Skip to Content

Declaring the end of science, Cape Town university riots 2016

London university wants to scrap white philosophers

British university students are demanding that philosophers Plato and Kant be scrapped from a syllabus because they are white.

Published: January 9, 2017, 10:44 am

    The founding fathers of Western philosophy, the very basis of civilised society, must go, according to students at a prestigious London university. They want Plato, Descartes and Immanuel Kant dropped from the curriculum because they are white, The Telegraph reported.

    School of Oriental and African Studies (SOAS)’s student union maintain that “the majority of philosophers on our courses” should be from Africa and Asia.

    It is part of wider campaign to “decolonise” the university, they say, to “address the structural and epistemological legacy of colonialism”.

    Virtually exactly the same demands were made by black students from Cape Town University last year. A so-called “fallist” has asked students at the University of Cape Town’s science faculty to consider scrapping science as a whole.

    At a panel discussion published on YouTube‚ the woman responded to a question about the decolonisation of science. “Science as a whole is a product of western modernity and the whole thing should be scratched off. Especially in Africa‚” she says.

    Under proposed British reforms to higher education, the Government wants to place student satisfaction at the heart of a new ranking system, but it critics fear could undermine academic integrity.

    Sir Roger Scruton, the philosopher, said the demands suggest “ignorance”. “You can’t rule out a whole area of intellectual endeavour without having investigated it and clearly they haven’t investigated what they mean by white philosophy,” he told The Mail on Sunday.

    “If they think there is a colonial context from which Kant’s Critique of Pure Reason arose, I would like to hear it.”

    The vice-chancellor of Buckingham University Sir Anthony Seldon added: “There is a real danger political correctness is getting out of control. We need to understand the world as it was and not to rewrite history as some might like it to have been.”

    The student union at SOAS, a leading centre for the study of Asia, Africa and the Middle East, states that “decolonising” the university and “confronting the white institution” is one if its priorities for the academic year.

    It says that “white philosophers” should be studied only “if required”, adding that their work should be taught solely from a “critical standpoint”. “For example, acknowledging the colonial context in which so-called ‘Enlightenment’ philosophers wrote within,” it says.

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    • Jace Curioso

      If the students do not wish to study ‘white philosophers’ then they are free to seek education at other institutions. I’m sure there will be, if not now but quite soon, ‘colleges’ or ‘universities’ seeking accreditation that will develop curriculum around all disciplines excluding those containing white writers, thinkers, creators, etc. God help those graduating from these ‘enlightened’ halls of learning seeking employment in the real world. Oh, one last thought: I suggest these enlightened individuals leave their laptops, computers, iPads, etc. at home because these devices were created, in great part, by white individuals. And they better study by candlelight; wouldn’t want to be using electricity or any other such white men science, would they?

      • Eric Bligan

        Hear, hear!
        You have just made vice-chancellor of Buckingham University Sir Anthony Seldon a retard.
        🙂

        • Jace Curioso

          Thank you, sir. I accept the appointment and, as my first act as VC, I will dismiss–for cause–any faculty members backing this ridiculous proposition.

      • Jonathan Stewart

        And if the students didn’t want to study Oriental and African philosophers they would doubtless have chosen to go elsewhere. Do people posting on here not have any sense at all?

    • Jonathan Stewart

      This article is nonsense. And the bigoted right would like 1,738,074 other articles like it to be taken into consideration.

    • Jonathan Stewart

      Look at the name of the institution – the School of African and Asian studies! It seems a reasonable request that they should study African and Asian philosophers. What about if a student studying French and German on a modern languages course were told they should be studying English because more people spoke it as well as every other modern language so they didn’t feel discriminated against.

      • Jonathan Stewart

        sorry School of Oriental and African studies. I’ve had a drink.

        • Andrew-John Miles

          Jonathan. Go read again, the institution is the London university. They are from the SCHOOL OF ORIENTAL AND ASIAN STUDIES union. Think you need to check your sense buddy, open the blinder lib

          • Jonathan Stewart

            I don’t understand your post at all. I’m not persuaded that this article is particularly accurate in the first place. But the issue relates to SOAS. DO you know how the collegiate system at London University works?

            • Jonathan Stewart

              And the term institution can be used for either the entire organisation London University or for each of its components – ie University College, Kings College, Goldsmiths, Imperial etc etc.

    • Jonathan Stewart

      Why would students at the SCHOOL OF ORIENTAL AND ASIAN STUDIES want to study philosophers who were neither Oriental nor Asian?

    Europe

    Marine Le Pen pays Putin a visit

    MoscowPresident Vladimir Putin met with the leader of the National Front, Marine Le Pen, in the Kremlin on Friday, Reuters reported, “handing her a potential boost to her campaign to win next month’s presidential election in France”.

    Russia warns Norway against building a missile shield

    OsloRussia has warned Norway that joining NATO's ballistic missile defense (BMD) would be met with consequences.

    Macron faces a determined Marine Le Pen in French presidential TV debate

    ParisFive of the French presidential candidates faced off in a televised debate Monday night.

    Eight letterbombs destined for EU officials neutralised

    AthensPolice in Greece have neutralised eight parcel bombs addressed to European Union officials and multinational companies in several EU countries. The parcels were discovered at a postal sorting office near Athens.

    Trump refuses to shake Merkel’s hand during frosty meeting

    WashingtonThe Atlantic Ocean was not the only dividing sea of differences between US and German leaders in the East Room of the White House on Friday. The two could barely disguise the gulf that separates them on trade and immigration.

    Republican senators implore Tillerson to cut Soros-funding

    WashingtonSix US Republican senators have asked the State Department to review US aid to NGOs run by billionaire George Soros, citing Macedonia and Albania as the most recent worrying examples of conflict-sowing interventionist policies in the Balkan.

    Rutte beats Wilders in Dutch elections, but coalition nightmare awaits

    The HaguePrime minister Mark Rutte looks set to be the winner of the Dutch election, but without coalition partners. Geert Wilders told RTL that even though he did not beat Rutte, he hoped that his party would be firm opposition to Rutte's VVD.

    Wilders and Rutte face each other in heated debate

    During a debate hosted by Dutch TV's EenVandaag, Wilders accused Dutch Prime Minister Mark Rutte of breaking election promises and not listening to voters.

    Muslim countries condemn Dutch row with Turkey

    Several Muslim countries as well as France, have condemned the Dutch authorities for deporting a Turkish official.

    Rallies in two Dutch cities as visiting Turkish minister is deported

    RotterdamThe Turkish Family and Social Affairs Minister was deported to Germany, after Dutch authorities declared her an "undesirable alien" and stopped her within 30m of the Turkish consulate in Rotterdam on Saturday.

    Go to archive