Skip to Content

Stock photo from Pexels

Lawsuit against Google’s facial recognition dismissed

A lawsuit against Internet giant Google, which has been pending since 2016, was rejected by a US federal judge. As a result, Google may continue to use its face recognition technology.

Published: January 3, 2019, 9:07 am

    Read more

    The ruling could also have an impact on other companies like Facebook.

    A US federal judge has dismissed a lawsuit against Google, which accused the technology company that its face recognition technology was violating users’ privacy rights. But because the case was dismissed, Google may continue to scan and save biometric data.

    The lawsuit, filed in 2016, found that Google violated the law of the state of Illinois by collecting biometric data without the consent of those affected, America’s toughest biometric privacy law. The data is obtained from images stored on Google Photos.

    The plaintiffs sought more than $5 million in compensation for “hundreds of thousands” of affected users and argued that unauthorized scanning of their faces was a violation of the Illinois Biometric Information Privacy Act(BIPA), which prohibits the collection of biometric data without consent.

    Google disputed the allegation and stated that the plaintiffs were not entitled to compensation because they had not been harmed by the data collection. On Saturday, US Federal Judge Edmond E Chang sided with the tech giant and ruled that the plaintiffs had not incurred any “tangible damage” and dismissed the lawsuit as a result.

    Not only will the ruling allow Google to continue the practice, but it could also affect other pending case against Facebook and Snapchat. Both companies are also currently facing trials for the alleged violation of the Illinois Law.

    Google has lobbied hard against BIPA, but the incoming Illinois Attorney General has vowed to resist attempts to weaken the privacy legislation.

    In the midst of increasing resistance from privacy activists, biometric scanning has become more and more ubiquitous in recent years. The technology has been used at US airports and by the British police – though it is unreliable and unregulated in most countries.

    Face recognition can be used to identify faces in crowds using CCTV footage, track the movements of people on public transport networks, and search public places for wanted criminals.

    It is not yet clear if the dismissal will be appealed, but with the Supreme Court decision on the same question of interpretation pending, it seems likely.

    State courts have previously found that an “injury in-fact” was necessary to establish harm in BIPA suits, but in a separate case have also found that damage to plaintiffs’ “property interest” is sufficient to establish harm.

    Alongside Facebook, companies like Epsilon, Equifax and Experian are even more intrusive and actually sell the data of users.

    Facebook is also facing a lawsuit because of its photo tagging feature. Currently, users will be asked if they want to tag the person in a photo because Facebook stores biometric data to identify people is in a given photo. The lawsuit alleges that this violates the privacy act because users do not give permission for their faceprint to be stored by Facebook.

    In April, a judge ruled against a motion by Facebook to dismiss the case brought against it. The tech company, which experienced a rocky 2018 to say the least, faces a class action lawsuit for its tagging technology which allegedly violates the privacy law.

    Companies like Facebook and Google are dangerous due to the power they wield over society, and it now appears that privacy laws won’t suffice to make them accountable.

    In Ireland, facial recognition technology has been used in a less Orwellian manner in tracking and monitoring the movements of dairy cows.

    Consider donating to support our work

    Help us to produce more articles like this. FreeWestMedia is depending on donations from our readers to keep going. With your help, we expose the mainstream fake news agenda.

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    Americas

    International support for Russian isolation dwindles

    New YorkWhile Western politicians are still cultivating the notion of Russia's foreign policy "isolation" after the start of the Russian military operation in Ukraine, a glance at the map shows that not even a quarter of the countries of the world have been following along obediently.

    US oil dynasties fund climate activists

    According to a media report, the heirs to three US oil dynasties finance climate activists and non-governmental organizations that promote climate protest actions. Descendants of oil barons Getty and Rockefeller allegedly feel responsible for preventing "eradication" on Earth. That may not be the real reason however.

    Soros pushes left-wing reforms for US judiciary

    WashingtonIn the run-up to the US midterms elections, the big speculator and "philanthropist" George Soros has found a new field of activity. He now excels at funding American prosecutors who want to "reform" the US justice system. Republican politicians and lawyers are outraged. They blame Soros for the increase in violence in the country.

    US Army to dismiss scores of unvaccinated soldiers

    WashingtonAlmost a quarter of the US army that has not yet received the second vaccine will be facing dismissal. President Joe Biden is ready to purge those in the military who have not received their second jab.

    US Army mired in recruitment crisis

    Washington"Woke" culture and sex change operations in the US military have done it no favours. In fact, in the spirit of Bertolt Brecht: "Imagine it's war and nobody goes there!"

    Biden selling US strategic oil reserves to Chinese company linked to his son

    WashingtonIn the United States, an energy crisis looms with record high fuel prices and inflation at its highest level in 40 years. Yet the Biden family plans to make a huge profit from it.

    Buying farmland: Bill Gates is ‘not welcome’ in North Dakota

    BismarckThe billionaire is considered the largest owner of farmland in the United States. This puts him in a "unique position to harm conventional agriculture," according to a Spanish newspaper. Resistance is therefore growing in North Dakota.

    Former US NATO policy planner urges Ukraine to cut a deal

    WashingtonThere has been a recent rise in voices in the US advising a negotiated settlement to the Ukraine war – positioning themselves against the Kiev government, which is clinging to continued fighting despite mounting casualties.

    Genetics: Scientists wanted friendly hamsters but made them much more aggressive

    AtlantaGeneticists admitted that they had been "really surprised" after a gene-editing experiment with the CRISPR/Cas9 technique went horribly wrong. They had instead turned the hamsters they had been injecting with their potion into hyper-aggressive monsters.

    Runner dies after Brooklyn marathon, 15 others hospitalized

    New YorkA runner died on Saturday morning after completing the Brooklyn Half Marathon, authorities said. The 30-year-old man possibly went into cardiac arrest around 9 am local time and was taken to hospital, where he was pronounced dead.

    Go to archive