Skip to Content

European Court to decide if Islamic Sharia Law can override Civil Law

Can Islamic religious sharia law override a European country's domestic law? The Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights is weighing that question as we write. Rulings handed down by the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights cannot be appealed.

Published: December 10, 2017, 1:34 pm

    Read more

    The Court is expected to issue its decision in the next few months.

    The Court heard a case this past week where sharia law was applied to a disagreement between citizens of Greece who are Muslims.

    Christian Concern (CC), a non-profit organisation based in London, intervened in the case, “because of the importance of the case in European law and its implications for countries across Europe, including the UK,” according to a press statement by CC.

    “We intervened in the case in order to make clear that sharia law is fundamentally incompatible with human rights,” Tim Dieppe, head of public policy of Christian Concern, declared on its website. “We hope and pray that the judges will see this and act accordingly.”

    Christian Concern say sharia law is “discriminatory” and its intervention in this case reveals the pitfalls facing the judiciary with sharia law applied in the UK.

    According to Dieppe, an estimated 85 sharia courts operate in the UK. “The use of Sharia has led to the promotion of parallel societies within the United Kingdom,” he told CBN News. “Sharia itself has disproportionately affected women and gives no legal rights to non-Muslims.”

    “The United Kingdom has also become the European hub for Islamic finance,” he added. “Any Grand Chamber ruling promoting the use of Sharia would only further give weight to the growing segregation of the Muslim community in England and its disassociation with democratic and British values.”

    The particular case in Greece, Molla Sali v. Greece, involved a dispute over an inheritance. After her husband died, Sali inherited his entire estate under his will written according to Greek law.

    But two sisters of the husband maintain that sharia law should govern how the inheritance is divided because the man was a member of the Muslim community in Thrace. Also, a mufti must oversee that process, they say. A mufti is regarded as a Muslim legal expert in religious law.

    “They relied in particular on the 1920 Treaty of Sèvres and the 1923 Treaty of Lausanne, which provided for Islamic customs and Islamic religious law to be applied to Greek nationals who were Muslims,” the European Court of Human Rights stated in a news release.

    “A ruling that sharia law should have precedence over the state’s civil law would set an alarming precedent for the Council of Europe’s 47 Member States, including the United Kingdom,” Dieppe responded. “By contrast, a ruling that civil law should overrule sharia law would have legal benefit throughout the Council of Europe.”

    “We are hoping that the Court continues its line of precedent that Sharia is incompatible with a democratic society,” he told CBN News. “However, if the Court were to rule that Sharia law should have been applied in Miss Molla Sali’s case, it would in essence be ruling that Sharia can enjoy legal supremacy over a nation’s domestic legislation even where the consent of all of the parties to its use in a matter is not present.”

    Meanwhile, the Greek prime minister announced a bill that would make applying sharia law in Thrace optional. The measure says civil law overrides sharia law, unless everyone involved agrees to abide by sharia law.

     

    Consider donating to support our work

    Help us to produce more articles like this. FreeWestMedia is depending on donations from our readers to keep going. With your help, we expose the mainstream fake news agenda.

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    • Andy C

      “Meanwhile, the Greek prime minister announced a bill that would make applying sharia law in Thrace optional. The measure says civil law overrides sharia law, unless everyone involved agrees to abide by sharia law.”
      Similar system in the UK. Shouldn’t be permitted.

    Europe

    Sweden: Immigrant child rapist commits 600 crimes – avoids deportation

    In May, the immigrant Bekim Dzelili was initially sentenced by the district court to 13 years in prison and deportation for life. He was found guilty of repeated aggravated child rape, the aggravated sexual abuse of a child, assault and unlawful threats. But the Swedish Court of Appeal has since reduced his prison sentence by one year and has canceled the deportation - the perpetrator may remain in Sweden because he has a "weak connection to his home country".

    Lampedusa: Landings intensify with migrants testing positive for Covid-19

    RomeImages of an illegal migrant landing that took place on 28 July on the most popular beach among shocked tourists and holiday makers, was broadcast by Italian CorriereTV. But the government is instead concerned about the politician who had tried to stop these illegal landings.

    Video: Sweden has knife violence, name changes, culture wars and a housing shortage

    Sweden used to be a 'model society'. But no more.

    German churches celebrate migrant crisis as a success

    MunichThe two large churches in Germany have drawn a positive interim assessment of the 2015 wave of migrants. Around half of those who came at the time are being trained or have jobs today, said the Council President of the Evangelical Church in Germany, Heinrich Bedford-Strohm.

    Erdogan and Islam: Religion as Trojan Horse for political influence in Germany

    IstanbulYesterday, the first official Islamic Friday prayer took place at the Hagia Sophia in Istanbul. The controversy of the re-conversion of the former Christian Orthodox cathedral into a mosque is also hotly being discussed in Europe.

    Swedish broadcaster TV4 edits interview to hide immigrant knife violence

    StockholmOn July 20, Swedish TV4 interviewed criminologist Tage Alalehto, who in the segment says that one explanation for the increased number of stabbings in the country could be "ethnic, xenophobic moods". But that was not really what he had said on camera.

    Will the death of Axelle Dorier in France ignite the identity powder keg?

    LyonSince the tragic death of the young French caregiver Axelle Dorier, ethnic tensions have redoubled in force on social networks.

    German Army infiltrated by Turkish agents?

    BerlinAccording to media reports, four Bundeswehr soldiers of Turkish origin are suspected of being members of the extremist Turkish organisation Grey Wolves. They are also suspected of collaborating with the Turkish secret service MIT.

    US State Department recruited and trained French race activists

    ParisThe United States began to reach out to ethnic and racial minorities in France with the blessing of the American embassy in Paris.

    Czech government supports constitutional right to armed self-defense

    PragueThe Czech government supports the constitutional right of citizens to arm themselves for self-defense. The proposed amendment aims to counter the disarmament drive of the European Union.

    Go to archive