Skip to Content

Migrants in Zurich. Photo credit: Wyron A

Swiss canton vote to include nationalities in police reports

The result of the referendum on the prohibition of wearing an Islamic niqab or full-face veil in Switzerland, obscured an interesting piece of news about another federal plebiscite in this country which has gone almost completely unnoticed: The canton of Zurich voted on Sunday to state nationalities in police reports.

Published: March 11, 2021, 9:35 am

    Read more

    As reported in Swiss daily 20 Minutes, this vote was in fact a counter-proposal from the Swiss government to an initiative from the Swiss People’s Party (SVP) to include migration background.

    The police in the canton have now been obliged to state the origin of the alleged perpetrators. Previously, this had been common practice in the German-speaking canton, which has a population of one and a half million, until a city council on the “Alternative List” banned the Zurich city police from doing so in 2017, following pressure from several left-wing parties.

    The arguments of the supporters of the decision at the time and today’s opponents of the voting initiative were: The naming of nationalities stirs up racism and prejudice and divides society. The Zurich voters could not be convinced however, and instead they wanted clarity, transparency and information. After all, in Switzerland criminal suspects without a Swiss passport are clearly overrepresented in relation to their proportion of the population.

    The majority of inmates in Swiss prisons are foreign nationals, according to official data. Of the 7 000 people imprisoned in Switzerland in January 2020, 70 percent were of foreign nationality.

    More than 55 percent voted in favour of the proposal on Sunday according to the authorities. Only 44 percent approved the proposal by the Swiss People’s Party to include a mention of a possible immigration background, falling short of a necessary majority.

    Zurich is the third of 26 Swiss cantons to introduce a special law over the past decade since cantons follow non-binding recommendations by the country’s police commanders approved in 2010 to mention the nationality of a suspect and victims as a rule besides their respective age. Exceptions are sometimes allowed for privacy reasons while information about a possible immigration background is only disclosed on request.

    It is similar in Germany. In relation to serious violent and sexual crimes, foreigners are more often suspected of being the perpetrators than Germans. In most federal states, however, the nationality is not mentioned in the police reports. An investigation from the beginning of February showed: Only in Saxony and Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania is the nationality of suspects generally stated.

    The negative consequences of the practice in the other federal states can be seen immediately after almost every publicly discussed crime: There is wild speculation on social networks as to where the alleged perpetrator comes from. “That was definitely a foreigner again,” most say, or: “Only Germans do that.” It is almost mandatory for journalists to ask the responsible police officer or to obtain the information somehow and eventually the origin of the suspect is made public.

    This approach shows that there is a public interest in the nationality of suspects. The general mention of this information would also put an end to speculation. When criminologists speak of “pseudo-transparency” because there is usually no connection between the nationality of a suspect and his act, this may be true from a criminological point of view, but it does not change the desire of many Germans to know more than just the gender and age of a suspect. Also because the proportion of foreigners in Germany continues to grow.

    However, in addition to nationality, another factor could be equally relevant. The Swiss People’s Party (SVP) in Zurich had tried (unsuccessfully) to make a possible migration background mandatory public knowledge through the police statement in addition to the nationality. “Only when you know the background are you in a position to correctly judge a situation”, SVP’s Zurich branch said on its website.

    In Germany, the member of the Bundestag and former police chief commissioner Martin Hess (AfD) advocates precisely this. “Citizens across Germany must be informed about the nationality and migration background of suspects. This is the only way they can draw the right conclusions in the elections and force the politicians to make necessary changes to their course,” he urged, speaking to the Berlin weekly Junge Freiheit.

    “Anyone who is against the naming of nationality in police reports only wants to cover up the fact that the policy of open borders makes our country much more insecure.” This contradicts the idea of ​​the democratic public, he said.

    Consider donating to support our work

    Help us to produce more articles like this. FreeWestMedia is depending on donations from our readers to keep going. With your help, we expose the mainstream fake news agenda.

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    • LuciusAnnaeusSeneca

      A large portion of the Swiss population is of foreign origin, and they or their parents came to Switzerland legally. They are productive, law-abiding members of Swiss society who have assimilated to that country’s laws and culture. That said, the illegals flooding into Europe have come to Switzerland, too, and are a major problem for law enforcement and public security in that country. There are probably many foreign-born Swiss who would like to see the criminal element among the illegals called out and identified by their country of origin, so that those in Switzerland legally are not confused with them.


    ‘Finland is ours’ – Nationalists advance in local elections

    On Sunday 13 June, Finland went to the polls, which was a great success for the nationalist True Finns. The party's overall result in the country's municipalities was 14,5 percent, an increase of 5,6 percentage points and 581 new seats since the last municipal election in 2017.

    UK: Teachers should no longer say ‘boy’ and ‘girl’

    LondonA British LGBT organization urged teachers to stop using the words "boy" and "girl". In addition, the organization that fights for the rights of gays, lesbians, bisexuals and transsexuals (LGBT) is urging schools to give children the option of both school uniforms – both skirts and pants.

    France: By an overwhelming majority young adults shun polls

    ParisTwo separate surveys give a better idea of ​​which young French voters decided not to vote on Sunday, June 20. According to Ipsos, nearly 87 percent of 18-24 year olds did not go to vote. A substantially equivalent proportion was revealed among 25-34 year olds, with 83 percent of whom shunned the ballot box.

    Almost two thirds of Germans refuse to accept more migrants

    BerlinA clear majority of Germans reject taking in more migrants. A recent survey showed that 62,5 percent are of the opinion that Germany should not accept any more "refugees" in view of the increasing number of refugees worldwide. Some 28 percent answered yes to a corresponding question.

    Interview with Alexander Dugin – ‘Welcome all newcomers!’

    Prof. Alexander Dugin, philosopher and geopolitical expert from Russia, sees the world changing: the old liberalism is being replaced by a new, aggressive, globalist mutation. Manuel Ochsenreiter's interview with Dugin gives a fascinating insight into the globalist future.

    Legal expert condemns Dutch patience for jihadists

    RotterdamA case that is representative of the ongoing Islamization of the Netherlands has exposed the Dutch tolerance for Islamic extremists, argues Paul Cliteur, a distinguished law professor in the Netherlands from Leiden University and a defence witness for Geert Wilders when Wilders was on trial for “hate speech”.

    German PEI greenlights Pfizer citing insufficient data after myocarditis reports

    BerlinThe new report by the Paul Ehrlich Institute (PEI) states that there is still "no clear picture" between cases of myocardial inflammation and Pfizer/BioNTech vaccinations. Mainly young men are affected. Notably, myocarditis can trigger a life-threatening arrhythmia or lead to cardiac arrest.

    AfD inquiry into refugee policy making waves in Hong Kong

    BerlinAn inquiry from the Eurosceptic AfD to the German federal government regarding the "German refugee policy towards the Chinese special administrative zone Hong Kong and the granting of asylum status" has apparently caused a sensation reaching as far as Southeast Asia.

    Education and immigration are main primers for voter choices

    ParisThe economists Amory Gethin, Clara Martínez-Toledano and Thomas Piketty, who work at the World Inequality Lab at the Paris School of Economics, asked some interesting questions in a study published in early May. The three researchers collected data from several Western democracies. Immigrant voters distinguish themselves by choosing the left.

    New Austrian conservative strongman calls into question arbitrary Corona rules

    ViennaFormer Austrian Interior Minister Herbert Kickl (FPÖ) is considered the new strong man in his party, slated to take over the leadership soon. In an interview translated from ZUERST! Kickl explains how he wants to bring the FPÖ back to being the top party.

    Go to archive