Skip to Content

South African media welcomed the prison sentence for Vicki Momberg. Photo: FreeWestMedia.

South Africa: Vicki Momberg sentenced to 3 years for using ‘K-word’

The Durban estate agent, Vicki Momberg, became the first person in South Africa to be sent to prison for using a racially offensive word, and not for an actual crime or any physical act.

Published: March 30, 2018, 8:14 am

    An estate agent from Durban, South Africa, was sentenced to 3 years imprisonment for calling a black policeman a “kaffir”, the equivalent of the American “nigger”. Vicki Momberg, who is white, had just been robbed by blacks in Johannesburg during a “smash-and-grab” incident in her vehicle when she refused to be assisted by black police officers, suggesting that they were incompetent and “useless”.

    One year of her prison sentence was suspended for three years, meaning that Momberg will serve two years for her “speech crime”. However, after being pronounced guilty of crimen injuria, an old-fashioned form of criminal libel in South Africa, Momberg was led to the court cells and spent her first night behind bars in Soweto’s notorious all-black prison for hardened criminals, nick-named “Sun City”, after the casino resort.

    Crimen injuria is a common-law crime in South Africa that is defined as “unlawfully, intentonally and seriously impairing the dignity of another”. Although it fell by the wayside in modern times, it has been used in recent years by South Africa’s ANC regime to persecute whites suspected of a “racist” attitude. But even harsher legislation is currently being instituted in the form of “The Prevention and combating of Hate Crime and Hate Speech Bill”. The new legislation will curtail freedom of speech even further and make it easier to prosecute whites rebelling against black authority.

    During her altercation with police while reporting the attack on her, Momberg used the word “kaffir” 48 times, according to court documents. A cellphone video of the incident was made and widely distributed on social media in the country.

    South Africa’s mainstream media were ecstatic in welcoming Momberg’s prison sentence. The Star newspaper in Johannesburg carried the headline “Victory over racism” (see picture above). Adriaan Basson, the editor of News24.com, the country’s largest online news portal, entitled his hit piece against Momberg, “Nowhere to hide for racists like Vicki Momberg anymore”. According to Basson, “It is the first time (that I am aware of) that someone will be imprisoned for using racist language in our country’s history.”

    A poll by the public broadcaster, the SABC, found that 57% of its TV viewers were in favour of a still harsher sentence of “more than five years’ imprisonment” for Vicki Momberg.

    South Africa’s main opposition party, the liberal DA (Democratic Alliance), welcomed the prison sentence, stating, “We trust this ruling will be a deterrent to those who harbour any racist sentiments.”

    However, another liberal-Marxist commentator, Rebecca Davis, expressed some concern over the chilling effect the sentence might have on freedom of speech in South Africa. Writing on The Daily Maverick website, she said:

    “It has been reported that the case is the first in South Africa in which a person found guilty only of crimen injuria has been sentenced to prison. Daily Maverick has been unable to confirm this, but it does appear to be the first racism case in which the offender will serve time behind bars for words rather than actions. The freedom of expression implications of this will need to be teased out by legal experts.”

    In June 2017, Momberg was fined R100 000 by the Equality Court, an amount she had to pay to the black policeman, Constable David Mkhondo, she had offended. However, proceedings in South Africa’s Equality Courts take place under civil, not criminal law, unlike the charge of crimen injuria.

    In effect, Momberg had to pay both civil damages and go to prison for using the word “kaffir”.

    Although the court was told that Momberg had previously refused to be served by black policemen in Durban more than a decade ago, she had never been convicted of an offence before. Legally, she was therefore a first offender, and would under normal conditions have qualified for a lighter, suspended sentence, a fine, or both.

    A South African lawyer, advocate Albert Murphy, characterised the sentence as “disproportionate”. In a tweet he said:

    “In my view the Momberg judgment is disproportionate and obviously politically inspired. What she did was wrong but certainly did not justify a prison sentence. White people are daily subjected to vile and murderous comments and songs from public platforms and no action is taken?”

