Skip to Content

Fathi Ali Bashaga: Minister and Torterer? Picture: Wikimedia/Awstishur (CC BY-SA 4.0)

‘My eye was gouged out by the Libyan Interior Minister’

After the terrible ordeal of a ex-detainee Ragab Rahil Abdel-Fadil Al-Magarhy in the Mitiga secret prison in Libya, an appeal was made to the United Nations. 

Published: June 3, 2020, 9:15 am

    Read more

    In recent days the international media agenda has been publishing an increasing number of reports connected to the situation in Libya. US officials are especially active in contributing to this topic: they publish reports full of photos and videos of alleged Russian planes, make loud pronouncements about Russian involvement in the Libyan conflict while accusing it of printing fake money to support one of the conflict parties.

    But the objectivity and veracity of these statements made by the US representatives should be carefully reviewed and evaluated. Therefore, it is of particular importance to watch for the reaction of the US concerning an appeal to the United Nations made by Ragab Rahil Abdel-Fadil Al-Magarhy.

    On the June 1, an Arab media outlet Alsaa 24 published the testimony of Ragab Rahil Abdel-Fadil Al-Magarhy – Libyan citizen who was kept at the Mitiga prison located in Tripoli, on the territory of the Government of the National Accord of Libya (the GNA).

    He had been detained there since summer of 2019, and had been suffering from horrendously savage abuse. Physical maltreatment and frequent torture are quite routine in this prison, but certainly the most tragic part of Ragab Rahil Abdel-Fadil Al-Magarhy’s story is that the antagonist who has been persecuting him, is none other than Fathi Ali Bashaga, the GNA Interior Minister.

    According to the testimony of Mr. Al-Magarhy, at a certain date of his detention at the Mitiga prison, he and the other prisoners were led to the head of the prison Abd al-Rauf Kara. All the while, Al-Magarhy was handcuffed with his hands behind his back. What happened next, goes beyond all excesses known to humankind.

    “Fathi Ali Bashaga came up to me, put me on my knees and fixed my head. At that moment I saw a spoon in his hands, which was brought to my face. In the next moment I felt a sharp pain and then lost consciousness. When I recovered my senses, I felt that my eye had been gouged out. The prisoners who were with me at the moment of that torture confirmed that Fathi Ali Bashaga had cut out my eye with the spoon he had in his hands,” Al-Magarhy said at his testimony, adding that he was not provided with any qualified medical care.

    After being released from the Mitiga prison, Mr. Al-Magarhy decided not to appeal for domestic legal protection as he is afraid of the prosecution from the side of the GNA authorities. But the inhumane torment he has had to endure and, even more outrageously, by a personality and a figure of authority who had gouged out his eye, pushed Al-Magarhy to do the best he possibly could in these dire circumstances – to write an official complaint and address it to the UN. He is doing so in the hope that this organization committed to the protection of human rights, will launch a proper investigation into his case and bring to justice all those who were involved in this terrible crime.

    It is hard to tell whether the request by Mr. Al-Magarhy will be heard. But the very least one should expect in such a situation, is an official comment from the USA, EU and other countries who openly express support to the GNA and its authorities.

    Moreover, the GNA is recognized by the UN so this international organization has a certain responsibility or at least a duty of observation regarding the activities of the GNA government.

    Unfortunately, it appears as though UN representatives do not perceive this duty seriously – in September 2019 the UN Human Rights Council refused to even listen to the report on torture of foreign citizens in Libya.

    Sadly, US officials go beyond that – they simply do not notice any torture being committed on the territory of the GNA. Such an attitude, given that there are lots of examples of barbarous and cruel treatments in Libyan prisons, is very far from being fair. Also, it hardly follows the principles of humanity and safeguarding protections for victims, which are stated in the UN Charter and widely promoted by the US all over the world.

    opinion@freewestmedia.com

    Consider donating to support our work

    Help us to produce more articles like this. FreeWestMedia is depending on donations from our readers to keep going. With your help, we expose the mainstream fake news agenda.

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    • LuciusAnnaeusSeneca

      “Moreover, the GNA is recognized by the UN so this international
      organization has a certain responsibility or at least a duty of
      observation regarding the activities of the GNA government.”

