Skip to Content

Rupert Scholz; migrants in Greece (Wikipedia)

German constitutional lawyer calls for change to asylum law

A heavyweight German constitutional lawyer Rupert Scholz has called for a change to the asylum law in the Basic Law adding that the Merkel regime has completely ignored regulations.

Published: February 27, 2018, 9:31 am

    Read more

    The current regulation, according to which asylum is always an enforceable fundamental right, is no longer acceptable, Scholz wrote in a contribution to German daily Die Welt. Accordingly, the constitution must be changed.

    Asylum should no longer be a subjective legal claim, but must become an objective-legal regulation, Scholz, a former minister of Defence, says.

    This would be possible if the current wording “Politically persecuted persons enjoying asylum” in the Basic Law is amended to: “Politically persecuted persons are granted asylum in accordance with the law”. This was already suggested for example by the Free State of Bavaria.

    “Such a law would then be able to effectively differentiate the asylum law from all other immigration problems and thus also provide the basis for a meaningful and economically sustainable integration, including clear immigration limits,” said Scholz.

    The current regulation, however, is abused by hundreds of thousands each year. “If an asylum seeker is denied for lack of political persecution, he will increasingly call on the administrative courts,” the legal expert said. Over extended years of proceedings as a result of being a “tolerated refugee”, such an individual will still be able to stay in Germany.

    Scholz expressed sharp criticism over the asylum policy of the Federal Government. Even under the current legal situation, no one should apply for asylum in Germany who came to Germany from another EU country or from a safe third country.

    “The same goes for European law, that is the regulations of Dublin. However, both regulations have been disregarded by Germany since the autumn of 2015, above all because of the totally groundless and unconstitutional opening of the border.”

    The former minister also disagreed with Anton Hofreiter, chairman of the Greens about “safe” countries. According to Hofreiter: “A country is a safe country of origin if no human being is persecuted in this country and no group of people in that country.” In Morocco, homosexuality is punishable, and if homosexuality is punishable, one can assume that homosexuals are being persecuted, Hofraiter argued.

    But Scholz dismissed the notion, and said it is not unlawful to declare such a country as safe.

    “Not automatically, if homosexuals are discriminated against in some way or are not treated humanely, that alone is not enough.” A safe country of origin is, where political persecution does not take place, he said.

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    Europe

    Ukraine, a terror state?

    New leader of Donetsk People’s Republic: The former leader of Donetsk People’s Republic Alexander Zakharchenko was assasinated by Ukrainian Security Service.

    Luxemburg minister swears at Salvini as immigration summit turns ugly

    This past week the interior ministers of the member states of the European Union met in Vienna where Jean Asselborn, a member of the Socialist Workers’ Party, and Minister for European Affairs and Foreign Affairs in Luxembourg, inadvertently boosted conservatives.

    Dalai Lama in Sweden: ‘Europe belongs to Europeans’

    The Tibetan Buddhist leader Dalai Lamas message is that Europe belongs to Europeans and refugees should return to their home countries as soon as the danger is over. Swedish journalists quickly changed from celebrating the peace laureate to suggesting the old monk is ignorant.

    French conservatives question proposed Arabic teaching at schools

    French conservatives on Tuesday criticised the "revival of teaching of Arabic" in schools welcomed by Education Minister Jean-Michel Blanquer. 

    Dutch government faces legal trouble after aiding terrorists

    The "moderate" rebels in Syria were not moderate at all, the recent scandal in the Netherlands has demonstrated yet again. Faced with mounting legal problems, the Dutch government has been forced to cut loose the jihadists. At least one prosecutor seems to believe that the government committed a crime.

    Dutch government supported armed groups designated as terrorists

    The HagueThe Dutch government supported an armed group in Syria that has been labeled as a terrorist organisation by the country's own Public Prosecution Service.

    Anti-establishment sentiment grows in Sweden

    The establishment parties dropped in yesterday’s election in Sweden, but far from what would be expected from early polls. The Social Democrats and Conservatives remain the biggest parties, with anti establishment Sweden Democrats at third place, growing from 12.9 to 17.6 percent. However, the party could still play an decisive role, since the difference between the socialist and conservative block is one single seat.

    Marine Le Pen welcomes rise of Sweden Democrats

    Marine Le Pen, leader of the French National Rally - formerly known as the National Front - welcomed the rise of the Sweden Democrats.

    Swedish elections: Anti-immigration party set to be largest

    Today the Swedes are going to vote for a new parliament, as well as regional and local representatives. The anti-immigration party, the Sweden Democrats are expected to rise to the position of biggest party, while a completely new Alternative for Sweden has a chance to enter the parliament.

    Spain’s new Matteo Salvini?

    The new Italian government, under the leadership of Interior Minister Matteo Salvini, has managed to stop the flood of migrants crossing the Mediterranean to Italy. But now Spain is struggling. Who will lead Spain out of the quagmire?

    Go to archive