    Momberg’s case contrasts vividly with that of Velaphi Khumalo, an ANC member and official of the provincial arts and culture department in the Gauteng Province. He wrote on his Facebook that “white people in South Africa deserve to be hacked and killed like Jews”.

    After a public outcry, Khumalo was finally charged by the Human Rights Commission with “hate speech”. Unlike Vicki Momberg who did not advocate the killing of anyone, but merely used an offensive word, Khumalo did in fact calling for white genocide. However, to date he has not only kept his job as a state or provincial official, but his “prosecution” by the Human Rights Commission has also been extremely protracted and without any visible result.

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    • Jandre Kroeze

      Maj. M.V. Mohlala of the South African National Defence Force’s
      (SANDF’s) Signal Formation at the Wonderboom Military Base in Pretoria gets away with it because he is a Bantu. https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/2f032a31fbcb0c17310bd2f9dcb867fa50980ef1fdfaf477b3c36a3f61a62681.jpg

    • Meanwhile, white farmers are killed by rampaging blacks, often aided by black police, members of EFF. God help her, they’re going to kill her. I would put a bullet in my brain, before going to an all-black prison.

      The fourth estate is a fifth column, enemy to whites everywhere. Hers is the fate of all whites, every Western nation, if we don’t rid ourselves of our third-worlders, and their traitorous, fifth column enablers.

    • Beatrice Sarlie

      This article is factually inaccurate.
      Suncity is not an all black prison for hardened criminals. There are different sections of the prison depending on the nature of the crime. There are many nonviolent offenders in the prison. It is also a multiracial prison. It is also not in Soweto. Soweto doesn’t have any prisons. Vicki Momberg threatened to kill the next black person she saw by running over them with her car. Any hate speech law would apply to all races. Rebelling against government does not need to be done in a racist way.

    Africa

    Polish activist Janusz Waluś’s parole hearing

    The long fight of anticommunist activist Janusz Waluś to free himself from a South African prison will continue in court today as he seeks again to be released on parole and deported to his country of birth, Poland.

    African Athletics Championship a complete disaster

    The African Athletics Championship held in Nigeria, has not turned into showing Africa’s sporting prowess to the world, but into an embarrassing fiasco.

    Crisis in multicultural Cape Town as trains go up in smoke

    Trains are regularly burnt in Cape Town by commuters, while City officials speak of "sabotage".

    South Africa: Military specialist speculates on German howitzer sighting

    The German Panzerhaubitze 2000 (or just PzH 2000) was spotted in South Africa recently. FWM interviewed a military specialist to speculate on the sighting of the howitzer.

    South Africa: Indian woman loses job for private text message with ‘k word’

    Alochna Moodley, a South African Indian has just lost her job as a result of sending a Whatsapp message to her fiancé in which she used the word 'kaffir', a South African slur for black people.

    South African Police Minister agrees to release farm murder stats

    PretoriaThe South African Minister of Police, Bheki Cele, and the Police Commissioner, General Khehla Sitole, indicated that they would once again release statistics on farm attacks and murders after eleven years of silence on the burning issue as international pressure builds.

    Jail sentence for satirical protest in South Africa?

    As freedom of speech in South Africa dies a slow death, protestors against the country's authoritarian government increasingly risk jail sentences for "showing disrespect".

    South Africa: Land occupation intensifies

    South African President Cyril Ramaphosa has received a donation of R858 million from the United Kingdom, while the country is increasingly struggling to attract foreign investment in a climate of investment insecurity and faltering economic growth after the ANC leader promised white land grabs.

    SA govt pension fund to bail out leftist media

    Massive turn-out for anti-genocide protest in Perth, Australia

    Native Australians and immigrant South Africans joined hands in protesting the killing of farmers and white genocide in South Africa on Sunday 8 April. A special report of the day was compiled by Free West Media.

    Go to archive