Skip to Content

Stock photo from Pixabay
Melbourne

Australian doctors denounce anti-hydroxychloroquine study as fake

Australian infectious disease researchers have raised the alarm about fake data in a study published in The Lancet denouncing the drug hydroxychloroquine in the treatment Covid-19. The Australian Department of Health has been stockpiling millions of doses of hydroxychloroquine.

Published: May 29, 2020, 11:01 am

    Read more

    The Lancet study prompted the World Health Organization to halt global trials on the drug even though it has been considered to be safe for decades already.

    Dr Allen Cheng, an epidemiologist and infectious disease in Melbourne, told Guardian Australia he has never heard of Surgisphere, and no one from his hospital, The Alfred, had provided Surgisphere with data for The Lancet. “If they got this wrong, what else could be wrong?” Cheng warned. Another “red flag” for Cheng is that the paper listed only four authors.

    He demanded that the Australian hospitals allegedly involved in the study be named.

    The study, led by the Brigham and Women’s Hospital Center for Advanced Heart Disease in Boston, in the US, examined patients in hospitals worldwide, including allegedly in Australia. It claimed that researchers had gained access to data from five hospitals recording 600 Australian Covid-19 patients and 73 Australian deaths as of 21 April.

    But data from Johns Hopkins University shows only 67 deaths from Covid-19 had been recorded in Australia by 21 April. The number did not rise to 73 until 23 April. The Lancet data is not readily available in Australian clinical databases either.

    Guardian Australia also contacted the health departments of Australia’s two most populous states, New South Wales and Victoria, both registering the highest number of Covid-19 cases. Of the Australian deaths reported by 21 April, 14 were in Victoria and 26 in NSW.

    The NSW Department of Health said it never provided Lancet researchers with the data from its databases, while Victoria’s department said the Lancet data did not reconcile with the state’s Coronavirus data, including hospital admissions and deaths.

    The Lancet responded to the claims of faked data provided by the lead author of the study, Dr Mandeep Mehra: “We have asked the authors for clarifications, we know that they are investigating urgently, and we await their reply.”

    In a statement, Surgisphere founder Dr Sapan Desai, also an author on the Lancet paper, claimed a hospital from Asia had accidentally been included in the Australian data.

    Spain will continue to use hydroxychloroquine against the Coronavirus despite the French ban and the WHO’s sudden doubts, Spanish daily El Paìs reported.

    The Spanish Agency for Medicines and Health Products (AEMPS) considers that the recent study published in The Lancet that warned about the risks of hydroxychloroquine does not provide conclusions “strong enough” to stop using this drug in Spain or stop research underway in hospitals.

    This position contrasts with that adopted by France, which has just banned the use of this drug to treat Covid-19, and the doubts of the World Health Organization (WHO), which has suspended all trials. In both cases, the decision was taken after the questionable study was published in The Lancet.

    Also, in the UK, the University of Edinburgh said it would continue their trial of the drug.

    In France, Nicolas Dupont-Aignan, the leader of Debout la France party, said the government’s ban on hydroxychloroquine goes against the right to an inexpensive and effective medicine.

    “This is a real state scandal”, said Dupont-Aignan. “The French government, because of stupidity or corruption, refuses French citizens treatment with hydroxychloroquine, which can save lives. And I think that the French will soon be outraged, because today this treatment is effective in many countries throughout the world”.

    He said pressure came from pharmaceutical labs and vaccine promoters looking to earn billions if other treatments are banned. “Professor Raoul and his treatment regimen is like a little pebble in the boot of large pharmaceutical labs”, the politician noted.

    Dupont-Aignan said Big Pharma influenced the decision taken by the WHO after The Lancet faked the data. “The WHO is influenced by pharmaceutical labs; it has lost credibility. The Lancet published a study – fabricated, not true – whose authors want to convince [people] that prescribing chloroquine is dangerous, that it is cardiotoxic… And we can clearly see the shadow of laboratories that want to sell us more expensive drugs or a hypothetical vaccine behind this fight against chloroquine, an inexpensive (almost free) medicine that could save hundreds of thousands of lives”.

    According to him, the danger is that the French government “seeks to impose official medicine”. He added: “For over 70 years, chloroquine has been on the open market in our country. This is not a new drug. It has no contra-indications. It just needs to be prescribed reasonably, and that is what doctors should do.”

    Consider donating to support our work

    Help us to produce more articles like this. FreeWestMedia is depending on donations from our readers to keep going. With your help, we expose the mainstream fake news agenda.

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    • pcl

      The worst thing about these attempts to discredit HydroxyChloroqine is that most of them don’t include zinc in the treatment. The drug has proven far more effective with zinc than without, so any “study” which excludes it is probably an intentional hit job.

      • It`s an ionophore for gods sake, without zinc it`s effect is limited, they know this, all these study`s are designed to discredit the drug, ALL flu type viruses are ph sensitive ALL of them, they need an acid ph to replicate, zinc alkalises the cell, stops virus replication and it dies. HCQ with zinc sulphate has to be provided at the earliest possible time. All these study`s leave zinc out, most provide the drug late in the illness and to the most ill patients. All these study`s are fraud, especially those linked to OXFORD
        UNIVERSITY. There is NO need for flu vaccines that`s what is at stake here, most of the time they don`t work, never take them and I am knocking on 80.

    ‘Shugaley’: In the hands of Islamist terrorists

    The Coronavirus pandemic has not been not an obstacle for the release of a new Russian movie about Libyan war, available online from April.

    Roger Scruton’s friend: ‘He gave us hope’

    Conservative philosopher Roger Scruton is dead. He died on January 12 of cancer. Scruton was honoured in 2016, but last year was subjected to a brutal smear campaign by the mainstream media and was at the end of his life persona non grata among the establishment. When death was imminent, Scruton told him that he had been deprived of both health and reputation, but expressed no resentment, only gratitude for all the positive things he had been involved in. The Swedish news outlet Nya Tider has spoke to Scruton's friend Gregory Lauder-Frost from the Traditional Britain Group.

    Merry Christmas to all our readers!

    The editorial staff of FreeWestMedia wishes you a blessed Christmas and a happy New Year! We thank you for the loyalty you have shown us throughout the year and for your support.

    Australia creates fake horoscopes to deter Sri Lankan migrants

    CanberraFor two years, Australian authorities have been broadcasting horoscopes with harmful predictions to dissuade potential migrants from carrying out their project.

    Will the Yellow Vests conquer the municipal elections?

    In the run-up to the 2020 municipal elections, the Yellow Vests intend to weigh in by loudly claiming their demands at a local level. And they will do so without necessarily presenting a list.

    Six out of 10 foreign-trained NHS doctors linked to sexual misconduct

    LondonShocking new figures from the UK's National Health Service (NHS) revealed that foreign-trained doctors commit six in ten cases of sexual misconduct with patients, even though they make up only a third of the NHS staff.

    Act XXXII: Yellow Vests return to their original strategy

    For Act XXXII of their mobilization, the Yellow Vests have chosen to return to their original strategy: blockages paralyzing the economy and targeted actions. The move could succeed in reigniting the movement.

    Security protection units for French ministers ‘exhausted’

    ParisOf the 61 French gendarmes who were charged on Thursday to escort two French high officials, 48 were off work.

    Large percentage of migrants condone violence against AfD

    A large percentage of migrants have expressed consent for violence used against the German anti-immigration party, the AfD.

    Russia to become 5th largest economy overtaking Germany

    The Russian economy has clearly weathered sanctions better than some Western politicians imagined. Despite years of international pressure and low oil prices, Russia will overtake Germany as the world's fifth largest economy.

    Go to archive