Skip to Content

Stock photo from Unsplash
Berlin

How inefficient is German wind power?

Germany has focused entirely on renewable energies and is promoting wind turbines throughout the country. However, the operators do not reveal how high the utilisation of their turbines actually are. It has now been calculated and the result has led to a depressing conclusion.

Published: November 14, 2022, 7:36 am

    Read more

    Some 28 000 larger wind turbines are in operation in Germany and no one knows how many of them are profitable. Germany’s wind farm operators hide the data “like a state secret”, reported the NZZ. Therefore, the Swiss daily examined and calculated the utilisation with the help of a simulation for 18 000 of these plants. To do this, it “evaluated hourly weather data over a period of ten years”.

    The result is sobering, in some cases even shocking.

    Wind power can only survive with subsidies

    Without a certain capacity utilisation, a turbine is not economically viable. According to the head of the Stuttgart Chair of Wind Energy, Po Wen Cheng, this requires a utilisation rate of about 30 percent. According to research by the NZZ, just 15 percent of the turbines have a utilisation rate of more than 30 percent. If one also takes into account that wind turbines are often shut down due to noise and environmental protection regulations, the percentage is probably even lower.

    In just under a quarter of the wind turbines studied, the capacity is less than 20 percent. “Such plants are only viable thanks to the German subsidy system, which also rewards poor locations.” On average in Germany, the capacity utilisation of wind turbines is just 24 per cent.

    There is no wind where industries are

    The situation becomes even more alarming when one considers how the wind turbines are distributed geographically. Most electricity is needed where German industry is located. The problem is that the wind is not oriented towards the locations of industry. It blows mainly in the north, which is why the majority – 83 percent – of the wind turbines that are well utilised are located there.

    However, industry is mainly located in the Ruhr area and in the southernmost federal states – Bavaria and Baden-Württemberg. The electricity gap is also greatest in these regions. But the south in particular has very little wind, which is why the poorly utilised wind turbines are primarily located there. While in Schleswig-Holstein, Germany’s most northerly federal state, the utilisation of wind turbines averages 31 percent, in the wind-poor Baden-Württenberg it is only 17 percent.

    That is why huge power lines are now being built to transport the electricity to where it is actually needed, reported the NZZ.

    Investors are not interested

    This does not bode well for the future, and it does not bode well for Germany’s energy policy. By the end of 2023, all federal states are to reserve two percent of their land for wind power – despite these enormous differences. The NZZ doubted that investors would be found for this. Especially in the south, where electricity is needed most urgently, hardly anyone wants to invest which is not surprising.

    Germany as a business location is currently hitting the wall at full throttle, as all new figures reveal almost daily. A single current figure makes it clear how far Europe’s economic engine has already fallen far behind: one single US state (out of a total of 50) has meanwhile overtaken Germany. According to the Pleitticker.de portal, California now has a larger GDP than Germany.

    Taking into account the latest growth numbers, California currently already has a lead of $72 billion over Germany. However, the figures for 2022 will not be published until next year.

    In 2021, Germany’s gross domestic product lead ($4.22 trillion, compared to California’s at $3.357 trillion) was reported to have been the smallest in history – and even that marginal difference has since melted away, if current numbers are to be believed. “If California were a sovereign state, it would overtake Germany as the fourth largest economy in the world,” commented the portal. With around 39 million inhabitants, California has less than half the population of Germany.

    Consider donating to support our work

    Help us to produce more articles like this. FreeWestMedia is depending on donations from our readers to keep going. With your help, we expose the mainstream fake news agenda.

    Keep ​your language polite​. Readers from many different countries visit and contribute to Free West Media and we must therefore obey the rules in​,​ for example​, ​Germany. Illegal content will be deleted.

    If you have been approved to post comments without preview from FWM, you are responsible for violation​s​ of​ any​ law. This means that FWM may be forced to cooperate with authorities in a possible crime investigation.

    If your comments are subject to preview ​by FWM, please be patient. We continually review comments but depending on the time of day it can take up to several hours before your comment is reviewed.

    We reserve the right to del​ete​ comments that are offensive, contain slander or foul language, or are irrelevant to the discussion.

    Europe

    Number of passengers doubled in 2022 despite doomsday predictions

    BerlinSomething doesn't add up. While climate activists are warning us about the end of the world, the number of passengers doubled in 2022. In other words: A massively growing number of people are using the air's "dirty" transport and are responsible for copious amounts of CO2 emissions.

    French unions announce more marches after Tuesday’s success

    ParisFollowing the second day of mass mobilisation against the Macron administration's pension reform, the unions have announced new social movements on 7 and 11 February.

    Orban: ‘The current political system in Europe will collapse’

    BudapestIn an interview with the Austrian daily eXXpress, Viktor Orban, Hungary's Prime Minister said he was convinced that the current political system in Europe would collapse within this decade.

    German FM ‘accidentally’ declares war on Russia, riles Africa

    StrasbourgThe “accidental” declaration of war on Russia by German Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock (Green Party) has stirred up the political classes. Moscow sees evidence that the EU states are "direct warring parties" and the Kremlin has demanded an explanation.

    Hungarian opposition: More illegal US funds than previously known

    BudapestThe result of parliamentary elections in Hungary in April 2022 has been the bane of the opposition. The defeated movement around Péter Márki-Zay received illegal funds from the US on a larger scale than previously thought, according to a recently declassified intel report. Most media outlets have been silent about it.

    WHO introduces a global patient file

    GenevaThe WHO has introduced a global patient file with the vaccinated and unvaccinated to be codified in future.

    Macron deputy consumes cocaine but justice system closes investigation

    ParisAn investigation by Médiapart revealed that the Renaissance deputy of Hauts-de-Seine Emmanuel Pellerin used cocaine, before as well as after his election.

    Sweden’s NATO membership bid goes up in smoke

    StockholmAfter the burning of the Quran in Stockholm, Turkey has no intention of allowing Sweden to join NATO. Sweden's Prime Minister, on the other hand, pointed to the importance of freedom of expression. The NATO Secretary General also spoke up on the matter.

    Internal EU report: Asylum applications has increased by half except in Hungary

    BerlinThe asylum disaster continues unabated in 2023. According to a confidential "Status Report on Migration and Refugees" by the EU Commission dated January 11, the number of asylum applications in the EU rose by around half in the past year to well over 900 000.

    French pension reform: 150 000 young demonstrators according to organisers

    ParisSome 150 000 students marched in Paris on January 21 against pension reform, according to the youth organisations that initiated the demonstration, but only 14 000 according to sources close to the Macron administration.

    Go to archive