including Islam, has had to give up attending school. Worse still: she has been unable to find an establishment capable of ensuring her safety.

    “The Ministry of Education is concerned about it, the rectorate is concerned about it, and is trying to find solutions – I am in no way questioning their good will – but the fact is that we cannot find an establishment in which the safety of this young girl will be assured today,” explained Richard Malka to BFM TV, on Thursday, January 29, saying that “it’s still dizzying”.

    On January 18, French daily Le Monde reported that Mila had rejected a subscriber’s advances. Because she rejected the man, he called her a racist. The girl then said that she “rejected all religions” and responded that she was not at all racist.

    She later added: “I hate religion, […] in the Quran there is only hatred in there, Islam is shit. […] I said what I thought about it, you are not going to make me regret it. There are still people who will get excited, I clearly don’t give a damn, I say what I want, what I think. Your religion is shit, your God, I put a finger in its asshole, thank you, goodbye.”

    Some conservative public figures at least denounced the “disturbing double standard” that we see depending on the religion under attack. After Malka defended in a column published in Le JDD the “right to blasphemy”, Elisabeth Badinter, in a text published on February 1 in L’Express and co-signed by the eminent Élisabeth de Fontenay, Marcel Gauchet, Jacques Julliard and Jean-Pierre Le Goff, warned that the debate had taken a dangerous turn.

    Their observation was very severe: “We will pay dearly for this cowardice,” they warned because Mila’s rant has forced her to drop out of school. “We can disagree with what the girl says, whether or not to appreciate her vocabulary, but nothing she says is illegal,” noted the signatories, recalling that the same was true for humorist Frédéric Fromet, whose song about Jesus at the microphone of France Inter sparked controversy.

    The great difference however is that the teenager has been prosecuted for “provoking racial hatred”, while Frédéric Fromet never faced the same treatment.

    The Mila affair has sent leftist politicians in a tailspin, with most expressing confused notions on the issue.

    The ex-ambassador of the Poles, Ségolène Royal, said she did not condone the behavior of the teenager threatened with death and harassed for her remarks on Islam, calling on her to show “respect”.

    She has been the target of thousands of threats since her insulting remarks against Islam. When asked if she would support the hashtag #JesuisMila, Royal said: “Absolutely not!”

    Royal was interviewed on France3 television on Sunday, February 2. She went so far as to criticize the teenager aged just 16 years, because she was being held up as the “paragon of freedom of expression”.

    To the question “should freedom of speech on religions be total?” the ex-presidential candidate of 2007, became particularly confused: “There is a freedom to criticize religions, but I refuse to hold the debate on secularism based on the declarations of a 15-year-old girl, because it is not from behaviors like these that we can seriously debate the question of secularism.”

    The schoolgirl, according Ségolène Royal, is perhaps experiencing “an adolescence crisis at the moment”.

    “If she had said the same thing about her teacher, about her parents, about her neighbour, about her girlfriend, we would have simply said: ‘A little respect’.”

    Thus, according to Royal, it is the poor education of young Mila that therefore explains her Islamophobic remarks. “Criticizing a religion does not prevent having respect, education, knowledge, being intelligent about what one says, and certainly does not warrant a teenager who lacks respect being held up as the paragon of freedom of expression,” she concluded.

    Royal was not the only confused leftist to wade into the debate. “We can criticize a religion, but we do not have the right to criticize people who practice it,” said Martine Aubry during a Lille city council meeting.

    Justice Minister Nicole Belloubet claimed that insulting religion was “against freedom of conscience”. The Minister told Europe 1 radio: “In a democracy, death threats are unacceptable (…) Insulting religion is obviously an attack on freedom of conscience, it is serious, but it has nothing to do with a death threat.” A former Socialist Minister said Belloubet should be given a “zero in constitutional law”.

    Finally, Raquel Garrido, the former spokesperson for La France insoumise, said it was a “big diversion operation” on the part of the government in an attempt to make people forget the mobilization against pension reform.

