Skip to Content

Woman wearing an Islamic veil. Photo credit: Ghadeer

Top Austrian court overturns headscarf ban

The Austrian Constitutional Court has ruled that the country's ban on headscarves in public schools violates freedom of religion as well as freedom of expression and is therefore unconstitutional.

Published: December 28, 2020, 8:58 am

    Read more

    IGGÖ President Ümit Vural welcomed the high court ruling, but both Austrian Minister of Education Heinz Faßmann and Minister for Women Susanne Raab, said it was regrettable.

    “It does not give girls the opportunity to make their way through the education system free of coercion,” according to Faßmann while Raab said it was “regrettable when little girls have to wear a headscarf and cover themselves in primary school”.

    Leader of the Freedom Party in Upper Austria, Manfred Haimbuchner, commented after the ruling: “The prohibition of the wearing of Islamic headscarves in elementary schools was never intended to be a restriction of religious freedom, but rather as a protective mechanism against sexualization and Islamic oppression of underage children…. Unfortunately, this judgment is a step backwards in terms of civilization.”

    He described the ruling as a “civilizational regression for society” while FPÖ leader Norbert Hofer said his party would fight the ruling: “With a two-thirds majority in the National Council [lower house of Parliament], we have the opportunity to put the regulation back into force through a constitutional law.”

    FPÖ city councilor for Vienna Dominik Nepp called the ruling “a sad day for children’s rights and a dramatic kneeling to political Islam”.

    “The prohibition of the wearing of Islamic headscarves in elementary schools was never intended to be a restriction of religious freedom, but rather as a protective mechanism against sexualization and Islamic oppression of underage children. We must accept the fact that the Constitutional Court has now repealed this law as unconstitutional.

    “Unfortunately, this judgment is a step backwards in terms of civilization. The door has now been opened to a religiously motivated oppression of girls, an oppression that we do not want in our society.

    “Therefore, it is now important to study this judgment carefully and to draw conclusions from it as to how such a ban can still be implemented for the benefit of the children. The search for a constitutional majority for appropriate legislation in parliament is of course an option.”

    According to the ruling, “a regulation that only affects a certain group of female students and that remains selective in order to ensure religious and ideological neutrality as well as gender equality misses its regulatory goal and is irrelevant. §43a SchUG therefore violates the principle of equality in connection with the right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion,” the court ruled on December 11, 2020.

    The headscarf ban was introduced in June 2019 by a governing coalition of the People’s Party (ÖVP) and the conservative Freedom Party (FPÖ). It was an extension of  the “Integration Law” from October 2017 which had sought to advance the integration of Muslims into Western society.

    The 2017 law banned face coverings — including burkas, niqabs or masks — in public spaces. In 2019, the law was extended to prevent children under the age of ten from wearing Islamic headgear in primary schools.

    The law did not explicitly refer to Muslims or Islam, but “any clothing that is ideological or religious and that involves covering the head” was banned. Head coverings were thus legally defined as “any type of clothing that covers the entire head hair or large parts of it” to include only Muslims. Sikhs and Jews were excluded

    The bill sought to promote “the social integration of children according to local customs and traditions, the preservation of the basic constitutional values and educational goals of the Federal Constitution, as well as the equality of men and women”.

    Austria’s official Muslim umbrella group [Islamische Glaubensgemeinschaft in Österreich, IGGÖ], condemned the law as “destructive” and a “direct assault on the religious freedom of Austrian Muslims ” and filed a lawsuit in January 2020 after Minister of Integration, Susanne Raab, announced that the ban would now include girls up to 14 years of age.

    The Court noted: “The principle of equality, in conjunction with the right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion, establishes the state’s religious and ideological neutrality. When designing the school system, the legislature is required to comply with this requirement by treating various religious and ideological convictions based on the principle of equality. The school is based, among other things, on the basic values of openness and tolerance (Art. 14 Para. 5a B-VG).

    “With §43a SchUG, however, the legislature picks out a specific form of clothing with religious or ideological connotations, which is in one way or another comparable with other, but not forbidden, religious or ideological clothing habits.

    “A regulation that selectively picks out a certain religious or ideological conviction by deliberately privileging or disadvantaging such convictions requires a special objective justification with regard to the requirement of religious and ideological neutrality.”

    It concluded: “The wearing of the Islamic headscarf is a practice that is applied for various reasons. The possible religious or worldview explanations that headscarf wearers give to justify the wearing of the headscarf, are manifold. By wearing a headscarf, you can simply express your affiliation with Islam or the orientation of your own life to the religious values of Islam. Furthermore, wearing the headscarf can also be interpreted as a sign of belonging to Islamic culture or of adherence to the traditions of the society of origin. The Islamic headscarf therefore has no clear and unambiguous meaning.”

