Skip to Content

Moody's. Photo supplied

NY rating agency blackmails Italy: ‘If you vote for populist parties…’

"One aspect we monitor carefully is the spread of populism among the population in Europe. And also in Italy". This was announced by Kathrin Muehlbronner of the rating agency Moody's.

Published: February 15, 2020, 8:34 am


    In an interview with Il Sole 24 Ore, Kathrin Muehlbronner , senior vice president of Sovereign Risk at the New York rating agency Moody’s, said: “One aspect that we carefully monitor is the spread of populism among the population in Europe. And also in Italy. If the majority of citizens approach populist ideas or parties, obviously we cannot ignore it “.

    These are very significant words, if you think that it is Muehlbronner herself, together with her staff, that determines the rating of one country. What if parties that the agency classifies as “populists” eventually come to power? In that case, a rating cut would the obvious answer.

    This also suggests that Moody’s is less interested in the real underlying economic issues.

    Her warning is reminiscent of one pronounced in May 2018 by the then European Commissioner for the Budget, Gunther Oettinger (who was later forced to apologize) when he said that “the markets will teach Italians to vote in the right way”.

    It seems as if Moody’s is not aware that the definition of “populism” is so broad that it could take on various meanings and connotations. According to the political scientist Francis Fukuyama, for example, “populism is the label that elites put on policies that they don’t like but that have the support of citizens…”

    Currently, says Muehlbronner in the interview, “the BAA3 rating is adequate for a country like yours, which has strengths (a diversified economy and low-debt families for example) but also weaknesses (a high public debt and a structurally low growth) “.

    What could therefore push Moody’s to downgrade Italy? At least three issues noted by Muehlbronner: “One: the risks of a liquidity crisis in which the government has difficulty in refinancing the increased debt. Two: if fiscal policies capable of increasing public debt were launched. Three: an increase in the risk that Italy may exit the euro.”

    What could increase the rating of Italy instead? According to the Moody’s analyst, “structural reforms” would be good. Italy, explained Kathrin Muehlbronner, “needs reforms that increase the potential of the economy. A few positive quarters of GDP are certainly not enough to change the rating”.

    In October 2018 the agency cut Italy’s rating from BAA2 to BAA3 but with a stable outlook. The decision was linked to a “concrete change in the budgetary strategy, with a significantly higher deficit than expected” and this implied the continuation of “weak growth in the medium term”.

    Rating agencies were magically “calmed down” when the Italian Democratic Party returned to government, after the “turnaround” last August that brought the League back to the opposition.

    As for 2020, according to Moody’s, the estimate is a 0,5 percent growth in GDP . “We are convinced that Germany and Italy in 2019 suffered particularly from the contraction of the manufacturing sector, due to the uncertainty linked to the trade war between the US and China. This year we believe instead that the sector will recover, both in Germany and in Italy. Also because your country is very tied to German growth,” Muehlbronner pointed out to IlSole24Ore.

    In 2017, the agency’s top European analyst warned that France’s rating could be weakened if Marine Le Pen reached the second round of the presidential elections.

    Consider donating to support our work

    Help us to produce more articles like this. FreeWestMedia is depending on donations from our readers to keep going. With your help, we expose the mainstream fake news agenda.

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.


    Nine major European hospitals now require assistance

    "We will soon be short of important drugs" in the fight against the new Coronavirus, Europe's largest hospital warned in a letter to its respective governments.

    Spain announces highest daily increase in Covid-19 deaths

    MadridSpain's health ministry has announced 838 Covid-19 deaths, the country's highest daily increase in fatalities, bringing the total to 6 528.

    Putin bravely dons hazmat suit to visit Covid-19 patients in Moscow

    MoscowPresident Vladimir Putin donned a yellow hazmat suit to explain to the public the emergency measures taken by the Russian government.

    Italian infections on the rise again despite curfews

    RomeAfter a few days of decline, the number of new cases in Italy have increased again. Wednesday's rise in the number of dead were 683, while on Tuesday the rise was 743. The number of confirmed cases in the US has however surpassed China and Italy to become the largest outbreak in the world.

    How the East fights against the Coronavirus

    MoscowEurope currently appears to be drowning in chaos and dysfunction when it comes to the fight against the Coronavirus. But how is Russia handling the challenge right now?

    Italy faces new emergency as it runs out of disinfectants

    RomeIt will no longer be possible to disinfect hospitals, ambulances, public transport and schools. The League has urged the EU to step in. "The government and Europe must intervene as soon as possible."

    Immigrants revolt against confinement in France, Germany

    ParisWhile drastic containment measures came into effect on March 17 at noon in France, carelessness and incivility persist in the immigrant districts of Paris. The police dispatched on the spot are exasperated with the inhabitants.

    Famous virologist explains risky ‘logic’ of herd immunity

    A virologist twice nominated for the Nobel Prize explains the British strategy of "herd immunity" claiming it may have a logical explanation, but is still too risky.

    Italian specialist: Three diseases that invite risk faced with the Coronavirus

    RomeIt seems that there are no more doubts since the data are clear: The mortality from Covid-19 is higher "for hypertensive patients, patients with cardiac arrhythmias, diabetics and patients with cardiovascular diseases".

    Dutch research team first to discover Covid-19 antibodies

    RotterdamThe first drug capable of attacking and neutralizing the Coronavirus could be ready for experimentation after a group of Dutch researchers discovered an antibody.

    Go to archive