Skip to Content

In Erft, Germany, the flooded main road. Photo: Facebook
Berlin

Why did the Ministry of the Interior not warn Germans of the coming floods?

Why were so many human lives lost during the floods in Germany? After initial criticism of the lack of warning messages from public television, the focus is now on the Federal Office for Civil Protection and Disaster Aid (BBK), which is subordinate to the Federal Ministry of the Interior.

Published: July 19, 2021, 11:32 am

    Read more

    As the London daily newspaper The Times reported, the hydrologist, Professor Hannah Cloke from the UK University of Reading, raised serious allegations regarding German civil protection and spoke of a “monumental system failure” in view of the many deaths and, in other cases, the seriously injured. Cloke herself is the co-founder and developer of the European flood warning system EFAS (European Flood Awareness System).

    The first signs of a coming catastrophe were discovered via satellite on July 10, four days before the storm. The scientists then sent a number of very precise predictions to Germany. From this it was clear that the Rhineland was on the verge of “extreme” floods, especially along the Erft and Ahr rivers, as well as in cities such as Hagen and Altena.

    The danger it posed to citizens was simply ignored by the authorities, responsible for the victims and the devastation.

    In many cases, there were detailed warnings issued for certain places or districts, but neither the responsible authorities nor the media issued a warning to the people in the affected areas in Germany. In addition, Coke had emphasized that one should not only have warned, but also assisted those affected if they had questions about how they should behave and what they should do.

    “I am terrified at the sight of people driving or wading through deep water. That is the most dangerous thing you can do in such a situation. [..] I would have expected that people would be evacuated, it is not expected that so many would die in 2021 from the predicted floods. It is indeed very, very serious, ” said the scientist, evidently very concerned.

    Uwe Kirsche, spokesman for the German Weather Service (DWD) said the warning had been passed on to the municipalities and added: “As a federal authority, the DWD is not responsible for initiating evacuations or other measures on site” regarding “local events” just like the state media.

    In the end, it appears that no one in power wants to shoulder the blame and once again it is the fault of the “climate” and, as is well known, the victims themselves are also to blame because they may have eaten meat, driven a diesel car or had too many children.

    In the town of Erft, inhabitants spent the weekend trying to clean up the debris from the floods. Photo: Facebook

    Germany does not have a “climate” problem as much as it has too many people in important positions who do not care about their own citizens.

    Notably, dams were nearly full before the massive rains came. Those responsible knew about it and still refused to drain the water from the dams. At this point one can hardly speak of incapacity. Rather, the suspicion arises that the catastrophe was at least accepted with approval because the federal government had been informed of the impending storms – days in advance.

    And now private individuals have to help with money, donations in kind and labour to aid their compatriots while Chancellor Merkel pushes ahead with her planned climate agenda. This scientific nonsense has been exposed too. It has rained before, often with worse consequences than currently. Persistent weather conditions, which increase the risk of massive rainfall, are no more common in the 21st century than in the past – regardless of climate change or penguin deaths.

    The cause of the catastrophic consequences of the rainfall in July 2021 is the combination of increasing soil sealing in urban and rural areas with consistently weak drainage possibilities for the water.

    Germans have moreover been mortified at seeing North Rhine-Westphalia’s Prime Minister Armin Laschet (CDU) laughing loudly during the visit of Federal President Frank-Walter Steinmeier (SPD) to the disaster area. In a video that could well cost him his political career, Armin Laschet, the designated candidate to replace Angela Merkel, had no choice but to apologize on Saturday. Earlier, while visiting the victims of the terrible floods in western Germany, which killed at least 141 people in the country, he had been filmed laughing merrily for several tens of seconds.

    The images quickly caused controversy across the Rhine. Laschet was spotted fooling around during a tribute speech, delivered by the President of the Republic Frank-Walter Steinmeier. Standing behind the head of state, he is seen in the footage laughing for nearly 30 seconds, with six people joining in the hilarity. The controversy has grown even more bigger because he is responsible for one of the two regions most affected by the disaster, North Rhine-Westphalia, in the west of the country, where dozens of people perished and at least a thousand are still missing.

    “Outrageous”, “disgusting” said people who saw the video, broadcast by the local television channel WDR. It was shared several hundred times on Twitter on Saturday, provoking the ire of social democratic politicians, partners of the conservatives in the government of coalition of Angela Merkel, and many Internet users.

    Consider donating to support our work

    Help us to produce more articles like this. FreeWestMedia is depending on donations from our readers to keep going. With your help, we expose the mainstream fake news agenda.

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    Europe

    Cold weather warning adds to Europe’s gloom as it battles self-inflicted energy crisis

    The weather in Europe is usually difficult to predict because conditions are dictated by several remote factors, but Europe may experience a colder winter with less wind and rain than usual, according to the European Weather Forecast Agency. This is bound to heighten the challenges facing governments trying to solve the continent’s energy crisis. 

    Unvaccinated are ‘the best of mankind’

    ParisFrench General Christian Blanchon, aged 58, commanded the 1st Parachute Regiment at Toulouse. He served as an officer in operations in Lebanon, Chad, Central Africa and Kosovo. And on September 9, 2022, this highly respected general published a tribute to the unvaccinated, which has gone viral on social media, but is being ignored by the mainstream media.

    The ‘lunatic in the Kremlin’ is surprisingly lucid

    MoscowMuch is being said about Putin's grand speech on the annexation of former Ukrainian territories. But the alleged “madman in the Kremlin”, in contrast to the geriatric US President Joe Biden, offered valuable insights into the neoliberal and neocolonial Anglo-Saxon world view.

    Meloni sticks to Anglo-Saxon course

    RomeFor those who had hoped that cooler heads would prevail, Italy's likely new head of government, Giorgia Meloni, has made an important political announcement: immediately after her election victory, she declared her solidarity with Ukraine and assured Kiev's President Zelensky of Italy's continued full support.

    US helicopters circled over Nordstream for weeks

    Gdansk/RønneMore and more disturbing details are coming to light in connection with the bombing of the Nordstream pipeline in the Baltic Sea.

    Nordstream pipeline likely sabotaged

    The politically motivated sabotage behind the apparently serious and wanton damage to the gas pipelines Nordstream 1 and Nordstream 2 were likely ordered by a technically and militarily highly developed state. The aim of this crime, a very large-scale crime, could only have been to destroy any hope of further gas deliveries from Russia to Germany.

    Hungarian FM: Europe’s narrative about war no longer relevant

    New YorkAt the UN General Assembly in New York, Hungarian Foreign Minister Szijjártó made an interesting observation: Europe has long since lost the "race of narratives" in connection with the Ukraine war.

    Industrialist: ‘The Americans control everything in the background’

    Burladingen German industrialist Wolfgang Grupp, the CEO of textile giant Trigema, does not understand why Germans suddenly see Vladimir Putin as a mortal enemy. He believes that the US is controlling everything in the background and are the only winners of this war.

    German secret service operates fake accounts to lure ‘right-wing extremists’

    BerlinAnyone who criticizes the German system is quickly labelled as an "extremist". But because the state still has not found enough "right-wing extremists", it has decided to help a little bit.

    EU states are fighting over the repeal of veto right

    BrusselsThe member countries of the European Union have revived the debate on whether to introduce majority voting on some issues of foreign or security policy instead of the current need for unanimous consent of all the bloc's states.

    Go to archive