Skip to Content

Mosque in Cologne

Austrian study finds mosques preach non-integration

An official Austrian study as well as private research conducted by a German journalist, has shown that Muslims do not want to integrate into Western societies. Despite that fact, establishment politicians continue to blame their own citizens for a lack of integration.

Published: November 26, 2017, 9:35 am

    In September, the Austrian Integration Fund (ÖIF), a department of the foreign ministry published a study, Forschungsbericht ‘Rolle der Moschee im Integrationsprozess [The role of the mosque in the integration process].

    Most imams however, were unwilling to have a conversation. And according to the ÖIF, only two of the mosque associations foster the integration of their members.

    For the purposes of the study, researchers of the ÖIF visited 16 mosques in Vienna and spoke with individual imams at Friday sermons.

    With few exceptions, the Viennese mosques are strictly run along ethnic lines: “There are Turkish, Albanian, Bosnian, Arabic, Pakistani and other mosques, in which sermons are generally held exclusively in the respective national language. Only in rare instances are parts of the sermon — or even more rarely, all of the sermon — translated into German.”

    These are “closed spaces in terms of ethnicity and language” and it fosters “social integration into an internal ethnic environment, and thus ethnic segmentation.” In eight of the 16 mosques surveyed, this trend is further reinforced by “widespread and openly-propagated nationalism”.

    A Bosnian mosque association that also runs a soccer club was singled out in the report. During the discussion, its imam said: “Every country, as with Austria, has its rules and laws and — something I always stress — it is our religious duty to comply with these standards and to integrate accordingly.”

    The authors were also struck by the almost complete absence of women at Friday prayers: “Only three of the mosques… provide women with their own space, which is reserved for them and actually used by them. If they exist at all, most of the mosques make the women’s areas on Fridays available to men, too.”

    The Turkish Milli Görüs movement, was noted to be particularly radical. Milli Görüs is closely associated ideologically with Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan and remains one of the largest Islamic organisations in Europe.

    According to the report, the imam in the Milli Görüs mosque “openly advocated for the establishment of a politically united Ummah under a caliphate.” The fitna [upheaval] he says, was brought into the Islamic community from the outside.

    The authors of the study say that the imam “sees himself surrounded everywhere by enemies of Islam, who want to prevent the Islamic community from dominating the world as foretold in prophecies”.

    The study concluded: “In summary, it may be said of the 16 mosque associations surveyed in this study, that with the exception of mosques D01 [one of the few German-speaking mosques] and B02 [the aforementioned Bosnian mosque], they do not actively promote the social integration of their members.

    “For the most part, they have an inhibiting effect on the integration process.”

    According to the study, at least six of the 16 mosque associations examined (37.5 percent) pursued “a policy that actively impedes integration into society and to some extent exhibits fundamentalist tendencies”.

    Half of the 16 mosques examined “preach a dichotomous worldview, the pivotal tenet of which is the division of the world into Muslims on one side, and everyone else on the other” while the remaining six were found to practice “explicit denigration of Western society”.

    German journalist Constantin Schreiber who, in 2016, spent more than 8 months attending Friday sermons in German mosques, published a bestseller in Germany: Inside Islam: What Is Being Preached in Germany’s Mosques.

    Fluent in Arabic, Schreiber introduced himself to the mosque associations as a journalist, disclosing that he intended to write a non-fiction book about mosques in Germany. The few imams with whom he was allowed to speak, spoke almost no German. “Apparently it is possible to live in Germany for many years with your wife and children, and still not even be capable of buying bread in German,” Schreiber noted.

    During sermons Schreiber noted the constant stream of criticisms against life in Germany.

    “Time and again, such as in the Al-Furqan mosque [a Sunni Arab mosque in Berlin] Muslims seemed committed to the idea that they are some sort of a community with a shared destiny: ‘You are a diaspora! We are a diaspora! … They [Germans] resembles a torrent that annihilates you, which obliterates you, and takes away your values and replaces them with its own values’.”

    Schreiber also noted the lack of transparency surrounding the Islamic faith, with no official directory of mosques. “Newly opened mosques are not recorded anywhere, and neither the intelligence services nor regional authorities are aware of their existence.”

    The city of Hanover actually rejected Schreiber’s appeal for information on mosques: “We do not want to have these institutions subjected to general suspicion.”

    University professors – whose salaries are paid by German taxpayers – refused to provide information about Islam and mosques, the subject they were appointed to teach.

    Scholars of Islamic studies and Islam experts “are very obliging in offering to be interviewed on current political issues” but the same openness does not exist when questions are asked about the faith.

    Schreiber’s conclusion is that “mosques are political spaces”.  He added: “The majority of the sermons I attended were aimed at resisting the integration of Muslims into German society. If the issue of life in Germany was raised, then it was primarily in a negative context. Frequently, the imams described everyday life in Germany as a threat and urged their communities to resist. The common feature of almost all the sermons is their appeal to the faithful to shut themselves off and to keep to themselves.”

    In “virtually every mosque”, Schreiber said “scores of refugees who had not been living in Germany very long” were present.

     

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    Europe

    Marine rips into Macron’s failed policies in live interview

    ParisMarine Le Pen, leader of the Front National, was a guest on the political talk show on French television where she ripped into unpopular President Macron's failing policies.

    Scandal shakes German refugee authority: Cash for asylum

    More than 25 000 asylum cases will have to be re-processed after Germany's Federal Office for Refugees and Migration (BAMF) became mired in a corruption scandal at its regional office in the northern city of Bremen.

    Britain’s claims about Skripal affair ‘precarious’ says German media

    BerlinGerman intelligence already had a sample of the nerve agent used to poison the Skripals in the United Kingdom at least two decades ago. And so did the US and Britain.

    Crisis brewing in ‘parking lot for migrants’

    Some 120 000 migrants are currently heading towards Croatia, en route to enter the European Union via the popular Western Balkan route. Croatian police have been put on alert.

    US newspaper urges Ukraine to bomb Kerch Strait bridge

    As Russian President Vladimir Putin opened the Kerch Strait Bridge connecting Crimea with mainland Russia on Tuesday, an opinion piece in an American newspaper urged Ukraine to bomb the bridge.

    Large EU firms are pulling out of Iran

    Major European firms have started to pull out of Iran to avoid being hit by harsh US sanctions despite tough talk by EU leaders.

    Leaked Italian manifesto suggest lifting of anti-Russian sanctions

    RomeIn a leaked manifesto, entitled Government for Change, calls for sanctions against Russia to be scrapped in Italy have been revealed. If this happens, Germany and France, could soon follow suit.

    Hungary and Poland stand firm against EU’s immigration plans

    WarsawAt the beginning of this month, 58 European and African countries gathered in Morocco in Marrakech to discuss issues such as migration and development. The EU plans to support immigration to Europe, not to stop it.

    Italy inching towards forming new government

    Leader of Italy's 5-Star Movement (M5S), Luigi Di Maio said that a fresh meeting with League chief Matteo Salvini on the formation of a new government went well on Friday.

    UK National Security Advisor tears up the Magna Carta

    The UK National Security Advisor, Sir Mark Sedwill was asked by a Whitehall panel about the evidence available implicating Russia in the Skripal affair recently. The Q&A took place after Sir Mark’s speech to the Defence Committee of the UK parliament and provided much insight into how Britain functions today.

    Go to archive