Skip to Content

Hungarian MP Marton Gyöngyösi
INTERVIEW

Kiev’s policy towards Hungarian minority: ‘Arrogant, cynical and childish’

Signs in Hungarian language removed, arrests of activists – repressions in Transcarpathia: Hungarian MP Marton Gyöngyösi in an exclusive Free West Media-interview about Kiev's politics towards ethnic and national minorities

Published: May 25, 2017, 2:58 pm

    Mr. Gyöngyösi, European politicians have spoken out in support especially of the Hungarian minority in Transcarpathia region but also in support of the rights of all national minorities in Ukraine. What is your reaction?

    Gyöngyösi: I am very happy and thankful that this important topic is getting more and more awareness in Europe. But the official EU institutions and Brussels are still turning a blind eye to it.

    How is the situation in Transcarpathia region today?

    Gyöngyösi: We have experienced within the last year the depreciation of basic human rights of national and ethnic minorities in Ukraine since the so-called Maidan. Before the Maidan there was a language law in Ukraine which was fitting to European standards, although it was even then not 100 percent implemented. But it could have been a good base for a dialogue. But the recent language laws submitted to the Rada in Kiev simply show that Ukraine doesn’t even want to comply with international obligations.

    Kiev and Brussels both want to get Ukraine closer with the EU. Shouldn´t the topic of national minorities and autonomy rights be discussed?

    Gyöngyösi: Western countries are trying to reach out to Ukraine and trying to integrate Kiev into the Western sphere of influence. But what we can see is that Ukraine is ignoring all international laws and any international charter which secure the rights of national and ethnic minorities. This is outrageous. And it is also outrageous that the European community has absolutely nothing to say about this! It is a non-topic in Brussels.

    Marton Gyöngyösi.

    You just came back from a PACE meeting in Paris where minority rights in Ukraine were also discussed…

    Gyöngyösi: I have to make clear it was an afternoon meeting of the cultural committee. There was a report discussed with the title “The protection and promotion of regional and minority languages in Europe” which has been drafted by the Hungarian MP Rosza Hoffmann from the Fidesz party. This draft is asking the members of the Council of Europe for nothing else other than to consider the European Charta for regional and minority languages. This Charta has been adopted decades ago as a recommendation for implementation. What was very strange for me, was that two Ukrainian members of the committee were absolutely outraged and in opposition to even negotiate the subject. The irony of all that is that the Ukrainian members of course used the topic for an anti-Russian statement, as if it has only to do with the Russian speaking population in Ukraine. But one MP who objected to the report fiercely was speaking Russian himself – and not Ukrainian. That was really strange…

    When it comes to the Crimean Tatars, Kiev is very vocal about their rights and even proposed an autonomous state for them – of course because of geopolitical reasons: Crimea has been part of the Russian Federation since 2014. But why doesn’t Kiev propose the same rights for other national minorities such as the Hungarians? Are the Hungarians a “second class minority”?

    Gyöngyösi: Absolutely! We should consider the fact that Hungarians have been living in Transcarpathia for more than a 1000 years. They can be considered as an historical, indigenous population there, who haven’t moved an inch. These Hungarians were always respected as having a Hungarian identity in the past. They were speaking their language and they had their own schools. They were always allowed to use their mother tongue. So what is happening to us now, done by Kiev, is something which didn’t happen throughout our whole troubled history. This is something terribly new for us.

    How do you see the calls for autonomy and the reaction of the Kiev government?

    Gyöngyösi: If Ukraine doesn’t recognize that it is a multi-ethnic, multi-religious and multinational entity, and if Ukraine continues with this extremely arrogant, cynical and childish attitude, which is in the 21st century completely unacceptable, then the Ukrainian politicians themselves are going to dig the grave of Ukraine as a nation state. If Kiev doesn´t accept the realities and gives its minorities the right of their cultural autonomy then in the long term the Ukrainian state will disintegrate and fall apart.

    Then why is the Ukrainian leadership not doing those necessary steps?

    Gyöngyösi: I do see the logic of Kiev. The political elite in Ukraine is busy with inventing their own nationhood right now. And the shortest possible way doing that is simply by depriving every other ethnicity of its rights and pretending that Ukrainian is the only language spoken in Ukraine and that the Ukrainian people are the only legitimate ethnicity. But history has shown that this type of strategy can never work. It will be extremely harmful for Kiev itself. If the Hungarians have managed to stay there for more than 1000 years regardless of the Tatars, the Turks or the Habsburgs invading the region, then we can already say now: It won´t be the Hungarians who are going to suffer in long term from that type of Kiev politics. It will be the Ukrainian nation in the first place.

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    Europe

    Van rams into holidaymakers in Barcelona, police foil second attack

    The Islamic State has claimed responsibility for the Barcelona attack in which 13 people were killed and over a hundred pedestrians injured when a white van rammed into unsuspecting holidaymakers.

    OSCE Monitor on Ukraine: Deadly violence has doubled since last year

    INTERVIEWInterview with Alexander Hug, Principal Deputy Chief Monitor of the OSCE Special Monitoring Mission to Ukraine.

    Cars as weapons: Could hackers be part of the growing problem?

    A car crashed through the front of a pizzeria on Monday evening in Seine-et-Marne, near Paris, killing a teenage girl. The 32-year-old male driver is believed to have "intentionally" crashed into the terrace on Rue du Commerce, Sept-Sorts in a "drugged state".

    Oligarch in trouble

    MOSCOWMoscow: Russian national oil company Rosneft joins a historical law battle against oligarch Vladimir Yevtushenkov

    MSF suspends its migrant rescue operations off Libyan coast

    RomeDoctors Without Borders (MSF) will suspend its migrant rescues in the Mediterranean, the organisation declared on Saturday after Italian government moved to halt the human trafficking from North Africa.

    Journalist who exposed German government bias in media coverage faces backlash

    German-Dutch freelance reporter Claudia Zimmermann faced innumerable hardships after exposing her employer, German public broadcaster WDR, for Soviet-style censorship of the migrant crisis. Zimmermann faced rejected contributions, calls to boycott her and even a public letter refuting her reporting which she says had been strictly factual.

    Knife crime surges in London with migrant influx

    LondonThe Weekly Standard (WS), a British daily, reported that the recent influx of African migrants, particularly from Somalia and the Congo, has caused a spike in knife crimes.

    Italian PM met Soros in secret as web of Soros-funded NGO’s is exposed

    RomeThe Italian Prime Minister met with George Soros in secret in May, just as concerned Italians were beginning to expose the spiderweb of Soros-funded NGO's operating in the country to promote immigration.

    Poland not considering deployment of US missiles, says minister

    WarsawPoland is not considering the deployment of US medium-and short-range missiles on its territory for the moment, Polish Foreign Minister Witold Waszczykowski told the Kommersant business daily.

    Libyan general threatens to bomb Italian vessels as chats between smugglers and NGOs surface

    Libyan General Khalifa Haftar has ordered his faction to bomb Italian vessels deployed in a mission to provide naval support to Libya, according to a tweet published by broadcaster Al Arabiya. The announcement comes after Italy impounded a German NGO vessel on suspicion of human trafficking.

    Go to archive