Skip to Content

Charles Prats. Screenshot from YouTube

French magistrate evokes immigrant social fraud totaling 50 billion euros

In his investigation "The fraud cartel", the French magistrate Charles Prats has taken stock of the huge extent of social fraud in France. 

Published: September 22, 2020, 9:36 am


    The complaints are serious: Tens of thousands of reputed centenarians are allegedly still alive, a third of irregulars are foreign recipients, terrorist beneficiaries receive allowances and fraud is being organized in networks. And the losses to French taxpayers amount to more than 50 billion euros. 

    MP Patrick Hetzel (LR), chairman of the parliamentary committee of inquiry into the fraud on social benefits, expressed his shock in March this year, after a hearing with Charles Prats. The magistrate then calculated a potential loss of around 30 billion euros, far from the moderate estimates of  social security administrators, which allege that it involves a few hundred million euros at most.

    Last year, at the start of the school year, MP Carole Grandjean (LREM) and Senator UDI Nathalie Goulet (UDI) had asked the Ministry of Solidarity and Health for the number of “Active NIRs“, that is to say the number of accounts in a format specific to people born abroad receiving French social benefits.

    In the pages of the Official Journal of the French Republic, the administration concerned said that it had identified 12 392 865 people born abroad “having an open right to receive at least one social benefit”.

    And it is on the basis of this group of policyholders that Charles Prats noted a first inconsistency: according to INSEE, there are 8,2 million people, mostly immigrants, born abroad in France.

    By subtracting the pensioners living abroad (1,1 million) and the regimes specific to Polynesia and New Caledonia, the magistrate arrived at the figure of 2,4 million people born abroad registered in the French Social Security system. It is on the basis of a national average expenditure of 11 800 euros per NIR that the magistrate declared that the potential fraud could reach tens of billions of euros per year.

    In detail, other inconsistencies also arose which had worried the magistrate. Of the more than 12 million policyholders born abroad according to the ministry, 86 percent have an open right to sickness benefits, 43 percent receive family benefits and 33 percent have pension rights.

    By comparing these percentages with statistics on social assistance recipients in France, this would, for example, mean that 42 percent of family allowance recipients were born abroad, or even a fifth of retirees in France were born abroad.

    These are highly inconsistent figures, according to the magistrate. The only explanation could be supernumerary security accounts – in other words, large-scale fraud.

    Contacted by French daily Le Figaro, the Social Security administration stressed that “this does not mean that there is fraud with these Vitale cards”.

    The magistrate underscored that there are currently 5 million “ghosts” in the system. Because this involved “immigrants” he said administrators as well as politicians were afraid to reveal this.

    Consider donating to support our work

    Help us to produce more articles like this. FreeWestMedia is depending on donations from our readers to keep going. With your help, we expose the mainstream fake news agenda.

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    • Grumpy Cat

      What is it with these stupid whites. They’ll legislate themselves into second class citizens. It is time for a revolution and making use of the guillotine again to rid society from these traitors


    Will universalist republican slogans be enough to save France?

    ParisAfter the deadly knife attack in Conflans-Sainte-Honorine, the French are particularly worried about a terrorist risk. So-called "progressives" have contributed to this situation, the Minister of National Education stressed. But Emmanuel Macron is guilty too.

    Knife murder in Dresden was Islamic terror attack – Syrian jihadist arrested

    DresdenTwo deaths, two knife attacks, one in Dresden, the other in Conflans-Sainte-Honorine. And while the decent people in France publicly express their solidarity in the hundreds of thousands for the history teacher Samuel Paty, who was beheaded by an Islamic terrorist, the analogous terror murder of a German in Dresden is only worth a marginal note in the "quality media".

    French teacher suspended in 2015 already for having shown caricatures of prophet

    Muslim parents at the majority immigrant "priority college" François Villon in Mulhouse in 2015 described the attitude of a teacher as "aggressive" because he had lectured his students on free speech. He was suspended for four months to “straighten things out” according to the rector.

    Death of Victorine riles France – suspect took part in tribute march

    GrenobleMore than two weeks after the discovery of the body of Victorine Dartois, the prosecutor of Grenoble announced the arrest of an individual on Wednesday, October 14, who has admitted having killed the young student of 18 years, according to several media outlets.

    China overtakes US to become EU’s biggest trading partner

    BrusselsEurostat announced that imports from China increased by 4,9 percent year-on-year in the January-July period, surpassing the United States. China is currently the biggest trading partner of the European Union (EU).

    Former German mainstream journalist feels ‘liberated to work for free media’

    BerlinOn Saturday, at the invitation of the AfD, the Second Free Media Conference took place in the Marie-Elisabeth-Lüders-Haus of the German Bundestag. The former mainstream journalist Matthias Matussek (who has written for Spiegel, Welt and Stern) gave a lecture there on the topic of "Critics on the sidelines - the 'quality media' are losing their bright minds".

    Vlaams Belang topping the polls in Flanders: ‘Belgians no longer feel at home’

    BrusselsVlaams Belang, the Flemish anti-immigration party, remains at the top of the polls in Flanders. How does one explain the incredible success of Tom Van Grieken's party?

    Alexey Navalny – a victim of intoxication or a master of political posturing?

    BerlinThe so called “Navalny case” is coming thick and fast and is looking more and more like a smartly prearranged and well-played spectacle. The Russian opposition figure and journalist Alexey Navalny has awoken from his coma at the German Charité hospital - he seems to be back in shape giving interviews, including a two-and-a-half-hour conversation with a famous Russian You-tube blogger Yuriy Dud.

    BLM supporter Procter & Gamble champions double standards

    Procter & Gamble (P&G) is building a new production facility in the Turkish industrial city of Gebze for 80 million US dollars. The American multinational consumer goods corporation headquartered in Cincinnati, Ohio, has elevated double standards to a new art.

    International students quit: ‘This isn’t Sweden’

    BörlangeInternational students at the Dalarna University in Borlänge do not want to live in the student residence which is offered to them in the immigrant suburb Tjärna Ängar, also known as “Little Mogadishu”. That is what a representative for Dalarna’s student union wrote in a letter to the university’s board.

    Go to archive