    Garrido, the ex-spokesperson for the leftist party, estimated that the Mila affair was used by the executive to divert attention from ongoing strikes, putting forward the notion of a conspiracy.

    “Why are the government and the political elites taking up the religious question at this time?”asked Raquel Garrido. “It is so that we stop talking about the biggest social movement that our country has known since the post-war period,” she explained.

    The laughter of the audience did not make Garrido budge. “You are accomplices, at your expense, of a great diversion operation,” she said.

    If the theory according to which the French government is at the origin of the Mila affair seems indeed very improbable, it cannot be denied that the political attention on a subject so sensitive logically has the effect of giving less media space to pension reform.

    Consider donating to support our work

    Help us to produce more articles like this. FreeWestMedia is depending on donations from our readers to keep going. With your help, we expose the mainstream fake news agenda.

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    • LuciusAnnaeusSeneca

      The response of the French left to the “Mila Affair”, as reported here, is reprehensible, and craven. Clearly the French left, and many others in government and public affairs, are in fear of the Muslims and the power they are now showing. Some may argue that French society is not yet under siege by the Muslim migrant community, but no one would argue that this will not be the future reality unless a strong push-back by the Macron regime begins against the campaign of terror described in this article, and against other excesses by the Muslim migrant community. However, the Macron regime’s record has shown that little if anything can be hoped for from the pro-mass migration regime now esconced iin Paris.

    • dcnj

      Round them up boot them out. Once one country does it the rest will follow. Islam will never be compatible with the western white world.


    Judiciary in a hurry to move against Salvini

    It appears that the Italian judiciary is in a hurry to move against former Interior Minister Matteo Salvini. The offices of the investigating magistrate of Catania have already received the official request of the prosecutor to set a preliminary hearing in the context of the proceeding against the Salvini "kidnapping" case.

    The grip of Soros on the ECHR revealed by French weekly

    ParisIn its latest issue, a French weekly revealed the extent of the influence of Georges Soros, the Hungarian billionaire at the head of the NGO network Open Society Foundations, on the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR).

    European Commissioner of the Interior defends asylum after ECHR ruling

    BrusselsThe European Commissioner of the Interior defended the right of migrants to ask for asylum, and even though this right “cannot be offered at each meter of the border” it should be, she argued.

    Orban: ‘It’s forbidden to say so in Europe, but migration is an organised invasion’

    Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban on Thursday warned of a rise in the number of organised groups of migrants attempting to enter the country as summer approaches as migration pressure increases on the country's southern border.

    More than 120 daily stabbing attacks in France

    ParisIn total, between 2015 and 2017, some 44 000 people were victims of a stabbing attack in France.

    The emergence of Europe’s ‘big four’

    BrusselsIt's Europe's "big four" - new axis between four major countries of the European Union,  trying to take the place of the Franco-German axis, which has been in crisis due to the continuous divergences between Paris and Berlin.

    Salvini faces up to 15 years in prison for stopping illegal immigration

    RomeDuring his year at the head of the Italian Ministry of the Interior, Matteo Salvini never stopped fighting illegal immigration. The boss of the League in Italy is accused of kidnapping because he blocked a boat of illegal migrants off the coast of Sicily when he was Minister of the Interior.

    AfD files criminal charges against Merkel for coercion

    BerlinIn the case of the Thuringian Prime Minister Thomas Kemmerich (FDP), who was forced to resign, the AfD has announced that it will report Chancellor Angela Merkel (CDU) for coercion.

    Dutch parties demand that FvD be excluded from coalition

    The HagueDutch party leaders have urged the VVD in the province of Brabant to rule out a coalition with the Forum voor Democratie after the province’s government collapsed. The VVD, the People's Party for Freedom and Democracy, is a liberal political party in the Netherlands.

    Migrants mass at Hungary’s border to test Orban’s resolve

    A group of hundreds of migrants that recently set off for Hungary from Serbia has reached Hungary’s southern border at Tompa, Hungarian public television’s current affairs channel M1 reported on Thursday.

    Go to archive