Skip to Content

IB rally in Halle. Twitter

Identitarians mark success in Cologne court

The decision of the Administrative Court of Cologne confirms the legal opinion of the Identitarian Movement Germany that there are no new points of view justifying the reclassification as "right-wing extremist".

Published: September 26, 2019, 11:47 am

    Read more

    Cologne

    The German domestic spy agency, known as the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution (BfV) had classified the Identitarian Movement (IB) as “right-wing extremist”.

    Already at this time it was clear that the upgrading of the former “suspected case” of so-called extremism was more politically and ideologically motivated and had little legal and argumentative substance.

    The mainstream media, however, did not care much about this salient fact and they took the opportunity to draw a distorted image of a supposedly extremist youth movement.

    Immediately after the decision, the IB filed an interim injunction before the Administrative Court of Cologne against the revaluation as “right-wing extremist”. Accordingly, it has forbidden the domestic spy agency to designate the Identitarian Movement as such until a firm decision.

    First and foremost, the court on Wednesday ruled that there was no valid reason why the Office for the Protection of the Constitution made this reassessment. The press release of the BfV also provided no new findings that would justify the classification as “certain right-wing extremist”.

    The IB lawyer in the proceedings, Gerhard Vierfuß commented as follows: “If such considerations does not exist – and did not exist – at the time the Constitutional Protection Report was drafted in 2018, they are not there. This means that the suspicion is confirmed that the reclassification by the BfV was done solely for political reasons. This is a worrying finding in a state that wants to be a constitutional state.”

    Now it is considered probable that the BfV will object to this decision within a two-week period.

    Nevertheless, this decision of the Administrative Court provides a firm base for the IB’s legal success prospects.

    The Cologne Administrative Court has thus prohibited the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution from calling the IB a group with “certain right-wing extremist aspiration”.

    In December 2018 and January 2019, the Ministry of the Interior had assured the Berlin Administrative Court that the Identity Movement in the context of right-wing extremism would only be mentioned as a “suspected case”, as long as the group was listed as such in the reports of the Office for the Protection of the Constitution.

    However, the domestic secret service called the IB in a press release of July this year as a group with “certain right-wing extremist aspirations against the liberal democratic basic order”. The judges interpreted this as a violation of the assurances of the ministry.

    The Communication of the Protection of the Constitution had violated the IB’s social rights to respect guaranteed by the general personality right as well as its fundamental right to free expression of opinion.

    IB boss Daniel Fiss told Berlin weekly Junge Freiheit: “For us it is clear that now it will go into the hot phase of legal confrontation with the Protection of the Constitution.”

    In this process, the Identitarian Movement is fighting “on a decision-making front that could point the way for all patriotic actors in this country”. He added: “Patriotic activism and youth work must continue to be legitimate.”

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    • LuciusAnnaeusSeneca

      ….. ‘the court on Wednesday ruled that there was no valid reason why the
      Office for the Protection of the Constitution made this reassessment.”

      There is certainly no valid reason, but a reason none the less: Late last year, Hans-Georg Maassen was replaced as head of the BfV by Thomas Haldenwang. Maassen, who had a reasoned, accurate view of the threat posed by radical leftists, Islamists, and leftist-globalist NGOs, was forced out by the leftist allies of the Merkel government, and replaced by an apparatchik who immediately set about trying to villify the AfD and anyone else right-of-center, while asking for a massive increase in resources to increase surveillance against them. Hence the legal action discussed here. It remains to be seem whether the BfV will back down, or take another course of action. The AfD still remains one of Merkel’s public enemies.

    Europe

    Nigerians terrorize Italian city

    PaduaThe Nigerian mafia has been busy in the Italian city of Padua. In less than 24 hours there were two violent episodes in the city center, and as always on via Diego Valeri.

    France: 41 percent ‘ignore’ news

    A survey carried out for a newspaper shows a growing distrust of the French towards the media.

    Gang rapes: Number of foreign suspects in Germany increasing

    BerlinThe proportion of foreign suspects in gang rapes in Germany has increased significantly in the past five years. This is despite the fact that the total number of suspects decreased between 2015 and 2017.

    Candidate recruits people of  ‘Turkish origin’ for French municipal elections

    Given the extent of the controversy, Mohamed Dine has now deleted his ad, previously posted on his Facebook page.

    Charlie Hebdo also defended pedophilia

    ParisLike part of the libertarian left at the time, the satirical newspaper supported three pedophile criminals, accused of having abused minors, before they were sentenced in 1977.

    Conservative German author’s reading cancelled in Dresden

    DresdenGerman author Uwe Tellkamp had his reading cancelled. It was not because of a lack of public interest, illness of the organiser or an important participant, or official orders for violations of the fire protection regulations. No, it had to be canceled because the author has a certain opinion.

    Pedophile personalities shake up French literary scene

    ParisThe French writer Gabriel Matzneff who has been accused by the novelist Vanessa Springora of pedophilia, benefits from low-cost housing in the heart of Paris which was allocated to him in 1994. Some other sordid facts about him and his friends have resurfaced.

    AfD sues German domestic spy agency over tracking

    BerlinThe AfD intends to take legal action against the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution, the domestic spy agency.

    Dispute over German broadcaster’s “environmental pig” song continues

    CologneSeveral editors from German public broadcaster WDR have accused director Tom Buhrow of harming the broadcaster with the so-called "environmental pig" affair. On Tuesday there will therefore be an editorial meeting in which Buhrow will also take part.

    Cars in flames all over France at the start of the New Year

    The car-burnings in France continue. There were burnt cars in Strasbourg, Bordeaux, Limoges, Nantes and other cities.

    Go to archive