Skip to Content

Stock photo from Pixabay

Brussels suing Austria for child benefit regulation

The EU Commission has brought Austria to the European Court of Justice over the child benefit scheme for EU citizens that has been in effect since 2019. The laws are discriminatory and therefore violate EU law, the highest EU authority claimed on Thursday.

Published: May 16, 2020, 9:33 am


    The previous Austrian administration comprising of the ÖVP and FPÖ parties decided in 2018 to adjust child benefit payments to the living expenses of the state in which the child lives. As a result, for example Romanians working in Austria received fewer benefits if their children lived in their home country. According to calculations, the Austrian government saved around 100 million euros by doing so.

    However, according to Brussels, these rules contradict EU law. Therefore, the EU Commission initiated an infringement procedure against Austria in early 2019. The rule violates “the existing rules on the coordination of social security and is discriminatory, since some mobile EU workers who fully contribute to Austria’s economy, employment and social security receive lower benefits than those whose children are in Austria live”.

    This is because indexing with lower payments does not apply, for example, to Austrians who work abroad for an Austrian authority and whose children live with them there, even though their situation is comparable to workers from the countries mentioned.

    Austria’s Minister of Family Affairs Christine Aschbacher (ÖVP) defended the regulation. “Because of the different cost of living in the EU, it remains a question of justice for us,” said the ÖVP politician on Thursday. The EU Commission could of course ask the Court of Justice “if it has doubts about the compatibility of indexing under European law”.

    The opposition SPÖ praised the decision of the commission. They send an “important signal for more justice,” said the two SPÖ-EU MPs Andreas Schieder and Evelyn Regner. “In a just Europe, all children are of equal value. Chancellor Kurz will also have to recognize this.”

    In Germany, too, the debate about the payment of child benefit abroad has been raging. According to the family fund, around 402 million euros in child benefit payments went abroad in 2018 to the 252 000 recipients. Parents of children living outside of Germany can choose whether the money is transferred abroad or paid into an account in Germany.

    The transfers had increased significantly in the past five years. According to the German federal government, around 75 million euros in child benefit payments went abroad in 2012.

    Consider donating to support our work

    Help us to produce more articles like this. FreeWestMedia is depending on donations from our readers to keep going. With your help, we expose the mainstream fake news agenda.

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.


    Dutch summer: Shootings, violence, chaos

    Scheveningen The Dutch town of Scheveningen has become something of the epicenter of the chaos and violence in the Netherlands. Enforcement personnel have been beaten with batons, and on the pier, people are shot and stabbed. There have already been several deaths.

    European Court of Justice sets new obstacles for deportation

    The latest judgment by the European Court of Justice (file number C-517/17 ), which was published on July 16, received little media attention. This decision calls into question the European asylum system.

    Movie ‘Shugaley-2’ outlines real threats for both East and West

    Despite a long period of lock-down nearly all over the world, the speed of geopolitical processes have not slowed down, nor have the attempts to reflect and analyze them through documentaries and movies based on true stories.

    Poland plans to withdraw from Istanbul Convention

    WarsawEven if the political debate over The Istanbul Convention is also a uniquely Polish debate about the conservative orientation of the country's domestic politics, the criticism against this Convention is more than justified.

    ‘I am disgusted with Bordeaux, we are no longer safe here’

    BordeauxAfter he was attacked and stripped of his belongings by an organised gang, a Bordeaux journalist gave a distraught view of his city, which he says he no longer recognizes. Residents report thefts and violent attacks on a daily basis. The mayor is worried about a "climate emergency" however.

    Sweden: Somali rammed group after he was reported for child molestation

    BörlangeThe Somali taxi driver in the Swedish town of Borlänge who ran down a group of pedestrians recently, wanted to take revenge on his intended victim because the person had reported him for child molestation.

    Sweden: Immigrant child rapist commits 600 crimes – avoids deportation

    In May, the immigrant Bekim Dzelili was initially sentenced by the district court to 13 years in prison and deportation for life. He was found guilty of repeated aggravated child rape, the aggravated sexual abuse of a child, assault and unlawful threats. But the Swedish Court of Appeal has since reduced his prison sentence by one year and has canceled the deportation - the perpetrator may remain in Sweden because he has a "weak connection to his home country".

    Lampedusa: Landings intensify with migrants testing positive for Covid-19

    RomeImages of an illegal migrant landing that took place on 28 July on the most popular beach among shocked tourists and holiday makers, was broadcast by Italian CorriereTV. But the government is instead concerned about the politician who had tried to stop these illegal landings.

    Video: Sweden has knife violence, name changes, culture wars and a housing shortage

    Sweden used to be a 'model society'. But no more.

    German churches celebrate migrant crisis as a success

    MunichThe two large churches in Germany have drawn a positive interim assessment of the 2015 wave of migrants. Around half of those who came at the time are being trained or have jobs today, said the Council President of the Evangelical Church in Germany, Heinrich Bedford-Strohm.

    Go to archive