      The GNA is supported by the UN because it gives the UN and its policies a presence in Libya. And it also gives access to the UN’s leftist-globalist allies and supporters in the global energy sector. Apart from that, the UN indeed seems to care little about what standards the GNA or its ministers and other personnel adhere to. It survives because it is of use to not just the UN’s agenda, but the agendas of others as well. Here are four cases:

      The GNA itself controls less than ten percent of the country’s area, and has been unable to extend its write south or east from the Tripoli region. In the latter, the GNA has allowed the use of its territory by organized criminal groups that move migrants across large parts of Africa to the Tripoli coast, as well as the organized criminal groups that then move them into Italy and Malta via the “migrant express”. The GNA has hosted representatives of NGOs that facilitate this illegal movement into Europe.

      Elsewhere, the GNA has allowed the use of its territory by ISIS, al-Qaeda, and other jihadist groups, many of whom also have a hand in moving migrants or putting a “tax” on groups that do so. These jihadists not only use Libya as a refuge, but also as a base and a conduit to funnel personnel and military equipment to jihadists operating in the Sahara and West Africa.

      Last, and not least, the GNA is now allied with, and supported by, the Erdogan regime, which has introduced Turkish military assets as well as Syrian jihadist mercenaries to the Tripoli region, to fight the forces of the eastern Libyan government of the Tobruk-based House of Representatives. The latter is backed by Egypt, the Gulf Arab states, and Russia. As a result of Turkish escalation, the Russians have upped their ante with increased air power, increasing the chance of incidents that could rapidly spin out of control.

      In addition to the situation on the ground in Tripoli, the GNA government has signed an agreement with Turkey that furthers the latter’s neo-Ottoman designs to control the eastern Mediterranean. The agreement, contrary to international law and treaties, is being used as a pretext for Turkey to encroach on the natural gas assets outside its internationally-recognized territorial waters. This also increases political and military tensions in the region, as it runs directly contrary to the Greek-Cypriot-Israeli effort to export natural gas to Europe.

    Africa

    Ahmed Maiteeq: Is he the newcomer and future leader of Libya?

    TripoliAfter a period of failed Tunisian negotiations under the auspices of the UN and UNSMIL's Stephanie Williams, which led to discord among the participants and exacerbated relations between the Government of National Accord (GNA) and Khalifa Haftar's Libyan National Army (LNA), there is renewed hope in Libya for the gradual restoration of constructive dialogue through economic arrangements.

    ‘Economic terrorism’: Attacks on foreign truck drivers intensify in South Africa

    PretoriaIn South Africa, in recent weeks, dozens of trucks have been set on fire with Molotov cocktails, cargoes looted, drivers injured, killed, in a fresh wave of particularly brutal attacks. The road transport industry is "under siege", according to the South African press. Most of the assaulted drivers are foreigners.

    Libya: Bashagha’s career puts Europe at risk

    TripoliA criminal Libyan politician and his Islamist gang are getting ready to run the country and threating the West and Europe. How did that happen?

    Fathi Bashagha: An ambitious radical seeking to seize power in Libya

    France and the United States may want to support him, but the price will be a new round of escalation in the conflict.

    Radicals among the radicals – Libya’s new leadership may even be more radical, Islamist

    TunisThe UN-recognized Libyan Government of National Accord (GNA) is often criticized for its links to radical political Islam.

    Is the Libyan Political Dialogue Forum an instrument of American neocolonialism?

    TunisThe Libyan Political Dialogue Forum started on November 9 in Tunisia. This forum was organized by the UN Support Mission to Libya (UNSMIL) headed by Stephanie Williams, former US chargé d'affaires in Libya.

    Farmers say horrific murder in Free State could have been prevented

    PretoriaFarmers in the Eastern Free State say the horrific murder of Brendin Horner could have been prevented if a detailed report had been considered in which the suspected members of transnational stock theft syndicates had been identified.

    South Africa: Two farm attacks in two days, farm manager tortured and killed

    Paul RouxIt is clear that a slow war is being fought against South Africa's white farmers and this slow racial war is increasingly also being taken to towns and cities. The murder of a white farm manager, Brendin Horner (21), serves as proof that the South African government’s rural safety plan is failing.

    The man of the future in Libya?

    The oil deal in Libya discloses the rampant fight for power and oncoming political changes.

    South Africa: Massive biker protest against farm murders

    Tens of thousands of motorcycle riders took part in a protest against the country’s gruesome farm murders on Saturday. In Cape Town, an attempt by motorcyclists to deliver a petition to the parliament building led to clashes between police and protesters, with a black officer assaulting a white motorcyclist and another drawing his gun on an unarmed protestor.

    Go to archive