    The Court stated that it could not offer an interpretation of its own “when there are several possibilities for interpreting a religious or ideological symbol, particularly when it comes to questions of freedom of religion and belief, and to base its assessment of the legal rights of the existence of such symbols in state educational institutions on this”.

    They added however that the ban carried “the risk of making it difficult for Muslim girls to access education or of marginalizing them from society”.

    Austria’s Muslim population now exceeds 700 000 or 8 percent of the total population, according to data compiled by the University of Vienna. If current levels of migration continue, the Muslim population of Austria is forecast to reach around 20 percent of the total population by 2050, according to the Pew Research Center.

    Muslim students already outnumber Austrian students at middle and secondary schools and it therefore only a matter of time before Muslims outnumber Austrians in Viennese elementary schools. Austria’s Agency for State Protection and Counterterrorism (BVT) has meanwhile warned of the “exploding radicalization of the Salafist scene in Austria”. Salafism can be described as an anti-Western ideology that seeks to replace liberal democracy with Islamic law.

    Consider donating to support our work

    Help us to produce more articles like this. FreeWestMedia is depending on donations from our readers to keep going. With your help, we expose the mainstream fake news agenda.

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    • LuciusAnnaeusSeneca

      Many Austrians doubtless rue last year’s public tirade of outrage against the FPO in the wake of the Ibiza-Gate incident, which now is known to have been a manufactured scandal by the foreign (German) press, likely with the involvement of at least one foreign intelligence agency. The objective of such outrage, the product of well-done social engineering, was the downfall of Kurz’ government. But Kurz is back, but now with a government that is limited in its ability to fight rulings by an unaccountable courts system, and a Greens Party Justice Minister who is a Muslim herself. As FPO leader Hofer has noted, the Islamist pushback against the headscarf ban would not have gone far in the first Kurz government, as it could have used a two-thirds majority in Austria’s lower house to institutionalize it. Austrians might have to wait for new elections to see if that might be possible in the future.


    Armin Laschet to lead Angela Merkel’s CDU as new chairman

    The Minister President of North Rhine-Westphalia, the most populous of the 16 states of Germany, Armin Laschet was elected as the new CDU chairman at the digital CDU party conference on Saturday. In the runoff election he prevailed with 521 votes against his toughest competitor Friedrich Merz (466 votes). In a nutshell, the party establishment pushed through its candidate, while the voter's candidate failed.

    The new rise of ISIS in Syria: The reasons and possible consequences

    Deir EzzorThe Syrian province of Deir Ezzor is back in the news after Israel's devastating airstrikes on Syria. However, against this background, most of the Western media has overlooked other events that may prove to be far more important to the security of both the Middle East and Europe.

    Italy: A poll that could become a nightmare for the left

    RomeBad news for the Democratic Party in Italy, which has seen Giorgia Meloni's party dangerously approaching them in the polls. Fratelli d'Italia (FdI) seems to be making great strides towards becoming the second largest party in the country after the Lega led by Matteo Salvini.

    Violent crime rises dramatically in French countryside new data reveals

    ParisA particularly worrying assessment of crime in the French countryside has seen the light. Crime is on the rise almost everywhere in France according to the 2020 report from the SSMI - Statistical Service of the French Ministry of the Interior .

    Islamist currents in France desperate to hinder ‘Charter of Values’

    ParisThe numbers are overwhelming, and so are the testimonials. Data collected by French pollster Ifop for the Jaurès Foundation, which had interviewed several teachers confronted with political Islam even in their classes, paint a dreary picture.

    The Hungarian social network to counter Facebook: ‘Hundub’

    BudapestIts designers promise a social network "without censorship" while its detractors see in it a political maneuver by Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban.

    Significant numbers of German nursing staff refusing Covid-19 vaccine

    For a large number of old people in nursing homes, a Corona vaccination is likely to be given a little earlier than expected. That is because about half of the nursing staff in Germany have decided to forego the "privilege" of being vaccinated against Corona first.

    The fire in the Lipa migrant camp

    The Bosnian "refugee" camp near Lipa burned down on December 23, 2020. The timing is suspicious since one inevitably thinks of Moria and the consequences. What better way to soften European hearts shortly before Christmas Eve in order to achieve a similar effect? However, the Lipa case has some deviations from Moria, but none of them can really be explained.

    Urban violence ushers in New Year in France, Germany

    ParisIn 2021, scenes of urban violence were witnessed throughout France despite the Corona curfew. There were 662 arrests, with 25 police officers and gendarmes injured.

    Vaccinated on Christmas Eve, dead five days later

    LucerneA person died in Switzerland five days after receiving the SARS-CoV-2 vaccine. Authorities said a link with the vaccine was "highly unlikely". German media called his doctor a "Coronavirus skeptic".

    Go to archive